The sociologist authors of this book examine financial challenges facing the US Social Security program, portraying a comprehensive and evenhanded picture of both proponent and opponent arguments about the scheme. This very well-written book is intended for a general audience seeking to learn about financial issues facing the Social Security program. However, it will also be a valuable reference to social scientists and policy analysts concerned about more fundamental questions surrounding the Social Security dialog.
Social Security has been a subject of debate among politicians on both sides of the political spectrum since its 1935 enactment. In the last two decades, particularly, all parties to the debate agree that something needs to be done to address the program's long-term solvency, but alternative reform proposals have been hotly debated and contested. So why, the authors ask, is this “great debate” over Social Security still with us? They observe that, although the debate seems to have been about how to address the fiscal soundness of the program, the real debate has mainly centered on fundamental questions of principles and politics. What the authors seek to convey to the reader is that this “great debate” is not just about the future of this public program, but also a trial of ideological positions in a much larger and deeper debate; it is part of larger culture wars over the respective roles of government and individual.
The authors set the stage for their inquiry by first providing an explanation of basic technical terms, concepts, principles, and relationships necessary for understanding arguments about Social Security, something that non-expert readers should appreciate. Such terms include demographic assumptions, dependency ratios, market, independence, interdependence, insurance, efficiency and fairness, risk and uncertainty, Trust Fund, and moral hazard. According to the authors, such technical terms can be used in deliberately confusing or misleading ways; both sides of the debate tend to focus on generating slogans rather than building comprehension. The authors also underscore that the best analytical treatment of Social Security's technical issues and proposed alternatives has come from economic analysis.
The authors go on with a fair presentation of the main arguments used by proponents of replacing Social Security with a different program of postemployment income insurance (termed privatizationists) and the main arguments used by proponents of preserving Social Security program (termed preservationists). As the authors note, while both camps use the same historical records and economic evidence to persuade the public about their positions, they interpret and present the evidence differently by emphasizing some points and dismissing others. Proponents of privatization emphasize individual responsibility, ownership, personal choice, efficiency, and fairness as important considerations in revising the system. They view private accounts as a way to give workers a greater sense of ownership and choice with their retirement savings. They also believe individuals are the best decision makers regarding their savings and that they will reap a high rate of return by investing in financial markets. Yet the authors point out that once one accounts for market volatility, taxes, inflation, and transaction costs, the stock market rate of return is not much higher than that obtained by Social Security.
In this reviewer's opinion, given that evidence indicates that the majority of individuals have limited or no investment knowledge, shifting investment decisions and risks to individuals is likely to produce inequality in retirement outcomes. In contrast to proponents of privatization, proponents of preserving the current program emphasize collective responsibility and risk sharing, social insurance, and wealth redistribution, as important principles that need to be strengthened with any future adjustments. They argue that private accounts will increase participants' retirement risk at a time when many companies are moving away from defined benefit pension plans and that past returns on stocks and bonds can not safely be assumed to persist in the future. In this reviewer's opinion, the 2008 financial crisis has strengthened the position of opponents of private accounts. This experience has shown that market volatility coupled with inadequate savings and employer contributions can have significant adverse consequences for retirement security. In particular, workers retiring during market downturns may be placed at a severe disadvantage.
The long-term fiscal problem facing Social Security is not a new issue, but lately it has been framed as a crisis, a view not unanimously shared across the political spectrum. According to the authors, Social Security advocates claim that the rhetoric of crisis is nothing more than a political tool designed to undermine public confidence in this program. In this reviewer's opinion, the absence of a short-term crisis (such as the one that occurred in 1983) prevents politicians from reaching a compromise and instead allows them to consider reform proposals with a mentality of “all this” or “all that”. Privatization's proponents, on one side, may assert that there is no acceptable alternative unless the proposal included private accounts and no tax increases. Proponents of the Social Security program as currently structured, on the other side, may minimize the seriousness of the financing problem by an excessive focus on defending the redistributive aspects of the program and may try to avoid any talk of tax increases or benefit reductions asserting that any changes along those lines would invariably undermine the program. In fact, the program's fiscal integrity can be restored without changing the program's structure by raising taxes and reducing benefits. The failure to act, the authors note, leads one to question motivations, since any delays worsen Social Security's fiscal integrity. American citizens should understand that the cost of reform will be larger the longer such changes are delayed, and a larger proportion of the cost will be shifted to future generations. Moreover, any solution to the fiscal problems of Social Security might be achieved as an outcome of political compromise.
Hardy and Hazelrigg have written an engaging and insightful book. The book does not seek a solution to the Social Security debate – many others have done that. Rather it fills a unique niche by urging readers to demand a more open and information-based debate of the relevant issues and of the potential consequences of alternative reform proposals.
