Reclaiming a Plundered Past: Archaeology and Nation Building in Iraq represents an important addition to the growing literature on the role of culture as a distinct power structure in the Western domination of the non-Western world. In a rich and engaging narrative spanning the period between the mid-19th century and the 1940s and covering a wide range of sources in Arabic and Western languages, Magnus Bernhardsson details the manner in which artifacts of Iraq's ancient civilizations became of central interest to Europe's colonial powers and, after World War I, a core component of British policy in Iraq.
He begins by presenting a comprehensive survey of European (and later American) interest in Iraq's archaeological heritage. In the 19th century, Ottoman rule offered minimal protection to important artifacts discovered by European archaeological expeditions. Large amounts of Iraq's civilizational heritage were spirited out of the country to prominent museums in the West. As the number of discoveries grew, competition among the British, French, and Germans intensified. By the eve of World War I, the Germans, with their close military and diplomatic ties to the Ottoman Empire and their advanced excavation technology, had become the most prominent Western power in the study and discovery of Iraqi antiquities. A large cache of German archaeological finds, which were left in the Iraqi city of Samarra during World War I, became the focal point of a struggle over their disposition following the end of the war.
European efforts to control Iraqi antiquities changed radically following Great Britain's invasion of Iraq in 1914 and defeat of Ottoman forces in 1917. Through a rigged referendum in 1921, the British engineered the creation of an Iraqi nation-state under the rule of the Hashimites. Despite Britain making the leader of the Arab Revolt and the son of the Sharif of Mecca, Faysal bin Husayn, Iraq's new king, political power lay largely in the hands of the unofficial British proconsul in Iraq, Gertrude Bell, who was appointed honorary director of antiquities in 1922. Once Bell became an adviser to Faysal I (1921–33), she came to see herself as an Iraqi official, bound to protect the new nation-state's interests, as much as a British civil servant. As Bernhardsson demonstrates, she alone was responsible for the antiquities law that was finally passed, after more Iraqi resistance than Bell and the British had anticipated, in 1924.
Reclaiming a Plundered Past suggests many dimensions of theories of colonial rule and domination that are often neglected in the literature on this topic. For one, Bernhardsson's study demonstrates that there were considerable cleavages within the British colonial bureaucracy regarding the manner in which Great Britain should manage Iraq's archaeological heritage once it controlled Iraq. Those who controlled museums in Great Britain, especially the British Museum and the Victoria and Albert Museum, approached the disposition of Iraqi artifacts from more narrow and selfish perspectives than members of the official colonial bureaucracy, who were concerned with Britain's image and political position in Iraq. Another cleavage was generational. Many younger British colonial officers, who came to realize at the end of World War I that the era in which Great Britain was able to maintain absolute control over its colonies had ended, argued that colonial rule must now assume a more indirect quality that, in turn, necessitated a more active role in co-opting and “educating” local elites. This internal conflict often undermined Britain's efforts to efficiently control Iraq.
Bernhardsson's study underscores another dimension of colonial rule that has only recently begun to receive greater attention: Britain's control of Iraq's archaeological artifacts was not only central to intercolonial rivalry but also to identity politics within Great Britain. On the one hand, control over Iraq's archeological treasures added to Great Britain's luster as a world power relative to its European rivals. On the other hand, the discovery and control of archaeological treasures also provided a mechanism whereby biblical texts could receive renewed authentication, which was important in an increasingly secular Europe and in light of the beginnings of the decline of British imperial power.
Also of significance is the self-doubt in the European colonial project that developed after World War I. By the early 1920s, rising nationalist sentiment and the European powers' recognition that their ability to control their colonies had been greatly diminished undermined the self-assured manner in which they had pursued la mission civilisatrice. Basing his work on extensive writings by British officials and members of Britain's cultural elite, Bernhardsson proffers a nuanced understanding of the workings of British rule that will be of interest to theorists of European colonialism.
Bernhardssohn devotes most of his attention to the British colonial actors who molded the manner in which Iraq's archaeological heritage was controlled, especially after World War I. Iraqi voices are only infrequently heard. We learn that both Satiʿ al-Husari, the Ottoman bureaucrat who befriended King Faysal during the Arab Revolt and was subsequently appointed director of antiquities (1934–41), and the well-known Arab nationalist, Yasin al-Hashimi, opposed Gertrude Bell's efforts to have the new Iraqi parliament pass the 1924 antiquities law that she had authored singlehandedly. If this study were to be expanded, one would want to learn more about Iraqi resistance to British antiquities policy in Iraq.
One example of early resistance occurred during the British establishment of the Iraq Museum, in which Bell played a central role. I would argue that the establishment of the Iraq Museum was much more contentious than Bernhardsson indicates and, perhaps of greater significance, reflective of the struggle within Iraq over which civilizational heritage would be most prominently represented. Iraqi nationalists in the Ministry of Education and elsewhere strongly objected to Bell's refusal to include artifacts and objets d'art from Iraq's Arab-Islamic past. After all, these nationalists argued, Baghdad had been the capital of the Abbasid Empire, and Iraq's greatness derived as much from its Arab and Islamic past as from its ancient civilizations. Nationalist agitation ultimately led Bell to transfer control of the newly created museum from Education to the Ministry of Public Works, where she felt the bureaucrats were less politically oriented. However, tensions within the Iraqi nationalist movement over which civilizational heritage most authentically represented Iraqi culture persisted.
During the 1930s, the Hashimites worked to create museums that were concerned with Iraq's Arab-Islamic past—for instance the restoration of the Khan Murjan market and the founding of the Museum of Arab Antiquities—as a means to strengthen their legitimacy among Iraqi nationalists. This tension between the British (and European) desire to conceive of only Iraq's ancient Mesopotamian civilization as worthy of commemoration and the contemporary nationalist emphasis on Iraq's Arab-Islamic or living heritage is a subject that requires more research. Following the failure of the May 1941 uprising by Pan-Arabist officers in the Iraqi army until the seizure of power by the first Bacthist regime in 1963, archaeology became increasingly politicized and an important component in the intensified struggle over control of the nationalist movement. The Department of Antiquities became identified with that wing of the nationalist movement that emphasized local Iraqi nationalism, as opposed to Pan-Arabists who wanted to see Iraq become part of a unified Arab state.
Finally, Reclaiming a Plundered Past raises the question of how the British and other European archaeological expeditions were able to export their finds to Europe. It is clear that such activity required the complicity of local officials, especially after European and American eyes were more closely focused on British actions in Iraq after World War I. One such official who does appear in the narrative is Hormuzd Rassam, described as the first Iraqi, albeit one closely identified with European culture, to have conducted archaeological excavations (during the 19th century). Were there organized local political and business interests that facilitated British control over Iraq's archaeological heritage?
In his final chapters, Bernhardsson analyzes the decline of British control over Iraqi antiquities during the late 1930s and 1940s. He details the increasing involvement of the Iraqi state in archaeological matters, especially the role of al-Husari as director of antiquities, a Pan-Arabist who shifted the focus of archaeological research to Iraq's Arab-Islamic and not just Mesopotamian heritage. Bernhardsson discusses the rise of indigenous groups of Iraqi archaeologists during the 1930s who were trained in the West, particularly Taha Baqir and Fuʾad Safar. Working under the leadership of Naji Asil, former foreign affairs minister who served as director-general of antiquities, this group founded the important archaeological journal, Sumer, in 1945. Reading the pages of Sumer from the late 1940s and 1950s is to encounter numerous letters from foreign archaeologists and research institutes praising the efforts of Baqir and his team as they engaged in an ever larger number of excavations, including those relating to Iraq's Arab-Islamic past. Indeed, Bernhardsson emphasizes the professionalism with which the Sumer group pursued their work. How an Iraqi-based archaeology came to eclipse and replace British control reflected not only the gradual decline of British influence in Iraq but also the increasing assertiveness of Iraqi nationalists who argued that Iraqis, not foreigners, should control their cultural heritage.
Reclaiming a Plundered Past ends with the hope that, once Iraq was freed of Baʿthist rule in 2003, archaeology might return to its earlier tradition and reclaim its position as providing Iraqis with a better understanding of their past, with all its civilizational contributions. As we know, this has not come to pass as Iraq struggles with sectarianism, a failed state, and an economy increasingly under the control of criminal elements. Bernhardsson's study, empirically rich and theoretically provocative, constitutes the definitive work to date on the history of Iraqi archaeology and its role in Iraqi politics and nation building. Reclaiming a Plundered Past constitutes a metaphor for much of what is happening in Iraq today, namely, the damage that can be done to a nation when a more powerful nation disingenuously seeks to subordinate and control it in the name of progress and civilizational development.
