When the sixteenth-century reformers formulated sola scriptura they did so in a context of both curiosity and consternation over the Bible. Gillian Evans, in her instructive Problems of Authority in the Reformation Debates,Footnote 1 commented that ‘[i]t is a supreme irony that it was at the time when Scriptura sola became a reforming slogan that it became unprecedentedly difficult to point unequivocally to the Sacred Page and say, “That is Holy Scripture”’.Footnote 2 For all their gains, the humanists who laboured over scripture incurred a host of questions. Which manuscripts are reliable? What is the relationship between the original languages and the Vulgate translation? Is it legitimate to emend the Vulgate on the basis of textual criticism? The Greek New Testament and Hebrew Old Testament? What of the stylistically rude aspects of New Testament Greek? Could a scholar point out a flaw in a biblical author's verbiage? In short, humanist scholars struggled to understand the nature of scripture in light of their new skills. The net effect of this, as Evans argues, was a challenge to the nature of biblical authority.
To Evans's conclusions must be added the fine work of Erika Rummel, particularly her detailed article ‘Biblical Scholarship: Humanist Innovators and Scholastic Defenders of Tradition’Footnote 3 on the fierce debates between humanists and scholastics. This article furthers and complements Evans's discoveries. While it does not focus on the authority of scripture as such, it contains important insights about scripture's sixteenth-century status. Rummel explains that humanists who used philology to study scripture were considered dangerous and rebellious: ‘[B]iblical humanists were frequently accused of being “lovers of innovation”, a charge that carried historical ballast and put them in a class with plotting revolutionaries and political assassins’.Footnote 4 The ‘epithets “bold” and “presumptuous” feature prominently in the traditionalists’ descriptions of efforts to correct Scripture’.Footnote 5 Scholastics dubbed humanist philology ‘a shadow power’ and believed that ‘the real power of rendering judgment was vested in the theologian who held the magisterium’.Footnote 6 The scholastics, then, worried about the humanist overthrow of tradition, while the humanists saw tradition as a barrier to the ancient truth. Ironically, both were interested in preserving the past.
In particular, scholastics felt humanists disparaged the venerable Vulgate, subjecting it to careless criticism and inappropriate inquiry. To suggest its emendation on the basis of textual criticism or to evaluate it in terms of the Greek and Hebrew manuscripts, as Desiderius Erasmus and Lorenzo Valla had done, was to question the inspiration of the treasured text. To provide new translations was seditious. Clearly the Vulgate had been assigned scriptural status in the medieval church; Rummel consistently finds examples of humanists who began their work with an apologia that they were not countermining the inspiration of the Vulgate; some contended that inspiration did not extend to the translation. The humanist project was further complicated by the fact that the Vulgate was used as the primary source of doctrine and its terminology was stock vocabulary for scholastic disputation. To challenge its accuracy or to make a recommendation like that of Cardinal Ximenes, who contended that the original languages needed to be engaged for a true apprehension of the meaning, was to call into question the basis and ground of medieval theology.Footnote 7 ‘In defending the Vulgate’, writes Rummel, ‘the scholastic doctors . . . saw themselves in the role of guardians of doctrine’.Footnote 8
What Evans and Rummel draw to our attention are the practical problems facing a view like sola scriptura, and the social scepticisms against the reformers who employed humanist learning. In light of their work it must be admitted that there were few social, political and even, given the perceived innovative character, theological benefits attached to advocating the scripture principle. Such a decision would be seen as ‘novel’,Footnote 9 heretical and politically subversive. What kind of reform introduced something new and foreign?
While in our modern day it is commonplace to collapse theology into psychology and/or sociology, such a reduction cannot be operative when considering the Reformation era, at least if we are to understand it aright. Sixteenth-century theology was of public concern, having been assigned a social and political value to the effect that its affirmations and judgements were normative for the full spectrum of human activity. Theologians, therefore, were not simply expressing their religious feelings, preferences or experiences in complete and utter freedom. No, the public normativity of theology placed a premium on historical continuity, making deviance a politically precarious move. When one challenged a staple doctrine, one threatened the stability of society and the authority of the church (hence, Evans) which constituted the fabric of sixteenth-century life and culture.Footnote 10 As a result, theologians, if they wished to be taken seriously and if they wished to do serious theology, needed both to demonstrate their fidelity to the inherited faith and to prove their upstanding citizenship. It is no surprise, then, that we find John Calvin dedicating his Institutes of the Christian Religion to King Francis I and, in that dedication, defending the Reformed church's harmony with the church fathers.
Establishing continuity with the past was one of the best ways to mitigate the charge of novelty. And in light of Evans's and Rummel's findings, documentation of how the reformers justified adherence to sola scriptura in the face of this accusation is required. The Reformation scripture principle was certainly fresh in its day, but the question remains as to whether it was so in the sense of reformFootnote 11 or in the sense of innovation. Roman Catholics, both then and now, have written it off as the latter. Many Protestants wearily concede. The reason: the earliest church knew of an extra-biblical tradition – regula fidei – which stood alongside and over scripture as a guide for interpretation and basis for doctrine. The existence of this interpretative tradition meant that the Roman Catholic notion of an authoritative oral tradition had historical precedent and therefore the Protestant sola scriptura was an aberration. On what basis could Protestants defend themselves? To put it in terms of the present article's title: How did they parse the relationship between the regula fidei and sola scriptura, the early church's knowledge of an authoritative tradition and the categorical priority of the written Word?
To answer this question, I turn to Martin Chemnitz's Examination of the Council of Trent. Not only does Chemnitz provide one of the most comprehensive discussions of the relationship between scripture and tradition in light of the codification of the Catholic position at Trent but, as a second-generation reformer living in the mid-sixteenth-century, he represents the maturation of Reformation theology. Chemnitz is well suited for this study since he exhibits an unswerving commitment to sola scriptura and, perhaps, the deepest devotion to tradition of any sixteenth-century reformer. Moreover, an early Protestant response to the Council of Trent is ripe for insight into the way in which Protestants understood their position in light of mounting Catholic critique. The issue of the rule of faith became evident in the Catholic, particularly the Jesuit, refutation of sola scriptura. Chemnitz was aware of this. His response, therefore, reveals the reasons why an early Protestant could legitimately claim the historic faith and dismiss accusations of divergence.
The study will progress as follows. A brief consideration of the nature and function of the rule of faith in the early church will comprise the first part, followed by an in-depth treatment of Chemnitz's understanding of the relationship between regula fidei and sola scriptura. The conclusion to be drawn is that Chemnitz, while attempting to rebut the claim that the early regula fidei of the church fathers is evidence for the Catholic position, found historical merit for the scripture principle in the very arguments of those who make use of the oral regula fidei. This discovery allows him both to charge his Roman Catholic opponents and the Council of Trent with innovation and to show that the Protestant church was the truly ancient church on the issue of scripture. In the process, I hope to move towards a closer understanding of the sixteenth-century Protestant scripture principle, specifically its positive and negative commitments as regards tradition.
The function of the rule of faith within the post-apostolic church
The early regula fidei has provoked numerous theories. Adolf von Harnack argued that it was linked to broader baptismal formulations.Footnote 12 Everett Ferguson likewise sees it as a ‘[s]ummary of the main points of Christian teaching’ which was ‘presented perhaps especially to new converts in preparation for baptism’.Footnote 13 J. N. D. Kelly noticed its connection to baptism, yet stated that it was ‘manifestly . . . not a baptismal creed’, but ‘a short commentary on it’.Footnote 14 He understood it as a ‘body of teaching transmitted in the Church by scripture and tradition’Footnote 15 which was often employed for polemical purposes (refutations of heresies). Eric Osborn too has highlighted the apologetic function of the rule within the early church, noting that it served as a measure of orthodox belief.Footnote 16 T. F. Torrance believed that, while not being intentionally creedal, it ‘paved the way for the dogmatic formulations in the Nicene Creed’.Footnote 17
Working with N. T. Wright's understanding of theology as inherently narratival,Footnote 18 Paul Blowers has suggested that the rule served as a summary of the biblical plotline which shaped early Christian identity in terms of redemptive history.Footnote 19 On Blowers's account, the rule was like a biblical highlight reel which preserved the integrity of the Christian Gospel over against all (primarily Gnostic) distortions. Lewis Ayres also finds that the rule was a concise formulation of the grand themes in scripture, writing, ‘Christians summarized the narrative and σκoπóς of the text in the “rule of faith” [. . . and] in all contexts the perceived traditional faith was the guide for interpretation’.Footnote 20
Looking briefly to Tertullian and Irenaeus – the two propagators of the rule with whom Chemnitz deals – we can conclude that the rule of faith was a formalized summary of the essential core of early Christian belief assumed to be of apostolic origin and to possess what I will call hermeneutical and apologetic authority. It was probably an oral tradition, either preached directly by the apostles or formulated from their preaching, which spread among the early churches through preaching and catechesis.
Tertullian (c.160–220) in his On Prescription of Heretics Footnote 21 sought to defend the regula fidei against Gnostic oral tradition. After setting forth its contents, he launched into the ‘point of our position’, namely, that ‘the Scriptures . . . do not belong to them [the heretics]’.Footnote 22 Rather, the ‘Scriptures belong only to those who have the rule of faith’.Footnote 23 So, Tertullian believed that one should turn to tradition before scripture since the latter cannot be understood apart from the church's received faith:
Our appeal, therefore, must not be made to the Scriptures [. . .rather] we must discuss: ‘with whom lies that very faith to which the Scriptures belong’ . . . For wherever it shall be manifest that the true Christian rule and faith shall be, there will likewise be the true Scriptures.Footnote 24
The point is primarily hermeneutical: without the rule, scripture is only ‘abused’. Alongside this hermeneutical authority, the apologetic authority of the rule is manifest. The rule is the vantage point from which Tertullian launched his arguments and the standard by which he measured orthodoxy. He accused the heretics of aberration precisely because they did not share the church's regula fidei.
Consequently, he looked to the ‘apostolic churches’ – churches purportedly planted by the apostles – for the knowledge of faith and the right reading of scripture. The rule was first declared by Christ, then disseminated by his apostles and, finally, deposited in the apostolic churches. This apostolic faith ensures the global unity of the church: ‘Therefore the churches, although they are so many and so great, comprise but the one primitive church, founded by the apostles, from which they all spring . . . We hold communion with the apostolic churches because our doctrine is in no respect different from theirs.’Footnote 25 Thus, without the rule, the heretics are not in communion with Christ's apostolic church and, therefore, have no claim upon the Christian scriptures which they malign and mishandle in their unruly interpretation.
While we ought to keep in mind that Tertullian never suggested a distinction in content between the rule and the scriptures, indeed, such would undermine his argument, it is noteworthy that he thought a church tradition was the key to understanding scripture, a position seemingly not far from that of sixteenth-century Catholics. His attempt to ground doctrine and the reading of scripture in the ‘apostolic’ church would certainly pose a threat to those who would later claim that the Bible is self-interpreting. The emphasis on the perfect transmission of the regula fidei via church leaders, something which we will see in Irenaeus as well, seems to suggest the importance of the magisterium for correct biblical interpretation. Finally, Tertullian's apparent separation of the rule from scripture – the rule is the key for opening scripture – could be a serious stumbling block for reformers who said that scripture alone was the rule of faith. All of these themes can be found in Irenaeus to whom I now turn.
Early in his Against Heresies,Footnote 26 Irenaeus (c.130–200), like Tertullian, declared that the global unity of the church was founded on its one apostolic faith. Note the ressemblances: ‘The Church, though dispersed throughout the whole world, even to the ends of the earth, has received from the apostles and their disciples this faith.’Footnote 27 This faith is the rule. And as with Tertullian, it is the primary basis from which Irenaeus argued, and the Gnostic departure from it gave rise to his refutation (this, again, suggests its apologetic authority).
Irenaeus complained that the Gnostics had foisted upon scripture an alien scheme of their own creation.Footnote 28 They brought ‘their own hypothesis’ at great ‘injury’ to the texts. In contrast to this Gnostic fabrication, Irenaeus posited the rule of faith which alone is the ‘hypothesis’ for interpreting scripture. The term ‘hypothesis’ had specific import in his day. Kathryn Greene-McCreight explains it well: ‘In the ancient world, unassembled mosaics were shipped with the plan or key (hypothesis) according to which they were to be arranged. The Rule of Faith is like the key, he [Irenaeus] says, which explains how the scriptures are to be arranged.’Footnote 29 Richard Norris, Jr., similarly, finds that the rule was considered to be ‘the “plot” which actually informs the Scriptures’.Footnote 30 Mary Donovan adds that it ‘governs right exegesis’ for Irenaeus.Footnote 31 Hence, the rule as the hypothesis or ‘plot’ of scripture is the hermeneutical key for interpreting it.Footnote 32
The final point concerns the way in which Irenaeus understood the presence of the apostolic faith in the churches of his day. Here we find something similar to Tertullian, namely, that the faith is present through a succession of church leaders. Irenaeus spoke of a ‘tradition which originates from the apostles and which is preserved by means of the successions of presbyters in the Churches’.Footnote 33 After recounting the succession of the bishops of Rome from the apostles on, he concluded that ‘by this succession, the ecclesiastical tradition from the apostles, and the preaching of the truth, have came down to us’.Footnote 34 Hence, this rule of faith which was for him apostolic was present in the church ultimately through the bishops of the church. The faith is thus found ostensibly in the apostolic churches where the rule is present.
There appears, then, to be an ecclesial tradition that is imposed from without upon scripture as a hermeneutic. Such a view would certainly aid Catholic apologists who argued for an ecclesial tradition that facilitated true biblical interpretation. Yet it is important not to force Irenaeus anachronistically into later debates where scripture and tradition are sharply distinguished. He certainly admitted a distinction (‘these men [the heretics] do now [sic] consent neither to Scripture nor to tradition’Footnote 35). Nevertheless, he almost always filled out tradition by recourse to scripture (note: Chemnitz will stress this aspect when he defends sola scriptura). Thus, the distinction is one of form rather than substance. Still, that Irenaeus stressed the necessity of the rule for accurate interpretation suggests its hermeneutical authority in relation to scripture, a point that appears to aid the reformers’ opponents who found the Bible insufficient.
With both Irenaeus and Tertullian, we see an attempt to uphold the catholic faith over against Gnostic perversion. The rule of faith was the basis for this endeavour and thus possessed a certain apologetic authority. The heretics failed precisely in their lacking acknowledgement of the rule. The hermeneutical and apologetic function of the rule is common throughout the church fathers. For example, Athanasius repeatedly accused his Arian antagonists of failing to read the scriptures in light of the rule of faith.Footnote 36 For the post-apostolic church, reading apart from the rule was arbitrary exegesis; it was exegesis not informed and constrained by the church catholic. As such, it was heretical.
While some have argued that the rule did not possess scriptural authority for these authors, being for them simply the right interpretation of scripture,Footnote 37 it can hardly be denied that the rule functioned as a tradition apart from which no correct interpretation could occur.Footnote 38 This, coupled with the fact that both conceived of the rule's presence and preservation in the church as one of ecclesiastical succession, seems to lend great plausibility to the Catholic position where the scriptures are in need of an official interpreter who possesses the catholic faith via apostolic succession.
We return to our question: how did reformers provide historical justification for sola scriptura if, as early as the second century, there was known and recorded an apostolic tradition given to the churches as the ‘key’ to unlocking the teachings of the scriptures? Did reformers have to concede the historic precedence of the Catholic position in the regula fidei? Enter Martin Chemnitz.
Chemnitz contra Trent
Martin Chemnitz (9 November 1522–8 April 1586), son of Paul and Euphemia Chemnitz, husband to Anna, was a shrewd Lutheran theologian of the mid-sixteenth century. Despite both being neglected in The Cambridge Companion to Reformation Theology Footnote 39 and David Steinmetz's Reformers in the Wings,Footnote 40 and generally overlooked in standard texts on the Reformation,Footnote 41 Chemnitz was a tremendously influential theologian whose work was an enduring achievement. Owen Chadwick hails him ‘the most learned Protestant theologian of the century’.Footnote 42 Jacob Preus echoes this, finding him ‘an enormously talented man’ who ‘was in great demand for his learning and wisdom’.Footnote 43 Robert Preus makes the bold claim that Chemnitz's Loci Theologici was ‘the most important contribution to dogmatic theology in the Lutheran Church in the 16th century’.Footnote 44 Known as the ‘second Martin’ for his retention of Luther's theology in the face of compromisers, Chemnitz made his mark on confessional Lutheranism, being both a chief crafter of the Formula of Concord and instrumental in its political reception (1577–80). His theological work on christology and justification by faith became standard for Lutheran theology, and defended Martin Luther's thought against both Reformed and Catholic detractors; many variously see him as the father of Lutheran orthodoxy.Footnote 45 Much of his corpus, as a testimony to its lasting significance, has undergone recent translation. Yet all of these intellectual achievements were simply the work of a man who cared intensely for the reform of the Christian church. Indeed, Chemnitz was above all a pastor. Most of his career (1554–86) was spent ministering in the town of Braunschweig where he first served as a pastor (15 December 1554–14 October 1567) and then as a pastor of pastors, a superintendent installed in office on 15 October 1567 where he remained until two years before his death.
A key moment in the ‘Catholic Reformation’,Footnote 46 and therefore an event that pastor Chemnitz had to address, was the Council of Trent convened on 13 December 1545. Holy scripture along with its relationship to sacred tradition received treatment in the fourth session (1546).Footnote 47 Relevant to our study are the following statements:
The council clearly perceives that this truth and rule [the Gospel of Jesus Christ] are contained in written books and in unwritten traditions which were received by the apostles from the mouth of Christ himself, or else have come down to us, handed on as it were from the apostles themselves at the inspiration of the Holy Spirit. Following the example of the orthodox fathers, the council accepts and venerates . . . the books of both the Old and the New Testament . . . as well as the traditions concerning both faith and conduct, as either directly spoken by Christ or dictated by the Holy Spirit, which have been preserved in unbroken sequence in the Catholic Church.Footnote 48
The council further decrees . . . that no one, relying on his personal judgment in matters of faith and customs which are linked to the establishment of Christian doctrine, shall dare to interpret the Sacred Scriptures either by twisting its text to his individual meaning in opposition to that which has been and is held by Holy Mother Church, whose function is to pass judgment on the true meaning and interpretation of the Sacred Scriptures.Footnote 49
It would be improper to say that Trent affirms ‘two sources’ of revelation. Rather both ‘written books and unwritten traditions’ have their source in God. Trent does suggest two media of revelation – scripture and unwritten tradition – that are, furthermore, governed and judged solely by the Catholic Church. The council, at one point, described the church's teaching as deriving ‘partim ex scriptures, partim etiam ex simplici traditione per manus’, leading many scholars to conclude that Trent understands some doctrines to have their root in scripture and others to derive from tradition.Footnote 50 Yet this language was dropped from the final document in order to aver ‘some basic unity between Scripture and tradition’.Footnote 51 Nevertheless, the allowance of a separate medium of revelation and the relegation of the interpretation of scripture to ecclesiastical judgement undermined, according to Protestants, the sufficiency of scripture, something which sola scriptura was meant to preserve. This was certainly Chemnitz's perception.
Two years after the Council of Trent between 1565 and 1573 Chemnitz began to release an examination of its decrees, an examination which Arthur Olsen has dubbed, ‘the most thorough and influential Protestant response ever made to Trent’.Footnote 52 J. Preus lauds it ‘one of the greatest theological masterpieces ever produced in Lutheranism’.Footnote 53 One cannot deny its significance for its day. It saw twenty-five editions and underwent translation into German by Georg Nigrinus in 1576, English in 1582 and French. And while Calvin may have been the first to respond, it was Chemnitz's work that consumed Catholic apologists for decades.
His Examination of the Council of Trent Footnote 54 is largely a polemical piece, being both a counter to the council and an apology for Lutheran Protestantism. With regard to the latter, Chemnitz constantly uses church tradition as a tacit apologetic to demonstrate that the Protestant church is in harmony with the ancient church. By scrutinising Trent, Chemnitz intended both to expose its unscriptural decrees and, perhaps more so, to reply to Jacob Payva de Andrada, a Portuguese Jesuit who attacked Chemnitz for his 1562 tract against the Jesuits. As the preface makes clear, Chemnitz, in the process of replying to Andrada, discovered that he (Andrada) was both working at the behest of Trent and defending the theology there espoused (hence an examination of Trent). Founded in 1540, the Society of Jesus initially focused its efforts on countering Protestant advances and attacking reformed leaders with sustained theological criticism. She was a fierce foe. In the context of the Genevan Reformation, Scott Manetsch comments that ‘the dramatic expansion of the Society of Jesus throughout Europe posed the single greatest intellectual challenge to Calvinism at the end of the sixteenth century’.Footnote 55 This could be said, mutatis mutandis, of Lutheran Germany as well. Chemnitz is often credited with being the first to recognise the gravity of the Jesuit offensive. The Examination must be read as part of this larger context.
At the outset of his Examination, Chemnitz laments Trent's placement of ‘unwritten traditions’ alongside the written scripture. While in theory this might suggest their equality, he believes that in practice it has led to the demeaning and demotion of holy scripture. In fact, Catholics, according to him, thought scripture to be obscure and, consequently, easily twisted, misinterpreted and abused. Tradition, by contrast, was considered more clear and more resolute and, therefore, easier to understand. The ‘papalists’ also argued from Jeremiah 31:33, contending that God did not have the entire gospel written since it was a superior to the stone tablets of the Law. The gospel has more to do with what is written on the heart by the Spirit than on paper by the human hand. It was a gospel of the Spirit and thus was better apprehended by the ‘living voice’ of tradition than the written word of scripture.
Chemnitz understood this as a claim for the superiority of oral transmission for the gospel and, conversely, the inferiority of scripture as a medium of revelation. He retorted that scripture was written by the will of God ‘in order that the Scripture might be the canon, norm, and rule of faith in the church’.Footnote 56 Contra the Catholic contention, he claims that oral tradition is a flawed and unreliable means of communication, a reality that led to the gospel being written down. He recounts a number of instances where God revealed himself through oral tradition (e.g. pre-Moses revelation) finding that in each case ‘the purity of the Word was finally not preserved faithfully by traditions of the living voice but corrupted and adulterated’.Footnote 57 This proves that oral communication is not the best means of handling the traditions of God. Thus God, according to Chemnitz, decided that writing would be the mode of his communication. God's commitment to the written text, argued Chemnitz, is manifest by the fact that the first biblical text – the Decalogue – was written by the fingers of God himself.
Andrada claimed that the early church lacked the written gospel for twenty years. Chemnitz was happy to accept this calculation for the sake of argument, adding that ‘in the Old Testament the church of God from the beginning of the world lacked the divinely inspired scripture for a period of 2,454 years’.Footnote 58 Chemnitz also agreed that the doctrine preached by Christ during his earthly ministry, and proclaimed by his apostles via the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, was initially mediated to the churches solely by an oral tradition. However, he hastens to add that it does not follow from these facts that oral tradition is a superior or even God's preferred medium of communication. Nor does it suggest a distinction between the content of scripture and the content of tradition.
In support, he enlists Irenaeus’ discussion of the apostolic faith which we rehearsed above. He quotes from Irenaeus: ‘We have learned from none others the plan of our salvation, than from those through whom the Gospel has come down to us, which they did at one time proclaim in public, and, at a later period, by the will of God, handed down to us in the scriptures, to be the ground and pillar of our faith.’Footnote 59 ‘This statement of Irenaeus’, Chemnitz comments, ‘speaks of the whole Scripture of the New Testament in general, whose authority, perfection, and (as we now say) sufficiency, he shows by the firmest demonstrations. . . . Therefore we have in the Scriptures which the apostles delivered to us by the will of God the foundation and pillar of the only true and life-giving faith of the primitive church, received from the apostles.’Footnote 60 Any faith that derives ‘from any other source than from the scriptures . . . is not the true, life-giving, apostolic faith of the primitive church. This lies most clearly and firmly in the argumentation of Irenaeus.’Footnote 61 After quoting Irenaeus’ contention that when heretics are refuted by scripture they reply by maligning scripture, Chemnitz remarks that Andrada and others of his ilk should recognise themselves as indicted by Irenaeus’ words when they claim the obscurity and insufficiency of scripture. Indeed, he believes that the ‘papalists’, by favouring the reliability of oral tradition and denigrating scripture, are at odds with Irenaeus’ understanding of the rule.
Having established that holy scripture contains the whole of the initially oral apostolic faith, and that it is a reliable and stable medium of revelation, Chemnitz turns to the issue of tradition. He begins by noting the ‘papalists’ believe ‘that the things which are transmitted and observed in the Roman Church which cannot be proved by any testimony of Scripture are the very things which were delivered orally by the apostles and were not put down in writings’.Footnote 62 Yet Chemnitz concludes that this is so convenient as to be contrived. What is more, it completely diverges from the ancient notion of tradition.
The Jesuits alleged that sola scriptura ended in scepticism; sometimes Pyhrronism was invoked to level this charge. Minimally, they argued that by subjecting scripture to the private interpreter Protestants had no criterion by which to adjudicate interpretations. Interpreters needed mother church, the holder of tradition, in order to understand scripture aright. In this, the Jesuits called upon the regula fidei of Irenaeus and Tertullian to claim that sola scriptura was an innovation. Chemnitz acknowledged their position. He wrote that Tertullian's decision to turn to the rule before the scriptures ‘seem to give much aid to the papalists against the Scriptures’.Footnote 63
Yet Chemnitz contends that the ancient church never understood the rule as teaching something new or other than what can be found in scripture. If Irenaeus and Tertullian are read in context and attention is paid to the development of their argument then, he says, it will be found that they only confirm the Protestant scripture principle.Footnote 64 It is his position that the ‘papalists’ have twisted the arguments of these two fathers to say that there are dogmas of faith found only in tradition that cannot be found in scripture. Yet Irenaeus, Chemnitz describes, ‘does nothing else in Books 3, 4, and 5 than to prove and confirm those articles of faith [the rule] at length from Scripture’.Footnote 65 We noted this above when discussing Irenaeus, and the second Martin brings it to the fore to note the disparity between Irenaeus’ understanding of tradition and the Tridentine notion:
Therefore let this, which is crystal clear and undeniable, be diligently observed first of all in this dispute, that the controversy [between the two fathers and the Gnostics] was not about dogmas of faith which they could not prove, or the opposite of which they could not refute, with the testimonies from Scripture. For they are those articles in which, as it were, the sum of the whole Scripture consists. Let this be observed, for then the reader will know with what cunning the papalists twist these arguments of Irenaeus and Tertullian to their traditions, concerning which they themselves confess that they cannot be proved with any testimony of Scripture.Footnote 66
Thus, the Catholics tried to use the regula fidei of Irenaeus and Tertullian as an example of their understanding of tradition which asserted a substantial distinction between scripture and tradition. Chemnitz, by contrast, stresses that such is alien to the thought of these two fathers; their argument presupposes unity since they substantiated the rule by scripture.Footnote 67 He thus calls his Catholic antagonists to account, arguing that the content of the rule and the scriptures were always the same and nowhere did the fathers speak of a doctrine in the rule not found in scripture.
Interestingly, implicit in Chemnitz' comments is his impression that Catholics practised a partim-partim understanding of the manner in which Catholic dogma derives from scripture and tradition, that is, some parts stem from scripture while other parts, distinct from those ex scriptura, are received from tradition alone. His concern lends itself well to those scholars who see sola scriptura as a rejection of an aberrant version of tradition rather than a wholesale rejection of tradition. In this regard, Heiko Oberman distinguished between ‘Tradition I’ – an exegetical unpacking of the contents of scripture – and ‘Tradition II’ – an extra-biblical source that consisted of separate content. Using this distinction he concluded that ‘the Council of Trent in its fourth session gave its sanction to the coinherence of scripture and Church in terms of Tradition II’Footnote 68 for in the Catechismus Romanus (1566) ‘[t]radition is seen as a second doctrinal source which does not simply “unfold” the contents of scripture, as in Tradition I but adding its own substance complements Holy Scripture contentwise’.Footnote 69 Oberman found that the Protestant scripture principle was not meant to be a rejection of Tradition I, but of Tradition II. Similarly D. H. Williams: ‘The conflict between the early Reformers and Rome was not one of scripture versus Tradition, but rather a clash over what the traditions had become, or between divergent concepts of tradition.’Footnote 70 The argument of Chemnitz confirms their findings. He does not argue against Irenaeus’ or Tertullian's use of tradition in relation to scripture, nor even the Catholic desire to utilise tradition as a help in biblical interpretation. Rather, he contends that these fathers knew of no material distinction between tradition and scripture.Footnote 71
If scripture and tradition were not distinguished substantively by Irenaeus and Tertullian, then why, Chemnitz asks, do they appeal to the rule as the only means of biblical interpretation? A Catholic might concede to Braunschweig's superintendent that these fathers admitted no difference in content, but he could still press the fact that both fathers appeal to a tradition as the only entry way into the content of scripture. Shrewdly, Chemnitz reminds his challengers that the Gnostics, who Tertullian and Irenaeus were combating, did not believe in the authority of holy scripture. The Gnostics held to a secret oral tradition, believed to be handed down by the apostles, which was superior to scripture. In this situation, Chemnitz argues, Tertullian and Irenaeus could not appeal to scripture. After all, as quoted above, Irenaeus reported that when scripture was used, the heretics would simply turn and malign scripture as deficient. Chemnitz explains that both fathers are quite clear that they make the appeal to tradition before scripture only because the heretics place their secret oral tradition over against scripture.
Tertullian and Irenaeus did not employ the oral rule because it was superior to scripture but, Chemnitz concludes, to prove the veracity of scripture and its essential harmony with the faith passed on from Christ and his apostles to the apostolic churches. Indeed, Chemnitz claims that, when confronted with the heretical rejection of scripture in favour of a secret oral tradition, Irenaeus and Tertullian attempted to demonstrate (a) that the only oral tradition came straight from Christ to his apostles and then to the Christian churches; and (b) that this tradition is now found in the church's scripture.Footnote 72 ‘Therefore the papalists act wickedly when they twist a qualified statement of Tertullian [that scripture cannot be sought first because the heretics do not recognize its authority and place an oral tradition above scripture] into an unqualified one, as if in religious controversies no appeal at all were to be made to scriptures and as if in disputes concerning dogmas of faith either no victory at all or only an uncertain one could be hoped for from the Scriptures.’Footnote 73 These fathers did not invoke tradition because it was ‘clearer’ or because scripture was insufficient, but in order to uphold the apostolicity of the scriptures. While admittedly the fathers worked from tradition to scripture, their argument revolved around the conclusion that the only apostolic tradition preached by Christ and his apostles is now in scripture. Thus, whereas Catholics found the early regula fidei to be evidence of tradition's magisterial role over scripture, Chemnitz finds that Irenaeus’ and Tertullian's arguments actually moved in the opposite direction.
Even in Irenaeus’ famous passage, detailing the succession of bishops at Rome, he does not ‘speak of dogmas of faith which cannot be proved by any testimony of Scripture’.Footnote 74 Rather, Irenaeus ‘says it [the preservation of the apostolic faith through episcopal succession] was done by the fullest use of the Scriptures’.Footnote 75 Chemnitz finds that the rule of faith in Irenaeus and Tertullian demonstrates ‘the agreement of apostolic tradition with scripture, so that tradition may not be set in opposition to the scripture, as if the latter were wrong, ambiguous, or incomplete’.Footnote 76 From these two fathers, ‘the truth, the authority, the perfection and sufficiency of scripture are proved and confirmed, so that the ancient constitution of the church and the true tradition of the apostles is preserved by the use and exposition of the Scriptures’.Footnote 77
At the close of his discussion of the rule, he explains why he considered it at length: ‘I have copied out these symbols [the rule] in order to show that we do not reject those things about which it is certain that they are true and ancient traditions of the apostles.’Footnote 78 The Protestants do not reject the traditions of the church; rather they reject the notion that there is an authoritative tradition that differs from apostolic scripture. They cannot rightly be accused of forfeiting tradition since the one apostolic tradition is found in scripture. It is the Protestants, according to Chemnitz, who are in agreement with the ancient church on the issue of tradition in general and the rule of faith in particular. In fact, the rhetorical effect is to locate Protestants alongside Irenaeus and Tertullian while placing Catholics such as Andrada in the company of these fathers’ Gnostic antagonists. It was the Gnostics who believed in a secret oral tradition that differed substantively from scripture. Irenaeus and Tertullian appeal to tradition before scripture because they had first to prove that the only tradition preached by Christ and his apostles was the regula fidei found in their churches. As Chemnitz shows, these two fathers constantly move from establishing the historical succession of this apostolic tradition to demonstrating that this tradition was found in scripture. Scripture and tradition were not separated by these authors as if to suggest that certain church practices and doctrines came from one and not the other. And this has been the Protestant claim all along. Thus, by sharing the Gnostic belief in an oral tradition that teaches different doctrines from those found in scripture, it is the Catholics who Chemnitz says have departed from the ancient church. This is the rhetorical effect of Chemnitz' arguments.
Conclusion: sola scriptura and the regula fidei
What then is the relationship between sola scriptura and the regula fidei for Chemnitz? And how could a Protestant defend against the charge of novelty? In the first place, there is no distinction between the teaching of the rule and the teaching of scripture for Chemnitz. The rule and scripture should not to be set in competition with each other for the New Testament simply is the apostolic rule written. Therefore, any appeal to the rule as an ‘unwritten tradition’ diverges from the Catholic Church's earliest understanding of the unity of scripture and tradition. In fact, as Chemnitz has it, such a move would place one beside the earliest heretics, the Gnostics. It is on this basis that Chemnitz could refer to the scriptures as the sole regula fidei and defend the Reformation against charges of novelty. The reformers’ scripture principle is for Chemnitz another way of saying what Irenaeus and Tertullian said about the rule of faith, namely, the apostolic faith is contained accurately, reliably and wholly in scripture. Sola scriptura was, at least for Chemnitz, the best way to preserve the ancient regula fidei.
