Jeremy Bentham, writing to his brother in 1776, says of his anonymously published Fragment on Government, containing fierce criticism of the first volume of Blackstone's Commentaries on the Laws of England (1765) ‘the poor Fragment is every body's but mine. Johnson (Dictionary Johnson) has read it and commends it much’. Johnson, who went up to Pembroke, Oxford, some ten years before Blackstone, is a lurking figure in any account of law and letters of the eighteenth century, though despite the work of McAdam, McNair and Curley the extent of Johnson's involvement in, and knowledge of, the law is still generally underestimated. It is not evident that Blackstone and Johnson ever met, but they had a close mutual acquaintance in Robert Chambers, Vinerian fellow under Blackstone and his successor in the chair and whose own Vinerian lectures owed a lot to Johnson.
Johnson is, of course, the quintessential eighteenth-century man of letters: journalist, poet, critic, novelist, biographer and dictionary-maker. Blackstone is evidently a man of law: whether to critic or hagiographer his Commentaries encapsulate, for good or ill, the eighteenth-century common law. But to those who have not been following Professor Prest's published elaborations on his subject over the years, it may be a surprise to see Blackstone hailed as a man of letters. True, he was a poet, though one who was not published under his own name in his lifetime. His own earliest composition was in verse, a schoolboy's marriage gift to his headmaster, and is given here in an appendix. He appears to have had a gift for architectural criticism – sometimes expressed in verse as in the anonymously published Pantheon: A Vision of 1747. As Bursar of All Souls he was able to engage his interest in the practical development of the North Quadrangle containing the Codrington Library and the gothick towers of the Wharton Building. One area, beloved of other academic lawyers, in which he made a small contribution was Shakespearean studies: his are the legal notes in Malone's edition. But it is not believable that without his published lectures Blackstone would have left any significant mark in the larger world outside the law. His service as Assessor, in effect judge, of the Vice-Chancellor's court in Oxford was juridically insignificant. Even as a judge in the common law courts from 1770–1780 his contribution was limited: as counsel it had been virtually non-existent. His best-known judgment, in Scott v. Shepherd,Footnote 1 the squib case, was a dissenting one dismissing the plaintiff's action: it had to await subsequent developments to be accepted as a correct statement of the law. His judicial advice for the House of Lords in the important copyright case Donaldson v. Becket Footnote 2 was again in the minority.
As a politician, whether on the academic or national stage, his effects were marginal, except in one particular. He failed to gain the Oxford chancellorship election of 1762 for his candidate the Earl of Suffolk. But more successful, and indeed critical, were his interventions in the affairs of Oxford's university press. He was nominated a delegate by the proctors, contrary to the prevailing custom of leaving such nominations in the gift of the Vice Chancellor. On election he proved an active member, not least by contrast to the other delegates who were all Heads of Houses, producing a detailed memorandum on the workings of the press in 1756. The claim is plausibly made that not only the present day Oxford University Press but the worldwide modern success of university publishing owes its being to him. But perhaps Blackstone's main surviving public memorial, albeit one of dubious credit, is to be found in Swinford bridge at Eynsham to the west of Oxford which, thanks to his parliamentary drafting of a clause exempting the profits from taxation, remains one of the few road bridges in private hands. Despite charging only five pence per car, this profitable business was sold for over a million pounds in 2009.
In the end though, Blackstone's merits and reputation stand or fall by the worth of the Commentaries. In his own lifetime they were an undoubted commercial success. The contemporary account of his earnings by his literary executor James Clitherow, reproduced here, shows that in the years 1765–1769 he earned well over £6,000 in sales. The sum of £2,000, which he received for the copyright in 1772, though unprecedented, was probably an underestimate of its value given the sums which continued to be generated by sales.
The written style of the Commentaries was universally admired (so, with the sole exception of the fractious Bentham, was his oral delivery). Edward Gibbon, with little liking for law or lawyers, recognised its clarity, whilst William Jones, the oriental legal scholar, thought him ‘one of the best writers in our language’. No doubt but that it was the attractiveness of the writing as well as the clarity of the legal analysis which contributed to the long survival of Blackstone as a student text on both sides of the Atlantic. The Commentaries were based very closely upon the text of his undergraduate lectures: this is evident from the comparison with the several examples of student notes of the lectures which have survived. (It is interesting to note that prior to the publication of the Commentaries these manuscript notes were themselves lent to and copied by others.) Moreover Blackstone himself responded to criticism by admitting that parts of the published text had been composed some years before. The Commentaries are therefore, above all, a memorial to and a triumph of legal education.
This was very much Blackstone's intention. The details of his involvement in university and college politics are of very limited general interest, even when that college is as iconic as All Souls. But interspersed with his maintenance of the college cellar and electioneering for the university's seats in the Commons, Blackstone was clearly committed to the task of improving the standards of education, and above all legal education, in the university. Almost anywhere else this would have seemed exotic, even quixotic. Education for the practice of English law had been based in London for more than five hundred years. All Souls had been founded to support, inter alia, the teaching of civil and canon law. The study of canon law had ceased at the Reformation. Although Henry VIII had taken the opportunity to create Regius chairs of civil (Roman) law at both Oxford and Cambridge to ensure a continued tradition of the learned law relevant to the practice of the ecclesiastical and admiralty courts, by the middle of eighteenth century the study of civil law had fallen into a low state. The Regius professor in Blackstone's day was a non-entity, and a later holder of the office, Phillimore, admitted to the 1846 Select Committee on legal education that neither he nor his predecessors had actually taught for a century.
Blackstone had himself chosen to enrol as a candidate for the BCL before first obtaining his BA, a course generally followed only by those of lesser abilities anxious to obtain a bachelor's degree but not too concerned about the extended period of study required (seven years instead of three). As he did not fall into this category, having been a child prodigy and at the top of the whole school at Charterhouse at the age of fifteen, Blackstone's choice requires explanation. Prest points to the relative freedom of study which this option furnished. His admission a year later in 1741 to the Middle Temple was not necessarily a mark of commitment to the law. More significant are the records of his visits to the University Library, starting in February 1743, and his election to a fellowship at All Souls the following November. His consultation of the Bodleian's 1567 edition of Justinian's Codex in September 1743, although we do not know his purpose, indicates an interest in the history of Roman law going well beyond the scope of his undergraduate study. In the end we can say little more than that modern expectations of the course of university study are not sure guides to understanding the career trajectories of eighteenth-century students. But at some point he began to envisage himself as a teacher of English law, a course which was only consolidated and not initiated by Viner's foundation of the chair with which he is now associated.
Wilfrid Prest's intellectual biography presents us with a more rounded and, it must be admitted, more attractive, figure than hitherto imagined, and to this extent his exploration of the byways of Blackstone's career is very valuable. Whether in the end Blackstone's achievements and interests in poetry, architecture and Shakespeare criticism add anything to his significance for the development of the common law and legal education may be doubted. The best way to get to the heart of Blackstone remains a critical reading of the Commentaries. To that extent Prest's work enhances but does not fundamentally alter our understanding of one of the common law's greatest expositors.
