No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
This volume brings together contributions that explore rural development in parts of the Middle East, the former Soviet Union, and the Mediterranean basin. The wide geographic scope of the volume is matched by an equally broad thematic focus: the chapters cover urban–rural relationships and population movements; describe tensions between traditional strategies for resource use and agro-industrial practices; and engage debates about individual land-holding size. Problems of post-colonial change (including change in post–Soviet states) and tensions between global integration and self-sufficiency are recurrent themes throughout the book. However, much of the thematic focus of the volume is roughly bifurcated along geo-political boundaries: rural development in the Middle East is framed in terms of resource scarcity and conflict, while the chapters on Eurasian states center primarily on land reform and demographic change.
A number of the chapters directly or indirectly engage the tension between boilerplate modernization projects and contextually appropriate policy. Michael Bonine's chapter on development and sustainability in the Middle East develops this theme. In some cases, this theme could be further developed by reference to the now substantial literature critical of universalizing approaches to modernization and development policy. Paul Kaldjian argues in his chapter on smallholders in Turkish agriculture that, because of substantial urban–rural linkages, modernization through agro-industrial consolidation will have a strong negative effect on urban as well as agricultural workers. Here, land fragmentation acts as a hedge against hazard, where the ordinary constraints of agricultural production combine with unstable employment in urban areas to militate toward the preservation of small farms. A similar phenomenon is apparent in Russia, where Stephen Wegren and Gregory Ioffe both suggest that household production on small, privately owned plots has helped generate social-political as well as economic stability in the post–Soviet countryside.
Several chapters focus on the implications of population movement and change for land reform. Ioffe points to an important caveat in studying this problem: statistical measures, interpreted without sufficient reference to the context in which they are produced, can mislead. Ioffe convincingly argues that a taxononomical shift explains a substantial portion of the apparent movement toward rural in-migration in Russia during the early 1990s. As people left rural areas, their depopulated settlements were reclassified: townships officially became villages, and urban residents became rural people. In other words, statistical trends indicated the reverse of actual demographic change.
The chapters focusing on environmental constraints emphasize the relationship between agro-industrial development and increasingly limited pools of natural resources. Colonial legacies in the Middle East, together with urbanization and population growth, have led to continuing intensification of resource use amid the deterioration or destruction of traditional models of irrigation (such as qanat systems) and crop rotation. The authors suggest a variety of remedies—ranging from crop substitution to population control—for the problem of unsustainable cultivation practices. All describe or advocate greater intervention by state institutions in resolving problems of sustainability. Philip Micklin's chapter on resource conflict in the Aral Sea basin emphasizes the importance of transnational strategies for conservation.
The main weakness of this book lies in the frequent confusion of authorial focus with case-level specificity. For example, the Introduction notes that peasant farms in Uzbekistan rely on former collective and state farms for inputs and services. This happens to be true in most Eurasian states, including Russia, but the non-specialist reader could be forgiven for interpreting that fact as a peculiarity of the Uzbek rural economy. The failure to distinguish adequately between structural conditions common to Eurasian institutional settings and issues specific to individual states or regions obscures causal patterns as well as certain legacies of Soviet development across Eurasia. As a result, some readers may reach general conclusions about the relationship of reform, resource use, and development that might not be supported by a broader evidentiary base. For this reason, the book would have benefited from more explicit comparison of reform and demographic processes across states.
This problem continues elsewhere in the book. Readers who lack specialized knowledge of individual cases occasionally may have difficulty interpreting the conclusions authors reach. Renee Giovarelli's chapter on land reform in the Kyrgyz Republic describes the October 1998 referendum as having been “held to introduce the concept of private ownership of land to the constitution in the hopes that such a constitutional amendment would provide the impetus for much-needed land legislation”. The author notes that the referendum “passed by a large majority.” The reader is thus left with the impression that land reform in the Kyrgyz Republic may not have faced the same public or political opposition that it did in Russia and other Eurasian states. What Giovarelli does not mention is that the referendum in question was an omnibus package. The package included among its multiple provisions a clause on the protection of press freedom (see the Draft Law of the Kyrgyz Republic “On amending and supplementing the Constitution of the Kyrgyz Republic”). For Kyrgyz citizens to have registered opposition to private land ownership, they would also have had to vote to allow limitations on freedom of expression. At best, we cannot draw firm conclusions about political support for land reform from the results of this referendum.
The editors of this volume took on a complex and exceedingly difficult task. Creating a coherent whole would have required the editors to be as expert in each of the chapter topics as the authors themselves. In part because of this obstacle, the Introduction does not provide either non-specialist readers or those who lack specific knowledge of particular countries with enough comparative background to make clear and accurate sense of the book as a whole. Nevertheless, this book will be of interest to some scholars with specific area expertise, as well as to readers engaged in policy debates about land reform and resource use.