On April 12, 2014, Fred Ho, the controversial saxophonist, composer, writer, and matriarchal socialist, died at the age of fifty-six after an extended battle with colon cancer. Although Yellow Power, Yellow Soul was published a year earlier, Ho's illness and impending death cast a long shadow on this anthology. More positively, his illness probably led many contributors to focus on the latter part of Ho's career. They explored how Ho's cancer diagnosis in 2006 affected his life and his work, and how he related his cancer battle to his revolutionary politics. These investigations significantly broaden the existing scholarship. More problematically, it is perhaps Ho's declining health that resulted in an anthology that often reads more like a celebration than a critical study.
Tamara Roberts's superb introduction examines how Ho constructed politically meaningful art in a period marked by the dissolution of mass social organizing and the neoliberal co-optation of multiculturalism. She outlines three strategies in particular: (1) Ho's “centering” of the music of marginalized people in his works, (2) his highlighting of the more radical underpinnings of popular and folk sources, and (3) his active cultivation of a sympathetic artistic and political community. The success of this essay stems from Roberts's balanced investigation of each. She questions whether listeners hear Ho's use of different musical traditions as musical decolonization or as Orientalist appropriation by a privileged Western composer. She also wonders to what extent Ho's use of mainstream marketing strategies blunts his political message. It is unfortunate, however, that not more of the remaining articles demonstrate such an evenhanded analysis of Ho's works.
The body of the book is divided into three parts. The first, “Revolution in Music,” is the most musicological in approach. It opens with one of the best essays in the anthology: Kevin Fellezs's examination of Ho's seemingly contradictory notion of the “popular avant-garde.” The author links this concept to Angela Davis, who argued that artists who engage popular culture can “motivate audiences to question normative assumptions and ideologies” (38). Fellezs further argues that many of the genres that influenced Ho, including jazz and various types of Asian folk music, have important “popular avant-garde” elements. Here he focuses on Chinese martial arts films. Initially skeptical of this genre, Ho was eventually convinced by Cherokee activist Day Star to recognize its revolutionary potential. Compelled by martial artists’ “willingness … to confront and contemplate conflict” and by the genre's ability to reach African Americans, Latinos, and youths, Ho went on to use martial arts choreography and philosophy in many of his stage works (40). Fellezs also contends that Ho was particularly attracted to the philosophy and artistry of Bruce Lee because the martial artist went beyond (and partially subverted) Chinese traditional culture by incorporating elements of Taoism and because he embraced improvisatory elements in his Jeet Kune Do system.
Meanwhile, playwright Ruth Margraff, who co-wrote seven operas with Ho, discusses her initial uneasiness with this collaboration. They ultimately settled on an unusual compositional process: Ho would write the music first, and then have weekly story meetings with Margraff. This brief essay is intriguing, but one wishes that she had gone into much greater depth about their working process. It ends with a warm tribute, which includes a list of her favorite memories of Ho. Arthur J. Sabatini surveys Ho's stage works and usefully connects them to Mikhail Bakhtin's notions of the dialogic and the carnivalesque. In addition to discussing the evolution of Ho's works, he provides vivid descriptions of the visual and dramaturgical aspects of several shows and discusses newspaper reviews of some of them. Unfortunately, Sabatini's discussions of the music are often opaque, and some of his points need much greater exposition. For example, he writes, “In performance, for Ho, the simultaneous representation of dance as martial arts and martial arts as dance is meant to be maintained, though highly stylized” (73). One wonders how this relationship is different from the use of martial arts in Chinese opera, acrobatics, and a host of other genres. Overall, the essay might have been more informative if Sabatini had focused on two or three representative works rather than surveying over a dozen of them.
The book's second part, “The Aesthetics of Politics,” opens with an essay and an interview that focus on Ho's formative years. Diane C. Fujino's outstanding essay reviews Ho's radicalization during the 1970s and his involvement in the Asian American movement, I Wor Kuen, and the League of Revolutionary Struggle during the first half of his career. Examining Ho's thoughts on the uneasy relationship between nationalism and Marxist-Leninism, she concludes that his emphasis on culture in revolutionary politics is closely related to assassinated Guinea-Bissauan and Cape Verdean nationalist Amilcar Cabral's notion that, because oppressors can only be successful when they destroy the culture of the oppressed, “maintaining one's culture, turning back toward one's cultural heritage, or re-creating a liberatory culture … in the face of colonialism is thus a revolutionary act” (98). Fujino concludes the essay with brief comments about the evolution of Ho's political thoughts since the 1990s, and one hopes that she will elaborate on some of them in a future article.
The next chapter is an interview between Ho and his friend from Harvard University, Salim Washington. Here, Ho not only discusses his political philosophy and his approaches to revolutionary music, but also his brief stint in the military and his years at Harvard. Another highlight of the anthology is Bill V. Mullen's wide-ranging examination of Ho's “body as a lived political location, as a tool for revolutionary change, as a site of attack by capitalism, racism, and sexism, [and] as an instrument for cultural and political transformation” (148). Mullen first explores how Ho's belief in the power of feminism to subvert capitalism and patriarchy is reflected in his collaborations with women writers and musicians and in the strong female characters in his stage works. He then discusses how the physicality in Ho's performances symbolizes the importance of using the body to battle the alienation of labor under capitalism. The final section of this essay investigates how Ho has connected his fight against cancer to his fight against capitalism. In explaining his gradual turn towards Ludditism in “Cancer Diary #12” (2007), Ho wrote, “Cancer cannot and will not be cured as long as there is more profit (money to be made) in ‘managing’ it, in coming up with newer and more expensive ‘power drugs’ and treatments rather than eliminating pesticides, environmental toxicity, greatly reducing processed foods and chemical additives” (155).
The final part of the book, “A Life in Community,” includes three essays and an interview with one of Ho's longtime friends and collaborators. While Magdalena Gómez focuses on Ho's loyalty, compassion, and fun side, Peggy Myo-Young Choy usefully outlines some of his practice of “fearless debate” with his collaborators (184). The most valuable contribution in this part is Miyoshi Smith's interview with Ho. Here, he discusses his difficult father, his loving mother, his experience growing up as a Chinese American in Amherst, Massachusetts, and his musical and political awakening. Kalamu ya Salaam's rumination on the meaning of Fred Ho's impending death and Arthur Song's brief examination of how Fred Ho changed since his cancer diagnosis conclude this anthology.
Given the length and controversial nature of Ho's career, Yellow Power, Yellow Soul would have benefitted both from a few analyses of the first half of Ho's career and from a few essays by his critics. That said, the anthology is a valuable one that provides great insight into Ho's formative years, his writing process with a variety of collaborators, and the evolution of his aesthetics and philosophies in his later career. Interspersed between the essays are poems by Jayne Cortez, Richard Hamasaki, Esther Iverem, Robert Kocik, and Genny Lim, which provide glimpses into Ho's influence on other artists. For future scholars, the volume usefully includes a comprehensive discography, a production history of Ho's stage works, and a detailed curriculum vita. Fred Ho was an important artist, political activist, and thinker; one hopes that Buckley and Roberts's anthology will spark a flurry of scholarship on his music and writings. It certainly whets one's appetite for Roberts's forthcoming monograph, Resounding Afro Asia, which includes in-depth discussions of Ho.
