If the title of this work sounds familiar, it is because the book is—with the exception of an index—identical to volume 9, number 2 (Summer 2004) of the Journal of North African Studies. Its appearance in this cloth format is a welcome opportunity for scholars and libraries that do not receive the journal to acquire this informative collection of essays on Algeria's recent political crisis. The contributors constitute a veritable international who's who of experts on Algeria's politics, economy, and society, many of whom gathered for a conference at the University of Michigan in September 2002.
The Algerian political scientist, Luis Martinez, known for his concept of an “imaginaire de la guerre,” opens the collection with an essay on the fundamental question, “Why the Violence in Algeria?” In a minor variation on his earlier work, Martinez attributes the violence to a profound cultural belief in equality. He argues that the armed Islamists felt a hatred for the state because it was perceived as “engaging in uncontrolled appropriation, generating unjustified benefits for limited groups” (p. 25). This passion for equality, common to the discourse of the wartime FLN as well as “the Islamist utopia of the FIS,” (p. 25) explains the extremes of violence that characterized Algeria's civil war. This paroxysm of fury having spent itself, Martinez argues that the challenge for the future is to find a way “to reconcile Algerians with their leadership and themselves” (p. 26).
How feasible does such reconciliation appear to some of the other contributors? To William Quandt in his “Algeria's Transition to What?,” it is not out of the question. He draws hope from the notion that “multi-party democracy is no longer a disparaged concept,” from a “vibrant free press” (which has regrettably lost some of its vibrancy since 2004) and from signs that the military is ready for a pact that would move it “to the sidelines” (pp. 86, 89). Quandt declares himself a “guarded optimist” (p. 91) regarding a gradual transition to democracy. Likewise Clement Henry expresses optimism about the prospects for constitutional democracy in the process of his chapter that debunks a standard rentier state interpretation of Algeria's woes. Azzedine Layachi, in his informative overview of the Islamist movement, sees a reasonable prospect for a new social contract between Islamists and secularists. Although the record is mixed, events since 2002 have not really discredited these hopeful assessments.
Part II of the collection contains useful essays by Boutheina Cheriet, Abdelbaki Benziane, and Kada Akacem on various aspects of economy and society—gender, education, and economic reform. Each pinpoints achievements, but deplores continuing blockages in these sectors. The following section on International Networks and External Powers treats such issues as the Algerian diaspora in France, the Barcelona process, and matters of foreign policy. Both Mohammed Akacem and Yahia Zoubir emphasize President Abdelaziz Bouteflika's reassertion of Algeria's role in world affairs. Akacem suggests that Bouteflika's activist diplomacy “may come at the cost of dealing with the domestic issues that are at the heart of Algeria's ongoing crisis” (p. 156), while Zoubir concludes that the president's energetic foreign policy has not only “ended Algeria's isolation” (p. 180) but also contributed to domestic stabilization. Together these two chapters contribute to an ongoing debate about the role of foreign policy in the Algerian political system.
The concluding section places Algeria in comparative perspective, following up on one of the editors' basic premises, namely that the situation in Algeria provides a key to understanding much of what is happening in the Islamic world. Mark Tessler's chapter reports interesting survey data that are compared with data from Morocco, Egypt, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia. John Entelis places the Algerian case in the broader context of state–society relations throughout the Middle East and North Africa. Viewing the FIS as a “quintessential … Islamist reformist movement” (p. 207), he sees the Algerian regime as conforming to a widespread practice of confrontation that “unleashed a much more virulent form of Islamic radicalism” (p. 210). I. William Zartman closes the collection by comparing Algeria's “midlife crisis” with the experience of other developing states after forty years. The idea is intriguing, yet one is tempted to wonder whether Algeria's midlife crisis did not begin closer to the fortieth anniversary of le premier novembre 1954 than forty years after independence. The outbreak of the Algerian war of independence in 1954 constitutes the founding moment of the regime and continues to explain many of the unique elements of the Algerian political system (including its imaginaire de la guerre). By 2004, when Bouteflika was elected to a second term, Algeria was fifty years beyond that landmark date and perhaps moving beyond its crisis. In any case, the contributors to this volume provide a good framework for ongoing reflection on these issues.
