This book showcases papers presented at a conference in Amsterdam in March 2007 on pension finance. Background material covers trends in population ageing and the shift to funding; the need to cope with the financial implications of massive pre-funding, both for markets and supervisors; and the value of enhanced financial education in the light of the transfer of risks to employees in defined contribution plans. Fortunately, these challenges have combined with a better understanding of issues in pension finance and how pension systems work, with this new material amply highlighted in this volume. The authors include many long-established experts in the pension field.
To review some chapter highlights, Exley argues that the source of value added in corporate pension provision is unclear using standard principles of economic valuation. Furthermore, he argues that the type of implicit options typical of real world funds may induce misalignment of interests of shareholders and beneficiaries. Nevertheless, the author omits discussion of key benefits of pension funds such as enabling intergenerational risk sharing, reducing taxes, and avoiding poor investment decisionmaking by individuals. The chapter by Gold maintains that pension analysis has been wrongly set in the context of portfolio choice rather than enterprise risk management. Given the tax asymmetry between pension funds and other investors, the latter approach would recommend hedging to reduce the variation of project outcomes. Accordingly, rather than holding long equities, pension funds should have net negative market exposures. The current market turmoil and increasingly poor long-term returns on equities give additional resonance to this conclusion. Yet the result appears to depend on the assumption that firms cannot default and individuals will take equity risk in the rest of their portfolios, neither of which are empirically plausible.
The work of Maurer, Mitchell, and Rogalla offers a practical study of how a German public sector entity might approach funding the accruing benefits of its public employees, thus limiting future pay-as-you-go liabilities. The authors find that an appropriate strategy is a contribution rate of 19% and a 30–70 split of equities and bonds; also optimal flexibility is obtained if both contributions and portfolios are adjustable by the pension fund manager. While they do not use a stochastic discount rate, such an exercise is of considerable interest given the volume of unfunded state employee pension liabilities in OECD countries. The chapter by Boersch-Supan, Duzgun and Weiss analyzes the productivity of older workers, a crucial aspect of the economic impact of population ageing. The authors find that older workers have lower productivity in a major manufacturing plant, but offset it with gains from experience. Nevertheless, it can be questioned whether these benefits apply in the service sector, where the need for techological skills can disadvantage the elderly.
In a chapter analyzing flaws in UK personal defined contribution funds, Blake highlights the very high fees which can absorb up to 50% of the return; these are also very difficult to evaluate. There are also problems of poor investment performance and high lapse rates. The author shows that these plans are not managed or designed in a consistent way, with decisions regarding sales, portfolio management, and annuity provision handled by managers and salespeople with very different incentives. Blake contends that pension plans must better be designed as an integrated financial product. The work by Brunner, Hinz, and Rocha analyzes the new risk-based regulatory systems being introduced in Denmark, the Netherlands, Australia, and Mexico. The focus is on sound risk management and, for DB plans, adequate capital, particularly in the wake of difficulties incurred in the bear market of 2002–4. It will be interesting to review how these systems have coped with the even more adverse market conditions experienced since 2007. The risk-based systems are most readily applicable to DB rather than DC plans, but there is some danger of simply imposing insurance-type solvency standards to pensions, including procyclicality of the financial system.
In his analysis, Ambachtsheer suggests that value creation by pension plans depends on alignment of financial interests of managers and beneficiaries, quality of governance and design, and economies of scale. He offers some empirical evidence confirming that returns depend on the managerial focus on key governance indicators. It would be useful to note additionally that contestability of the market for pension manager services could also help drive successful outcomes. The chapter by Bodie observes that there is a need not only for good returns but also for pension guarantees in the DC context, since these will help retirement planning by being more comprehensible and thereby reduce the need for financial education. These might be implemented by offering a principal guarantee as is the case for certain German funded plans. Appropriate funding, matching, and transparency are essential counterparts, as are government issuance of longevity bonds and international risk sharing via swaps. By contrast, Bovenberg argues that standalone collective pension schemes such as the Dutch industry schemes are an attractive way to recharacterize pay as you go and conventional DC plans. His model entails a flexible DC pension for the young but which convert to DB for the old, to offset changing levels of human capital over the life cycle.
To close the volume, Papademos outlines the projected macroeconomic impacts of aging such as lowering economic growth and possibly lower long-term interest rates. The author also notes that aging may affect the monetary transmission process, while the lack of transparency in distribution of risk by institutional investors could have an impact on financial stability.
The chapters in this volume were written in the days of “innocence,” before the global financial crisis began in August of 2007. Were the work to be updated, the authors would surely focus more on challenges to pension finance posed by financial instability, including the search for yield in a low interest environment. Some of these were apparent in the run-up to the crisis (Davis Reference Davis, Herrmann and Auerbach2002).
