The result of a PhD thesis, this book focuses on the role of Roman terra sigillata pottery, long appreciated for its importance in shaping debates about economic and cultural developments in the Roman world. However, moving away from traditional pottery analysis, Astrid Van Oyen uses published Gaulish terra sigillata to demonstrate a new approach to material studies using Actor Network Theory (ANT) within the broader discipline of Science and Technology Studies (STS), to look more closely at the pots as active agents within a ‘relation-based framework’, that can help answer questions about wider historical processes.
Ch. 1 introduces the subject and the history of material studies and material agency, with a focus on the connections between humans and objects, demonstrated for instance by the production process of pottery. However, what has been lacking, according to V.O., is connecting this material culture to broader historical debates: terra sigillata is not just a ‘history-teller’ but also a ‘history-maker’. Ch. 2 begins with a ‘survival guide’ (which is excellent, but could do with more subheadings and tables for true pottery dummies), followed by a historiography of sigillata studies and the development of its role in historical narratives. The challenge is thus set to deconstruct current sigillata studies in order to track their trajectory.
Ch. 3 looks at the historical specificity of its standardisation, concentrating on Lezoux (Central Gaul) in the second century a.d., examining production techniques and distribution, and changes over time, underlining the importance of focusing on how changes were made. The result was a standardised brand that had a direct effect on production, distribution and consumption — sigillata as history-maker. Ch. 4 examines the firing process, using evidence from the La Graufesenque firing lists as a way of looking at the organisation of production; V.O. then moves to distribution, suggesting that rather than being produced for a market system, terra sigillata should be viewed in its own right, as helping to shape that very market.
Ch. 5 focuses on stability in production and distribution by also introducing the production of ‘Rhenish’ wares and the importance of relating different wares to one another in any attempt to define them. The well-known notion that sigillata from Trier was inferior to earlier production at Lezoux is also questioned — instead, the differences between the Trier and Lezoux production may have been to do with shifting trends, new production techniques and relationships between ware production at different sites. Ch. 6 investigates how consumption affected production. At Colchester, for instance, they tried to make a version of Lezoux sigillata, but the high-level standardisation of the latter production made this impossible, as they were unable to adapt local firing and local clays to fit this standard, demonstrating ‘sigillata as a history-maker’ again. On the other hand, third-century sigillata production in the Nene Valley was based on East Gaulish production, which was less homogeneous.
The conclusions, ch. 7, summarise the conceptual arguments presented in each chapter, and the principal idea that runs through the book, namely that pottery not only helps us to tell histories, but also shapes ‘historical trajectories’. V.O. underlines again how the Lezoux production set the standard for all other sigillata production, thus demonstrating how the pots themselves steered the course of history, such as through the shaping of a centralised production landscape. Thus the causality of material culture is perhaps more complex than previously thought. The point that a trajectory is not the same as a biography is useful, with the former being explained as more about possibilities than actual events — that is to say, trajectories focus on the nature of the objects, which may shape how they are traded and consumed. This leads to the importance of allowing pottery to answer wider questions about empire: the formation of empire worked alongside the formation of terra sigillata — ‘one did not precede the other’.
Finally, V.O. puts this new thinking within the context of current archaeological research. The issue is that pottery studies are generally separate from historical narratives, which summarise the evidence from the pottery, and conferences are often separated in a similar manner. But these traditional typological studies of pottery are often not flexible enough to consider trajectories, and they need to refocus on the historical role of the object. However, in order to integrate this new approach, there need to be some adjustments to the way academics study artefacts and how the history writers look at pottery reports.
As a Roman pottery specialist, I found this volume to be a very welcome study opening up new approaches to the analysis of ancient ceramics, or material culture in general. The non-specialist, or non-theoretical archaeologist, will need to concentrate to appreciate the complex ideas contained within the text, but it is worth the effort. With all the new scientific methods to hand for expanding the repertoire of evidence we have for material culture, now is the moment also for reshaping how we use this information. Though pottery volumes and conferences are important for the specialist community, there is certainly a need for greater communication between the specialists and those creating the historical narratives. As the author puts it, ‘material culture is active with large-scale historical narratives’. I would urge not only material specialists, but particularly academics focusing on wider historical questions, to at least read the introduction and conclusions, so that we can begin to better integrate all of the information that archaeology and history present us with today.
