Among the canonical gospels, John places distinctive weight on Jesus’s impending physical absence.Footnote 1 In the synoptic accounts Jesus predicts his impending death and subsequent resurrection (e.g., Mark 8:31; 10:33–34; Matt 17:22–23; Luke 9:21–22); in John, Jesus states that he will depart and be inaccessible: “I am departing and you (pl.) will seek me, and you (pl.) will die in your sins; where I am going, you (pl.) are not able to come” (John 8:21; cf. 7:33–34).Footnote 2 Strikingly, Jesus directs this prediction of departure not only to those who oppose him but also to his closest disciples: “Children, I am with you (pl.) yet a little while. You (pl.) will seek me, and just as I said to the Jews, ‘where I am going, you (pl.) are not able to come,’ so also I speak to you (pl.) now” (13:33). These predictions of Jesus’s departure to a place where he cannot be accompanied frame his impending absence as an event affecting believers and unbelievers alike.Footnote 3
Readers of the Fourth Gospel have long recognized this Johannine emphasis’s rhetorical power, with Jörg Frey asserting that “the reason why the Gospel of John has appeared to many interpreters as the most ‘modern’ Gospel [is because] it helps the reader cope with the apparent absence of Jesus and tackles the problems of the community in the period between Easter and the Parousia.”Footnote 4 Frey observes that the “apparent absence of Jesus” creates problems for ancient and modern Johannine audiences which must be “coped” with. As I show below, how one conceptualizes the contours of these problems and the way John helps the audience cope with them depends to a large extent on one’s understanding of John’s Christology. There exists a tension between John’s Christology and his emphasis on Jesus’s physical absence: Jesus’s absence complicates the audience’s ability to accept John’s Christology, and simultaneously, John’s Christology conditions the solution that John provides to the problems caused by Jesus’s absence. While this tension is widely acknowledged, I argue that scholars often neglect the full extent to which it shapes the Johannine narrative.
To illustrate how this tension’s full import is frequently overlooked, imagine two poles in a circus tent, which, for the metaphor’s sake, represents the Fourth Gospel. Johannine scholars consistently observe these two poles (representing John’s Christology and the emphasis on Jesus’s physical absence) and recognize their prominence within the tent. Yet for the circus’s audience, the poles’ most salient function lies in anchoring a wire suspended between them, which facilitates the high-wire act. I contend that John’s plot, like the high-wire act, runs along this type of wire; John intends to direct the audience’s attention not only to the poles themselves, but to the performance playing out between them. By situating the plot along this high wire, my analysis amplifies the drama in the narrative and locates it where the authorial audience could have appreciated it.Footnote 5 At the same time, a high-wire act can only occur when the wire supporting it is attached to both poles and stretched into tension. In what follows, I briefly survey four strands of Johannine scholarship that exhibit a tendency to argue that John solves the problem of Jesus’s absence by minimizing either the adverse effects of Jesus’s absence on the audience or Jesus’s absence itself.Footnote 6 Each strand of scholarship I survey thus cuts the tension in the wire instead of fully recognizing how John maintains it to drive the plot forward.
The Heavenly Redeemer and Divine Descent-Ascent Motif
Popularized by Wayne Meeks and Charles Talbert, one strand of Johannine scholarship has contended that John’s depiction of Jesus echoes the motif of a “descending and ascending” redeemer figure common throughout the ancient Mediterranean basin.Footnote 7 Talbert, for instance, argues that John resonates with the motif’s common features, especially those from Hellenistic Jewish texts: the redeemer figure’s heavenly preexistence, descent to earth to effect redemption, and return to a heavenly dwelling (with the possible expectation of a future parousia). Readings of John recognizing this “descending and ascending” redeemer motif rightly perceive a direct relationship between John’s depiction of Jesus as a divine figure and Jesus’s absence.Footnote 8 For Meeks, this motif highlights Jesus’s “foreignness,” which John intends to resonate with the sectarian character of the Johannine community: Just as Jesus’s return to heaven reinforces his alien origin, so the community, currently alienated from the world, can anticipate their own future ascent to heaven.Footnote 9 Jesus’s very strangeness, in addition to the Paraclete’s presence, comforts the believing community, which, like Jesus, is isolated from the world.Footnote 10 While Meeks maintains that the community experiences Jesus’s absence in a real and ongoing manner, he implies that John has eliminated that absence’s negative connotations. Instead, Jesus’s absence shapes the community’s understanding of both Jesus and themselves in relation to the world. Meeks’s perspective on Jesus’s absence depends on the community viewing Jesus’s ascent as a standard component of this motif and as judgment on nonbelievers.Footnote 11
Godfrey Nicholson emphasizes that Jesus’s departure is a necessary component of the “descending and ascending” redeemer motif to an even greater extent: “the one who descended to this world had to ascend to the world above … To those who would say that the anointed of God is to remain on into the age (12:34), the Evangelist has made it clear that the Son of Man came in order to depart.”Footnote 12 By reasoning that Jesus’s departure is included in the purpose for which he came to earth, Nicholson lowers the offense that Jesus’s absence generates and neuters the tension between John’s Christology and Jesus’s absence, effectively making the latter an essential feature of the former. As I will argue in Chapter 7, this approach undermines both the way John describes Jesus’s absence as offensive to believers and nonbelievers alike and the purpose which, I contend, John attaches to Jesus’s departure. Furthermore, by construing Jesus’s departure as a necessary aspect of his role as a divine redeemer, these readings, in my assessment, fail to account adequately for John’s emphasis on the benefits of Jesus’s presence for the authorial audience and how those benefits can be accessed in Jesus’s absence.Footnote 13
Reconstructions of the Johannine Community
Toward the end of History and Theology of the Fourth Gospel, J. Louis Martyn argues that Jesus’s absence (and the Paraclete’s coming) triggers the Gospel’s two-level drama, for Jesus’s absence requires the community to reframe how Jesus remains present with them.Footnote 14 By “two-level drama,” Martyn means that Jesus traditions preserved in the Gospel have been expanded and reframed to address the audience’s specific circumstances: their expulsion from the synagogue and experiences of opposition.Footnote 15 On Martyn’s reading, the community has emerged from conflict with the synagogue over the community’s belief that Jesus is the Messiah, the meaning of Jesus’s signs, and “the relationship between Jesus and Moses”/the Torah.Footnote 16 Although Martyn’s reading resonates with Meeks’s in that both focus on the Johannine community, which is in conflict with the world around it (particularly the synagogue), Martyn gives much greater prominence to how Jesus’s absence troubles that audience and prompts many of John’s distinctive narrative features.Footnote 17
Martyn recognizes that for an audience struggling with opposition and the implications of Jesus’s continued physical absence, a major concern is effective presence, namely, whether the absent Jesus remains powerful and at work in their lives.Footnote 18 Jesus’s absence causes fear among the community for “[t]hey are left behind in ‘enemy territory’ without their leader. From their point of view, the Lord is departing in midstream, so to speak.”Footnote 19 Other scholars, such as Christian Dietzfelbinger, following Martyn’s lead in recognizing a two-level drama, likewise accent the effects of Jesus’s departure on the audience: “This is a central theme of the Farewell Discourses. Their great concern is less misgiving about Jesus’s death, having once occurred, than about his present absence, his apparent ineffectiveness and powerlessness.”Footnote 20 Similarly, Martinus de Boer argues that the audience, particularly in defending their beliefs to others, struggled with the fact that “[t]he Messiah is not supposed to disappear from the scene, as Jesus of Nazareth did, even after what was supposed to be his greatest and climactic messianic sign, his resurrection from the dead.”Footnote 21 Scholars such as Martyn, Dietzfelbinger, and de Boer, among others, thus highlight the way Jesus’s absence accentuates for the audience the disappointment of a delayed parousia, the temporal distance from the events of Easter, the difficulties caused by opposition, and the implications of those difficulties for the effectiveness of Jesus’s power in their present reality.Footnote 22
According to these scholars, John responds to his audience’s struggles by paradoxically highlighting Jesus’s absence and yet maintaining that Jesus himself remains present and active in the Paraclete. As Martyn observes, “while I am confident that the problem posed by Jesus’ departure to the Father is a real one, I am equally confident that the Johannine church would emphatically deny that Jesus is now absent from the world in an absolute sense.”Footnote 23 John’s introduction of the Paraclete “solves” the paradox, for in the Paraclete, Jesus himself is present: “The Paraclete makes Jesus present on earth as the Son of Man who binds together heaven and earth (1:51). Therefore the Son of Man cannot be located exclusively either in heaven or on earth … the second Paraclete looks like the first [i.e., Jesus] for the sake of the two-level drama.”Footnote 24
Martyn and the other scholars discussed above rightly recognize that the tension arising from the narrative’s emphasis on the significance of both Jesus’s presence and his absence shapes how the Gospel’s audience could interpret the narrative and relate it to their own experiences. At the same time, however, these scholars’ perspectives illustrate several tendencies that can lead to what I argue is a failure to pull the wire sufficiently taut between the poles of John’s Christology (i.e., the significance of Jesus’s person) and Jesus’s absence. First, despite the focus on the Johannine community’s conflict with the synagogue, for many scholars, Jesus’s absence seems to be consequential only for those who believe in him. On the one hand, this emphasis makes sense, given that the usual focal point for examinations of Jesus’s absence is the Farewell Discourse – speeches Jesus gives to prepare his disciples for his impending absence.Footnote 25 On the other hand, this focus neglects key passages that describe Jesus’s absence as a problem for those who reject him (7:33–34; 8:21–22; 12:26, 35), including John 13:33, which I quoted in my opening paragraph. Here, Jesus – right at the outset of the Farewell DiscourseFootnote 26 – explicitly frames his address to his disciples with reference to his previous remarks on his absence to his interlocutors.Footnote 27 John emphasizes the consequences of Jesus’s absence both for those who believe in him and for those who reject him and then uses the interplay between those consequences for the Gospel’s rhetorical aims.
Second, amidst diverse proposals for the audience’s circumstances and how Jesus’s absence affects them runs a common assumption that the audience’s struggle with opposition is the most significant factor in their grappling with Jesus’s absence.Footnote 28 I affirm that John places a particular emphasis on opposition and that his description of Jesus’s opponents seems more generalized than those in the Synoptics so as to allow easier application to the audience’s own circumstances. Yet as the decades since Martyn’s proposal have shown, no single construal of the audience’s precise circumstances has achieved consensus.Footnote 29 While detailed reconstructions ostensibly arise from the data in the text, when they are then used to interpret the text, the result inevitably becomes circular and self-fulfilling.Footnote 30
In the end, those who reconstruct the Johannine community’s circumstances to explain John’s stress on Jesus’s absence recognize how a tension between the significance of Jesus’s person (especially as an actor on the community’s behalf) and Jesus’s absence pervades the narrative. Yet these scholars contend that John solves the tension through elimination: Jesus is not really absent since the Spirit-Paraclete replaces Jesus. Martyn speaks of Jesus’s “return in the person of the Paraclete,” and Raymond Brown states that “Not two presences [i.e., Jesus and the Paraclete] but the same presence is involved.”Footnote 31 Although allowing a theoretical distinction between the two figures, Martyn, Brown, and others essentially end up identifying Jesus and the Spirit-Paraclete, in that the Spirit-Paraclete is the presence of Jesus.Footnote 32 In the absence of a mechanism that explains how ancient audiences would have understood the Spirit-Paraclete to represent Jesus’s presence without collapsing the two figures into one, however, this depiction of the Spirit-Paraclete does injustice to how John carefully maintains a distinction between Jesus and the Spirit-Paraclete (see further, Ch. 9).Footnote 33 Furthermore, when Martyn frames the community’s underlying concern as a struggle with opposition (internal or external), he implies that it is Jesus’s (apparent) inability to act on the community’s behalf that the audience most struggles with.Footnote 34 As a result, the Spirit-Paraclete solves only this implication of Jesus’s physical absence. While I concur that Jesus’s ability to act on the audience’s behalf remains a concern (cf. Ch. 9), I maintain that his absence connotes a more fundamental problem for the audience which the Spirit-Paraclete addresses: access to the Father.Footnote 35
The Temple Motif
Over the past three decades, a growing subdivision of Johannine scholarship has focused on the temple motif and its role in John.Footnote 36 Like the other perspectives I have surveyed so far, scholars arguing for a Johannine temple motif recognize a tension between the shape of John’s Christology and the issue of Jesus’s absence. Emphasizing the crisis created by the temple’s destruction in 70 CE, these scholars maintain that John aligns with Jewish literature responding to this crisis by filling the theological and cultic void generated by the temple’s destruction. In John’s case, Jesus himself replaces the temple and thereby fills the vacuum. These scholars acknowledge the inherent overlap between concerns with divine presence and temple and underscore the role of John 1:14 in orienting the subsequent narrative, perceiving (with most commentators) the Gospel’s accent on Jesus as the locus of divine presence.Footnote 37 Studies of the temple motif often track the occurrence of “temple imagery” throughout the Gospel, widening the definition of which material contributes to this motif beyond divine presence to include the cult and even Jewish festivals, all of which they incorporate in the “temple” that John’s Jesus replaces.Footnote 38 By anchoring John’s presentation of Jesus to the temple as a broad symbolic metaphor, these scholars accentuate how John’s Christology addresses the audience’s concerns arising from the Jerusalem temple’s destruction.Footnote 39
Yet connecting John’s Christology to a concept as concrete as the temple can effectively recapitulate the problem that these studies intend to solve. If John presents Jesus as the destroyed temple’s replacement, then how was the audience to understand Jesus’s death and subsequent absence, which would seem to reprise the temple’s destruction?Footnote 40 Scholars arguing that Jesus himself replaces the temple often take John 2:20–21 to indicate that the temple of Jesus’s body was raised and not destroyed.Footnote 41 Yet if Jesus’s resurrected body corresponds to the destroyed temple’s replacement, then does not the physical absence of that body/temple present a problem?Footnote 42 In response, Mary Coloe proposes that in John 14 the temple symbolism shifts from depicting Jesus as the metaphor’s tenor to placing the church in that role.Footnote 43
I will address other concerns with what I perceive to be an over-concretized connection between Jesus and the Jerusalem temple in Chapter 6.Footnote 44 For now, I merely highlight that, as with the other strands of scholarship I have surveyed so far, Coloe solves the problem of Jesus’s absence by treating it primarily as a conceptual problem. Emphasizing the Gospel’s realized eschatology, she argues that neither the temple nor Jesus is truly absent; rather John has creatively shifted the new temple concept from Jesus to the church,Footnote 45 which represents the new temple, built and inhabited by Jesus.Footnote 46
A Stoic Lens?
Both Gitte Buch-Hansen and Troels Engberg-Pedersen have approached John’s narrative through a Stoic lens. Buch-Hansen contends that John is a “story of pneumatic transformations, [where] the Johannine πνεῦμα is a pre-condition of the ultimate pneumatic event in which believers are themselves regenerated ἄνωθεν through the reception of the Holy Spirit (20:22; cf. 3:3, 5).”Footnote 47 By applying this Stoic lens, Buch-Hansen adds greater clarity to readings that emphasize the descending-ascending redeemer trajectory by taking the general arc of Jesus’s heavenly origin and return and reconfiguring it so that “the climax of the story is moved from the coming of the λόγος into the world into the complex of events related to Jesus’ departure from the world: the death on the cross, the resurrection, the ascent to the Father and, finally the infusion of the Holy Spirit. The regeneration of believers constitutes the open end of the story.”Footnote 48
Engberg-Pedersen’s monograph, John and Philosophy, takes the strengths of Buch-Hansen’s reading and develops them with greater attention to the narrative’s overall progression. With Buch-Hansen, Engberg-Pedersen sees the Stoic pneuma as the narrative’s true protagonist.Footnote 49 Dividing the Gospel into eight sections, Engberg-Pedersen identifies a philosophical question that each section raises and addresses.Footnote 50 These sections are not self-contained philosophical reflections. Instead, they are combined into an overall story that addresses the fundamental issue of Jesus’s identity and the life available through belief in him. To tell this story, John relies on a Stoic outlook (though Engberg-Pedersen allows for some hybridizing with Jewish influences),Footnote 51 specifically a Stoic conception of the “logos (God’s plan for the world) which had been with God from the beginning but which was fixed on Jesus precisely when he received the pneuma (at his baptism).”Footnote 52
Yet Engberg-Pedersen argues that the question of the relation between Jesus, the pneuma, and the logos is only part of the story, which addresses not only Jesus’s identity but also the associated issue of how humans are to relate to him.Footnote 53 For Engberg-Pedersen, the tension between John’s Christology and Jesus’s departure drives the entire narrative. Jesus’s departure is the precondition for the pneuma’s coming; only with the pneuma’s advent was a full understanding possible of Jesus’s identity and of how to relate rightly to him.Footnote 54 The Farewell Discourse clarifies that the disciples did not grasp “the fact that Jesus was resurrected and went back to the Father, that is, his return as opposed to his having come (in some sense) from the Father, a point that many understand. It is the fact of his return that shows fully who and what Jesus is.”Footnote 55 Even more than the other strands of scholarship I have surveyed, Engberg-Pedersen recognizes the way the tension between John’s Christology and departure shapes the narrative.
Although my own reading aligns with Engberg-Pedersen’s concerning the significance of this tension in the Johannine plot, we disagree in our diagnosis of John’s solution to the problem of Jesus’s departure. For Engberg-Pedersen, the Farewell Discourse functions to encourage the audience in their faith and calls the post-Easter audience, which has received the pneuma, to understand and live according to their faith. It is only through the pneuma that anyone can understand Jesus rightly. The post-Easter audience has received the pneuma in the Paraclete, whom they receive immediately after Jesus’s departure. On Engberg-Pedersen’s reading, Jesus is never truly absent from the audience because Jesus and the Paraclete are fundamentally identical and the Paraclete comes immediately after (or even simultaneously to) Jesus’s departure.Footnote 56 Engberg-Pedersen’s reading, for all its strengths, repeats what I have argued is a tendency to resolve the tension between John’s Christology and Jesus’s absence through elimination. By collapsing all distinctions between Jesus and the Paraclete (to an even greater degree than is done by Martyn, Brown, and others), he contends that John’s answer to the question of Jesus’s absence is essentially that Jesus is not absent, but rather that he is present as pneuma.Footnote 57
Summary: A Neglected Tension
Each reading discussed so far configures John’s Christology with different nuances, yet each recognizes that Jesus’s departure and absence generate a tension with that Christology, a tension that implies problems for those in John’s audience who accept John’s characterization of Jesus. For instance, Nicholson argues that Jesus’s departure was part of his purpose in coming to the earth; Martyn highlights how Jesus’s absence threatens believers who feel isolated, alone, and cut off from the power and care of Jesus, their Messiah; based on the conclusion that John describes Jesus as the “new temple,” Coloe responds to how Jesus’s departure could be understood to recapitulate the Jerusalem temple’s destruction so that believers would still lack a place to encounter God’s presence; Engberg-Pedersen argues that misunderstandings of the nature and significance of Jesus’s departure drive the narrative, and it is only through properly understanding the necessity of Jesus’s return to the Father that one can fully comprehend the relationship between the logos and pneuma essential to John’s Christology. Although these readings of the Johannine narrative differ in their methodology and approach, each proposes a generally similar understanding of how John resolves the tension between Christology and Jesus’s absence: John minimizes the reality of Jesus’s ongoing absence and thereby resolves the tension, either by describing Jesus’s absence as empowering for the community’s own understanding of their identityFootnote 58 or by implying that Jesus himself remains present through the Spirit-Paraclete’s facilitation.Footnote 59
In contrast, I contend that while John seeks to mitigate the effects of Jesus’s absence on the Gospel’s audience, he does not eliminate the tension by minimizing the reality of that absence. Rather, John accentuates the tension between his understanding of Jesus’s identity and Jesus’s absence and employs that tension rhetorically throughout the narrative. I argue that John configures Jesus’s departure as akin to a deity’s departure in judgment on impious worshippers in a manner that echoes the rhetorical moves identifiable in other texts that also address the issue of a deity’s departure or inaccessibility. John, like other texts, exploits common motifs of divine departure and absence to differentiate between two groups – the impious who are responsible for the deity’s absence and now remain cut off from that deity’s presence, and the pious who remain in relationship with the deity and for whom the deity provides new means of encountering the divine presence. I elaborate in what follows on the thesis to be developed in this book, but even now it should be clear that my argument, like those of the scholars discussed above, depends on a particular formulation of John’s Christology.
A Christology of the Divine Presence
Throughout this book I describe John’s Christology as one of enfleshed divine presence, arguing that John describes Jesus as the presence of the God of Israel manifested in human flesh.Footnote 60 While my argument’s exegetical basis will follow in Chapter 5, here I clarify what I mean by each term in this descriptive phrase. I use the expression “enfleshed” to capture John’s stress on Jesus’s physicality. This is not to say that John emphasizes Jesus’s physical characteristics; although occasionally John references various parts of Jesus’s body, descriptions of Jesus’s physical appearance remain largely absent from the narrative.Footnote 61 Rather, John depicts Jesus as God’s presence (more on this term below) manifested in particular human flesh, namely the flesh of Jesus from Nazareth (1:45).Footnote 62 While John’s portrait of divine enfleshment was certainly distinctive in the ancient worldFootnote 63 – in that John emphasizes Jesus’s complete humanity rather than depicting Jesus as the temporary apparition of a deity in human form (as was common in epiphanic narratives)Footnote 64 – recent studies by Deborah Forger and Brittany Wilson, among others, have shown that the expectation that the God of Israel could manifest himself in bodily form was common in the milieu of second Temple Judaism.Footnote 65 These studies highlight that despite its innovative features, John’s depiction of Jesus was nevertheless comprehensible to ancient audiences through the leveraging of conceptions of divine manifestation, particularly of Israel’s God, common in the authorial audience’s symbolic world.
Applying the term “divine presence” to John’s depiction of Jesus is likewise far from novel. Scholars frequently use language of God’s presence to describe John’s portrait of Jesus, stating that Jesus in John is the “new localization of God’s presence on earth,”Footnote 66 the “locus of divine presence,”Footnote 67 “a special locus for access to God,”Footnote 68 “the true place of God’s presence on earth,”Footnote 69 or “the place for God’s presence in his person.”Footnote 70 As I will argue in Chapters 5 and 6, however, John likens Jesus not to the structure in which God’s presence dwells (as each of the scholars quoted above implies), but rather to the one who dwells in that structure.Footnote 71 According to John, Jesus shares attributes that characterized the God of Israel (e.g., distinction from terrestrial creation, ability to bestow life),Footnote 72 speaks and acts on God’s behalf,Footnote 73 and in his person provides a visual and physical encounter with God himself.Footnote 74
John’s narrative resonates with narratives of deities manifesting themselves to humans, common throughout the Greco-Roman world. Yet John’s depiction of Jesus is not as straightforward as stories where Athena or Zeus simply appear in physical form. Rather, John also describes Jesus as a figure distinguishable from God, namely as the Son of the Father, who himself uses the appellation “God” (θεός) to refer to the Father (17:3; 20:17). In maintaining that Jesus is a discrete agent who nevertheless legitimately manifests God’s presence and is rightly called God himself (20:28), John seems to depend on an understanding of divinity common in the ancient milieu: God’s divinity was “extendable,” to borrow a phrase from Crispin Fletcher-Louis.Footnote 75 That is, the God of Israel could extend his being into other figures without a loss of being or glory; the divine extensions remain distinct entities and are properly considered and treated as divine – partaking in the divine being of the one God of Israel – yet without being viewed as separate or rival deities in their own right.Footnote 76
John builds this characterization of Jesus cumulatively throughout the narrative. Yet my terminology of “enfleshed divine presence” arises primarily from how John begins the Gospel by likening Jesus to figures who, in a range of other texts, functioned as such extensions of the one God of Israel’s divinity through whom he manifested himself in the world (e.g., Sophia, Logos, the divine name, the divine glory [i.e., כבוד, Shekinah]).Footnote 77 As Deborah Forger has demonstrated in her recent study, “These entities are not synonymous with Israel’s supreme deity, but they participate in the divinity of that ineffable and uncreated One, and thereby can also be considered divine.”Footnote 78 This is not to say that most ancient Jews had precise understandings of the metaphysical relationships between God and these other figures through whom God extended his divinity.Footnote 79 Various texts seem to conceptualize these relationships differently, and many seem to simply take for granted that the God of Israel is uniquely one, while simultaneously allowing that other figures can be understood and treated as divine.Footnote 80 Consequently, in this book, I use “enfleshed divine presence” rather than “God’s enfleshed presence” to highlight that John portrays Jesus not as indistinguishable from the God of Israel, but as a figure who functions as an extension of the one God of Israel’s divinity embodied as the human person Jesus Christ.Footnote 81
Yet while I will later demonstrate that the conception of Jesus as the enfleshed divine presence arises from the text of John itself (cf. Ch. 5), my primary goal in this book is not to engage in debates about first-century formulations of divinity and monotheism. Rather, I seek to establish how perceiving Jesus as the enfleshed divine presence shapes the Johannine narrative and provides a particular vantage point on the tension between John’s Christology and his emphasis on Jesus’s absence. I contend that if John’s depiction of Jesus was comprehensible in an ancient symbolic world of how deities manifest their presence, then John’s stress on Jesus’s departure would have likewise activated understandings of divine departure and absence prevalent in that same symbolic world.
Divine Presence, Divine Absence, and the Argument of This Study
My core argument in this book is that John makes the tension between the significance of Jesus’s presence and Jesus’s departure integral to the entire narrative. John does not simply characterize Jesus as the enfleshed divine presence. Rather John leverages this characterization in tandem with motifs of divine presence and absence common in epiphanic narratives, which pervaded Greco-Roman texts of various genres and media. In nuce, epiphanic narratives describe the encounter of a human with a deity manifesting his or her presence in a physical form – normally but not always in human form.Footnote 82 Across this wide range of generic instantiations, epiphanic narratives exhibit some consistent features, as Georgia Petridou has shown in her recent study.Footnote 83 One persistent theme across epiphanic narratives is the challenge of recognizing the “divinity behind the all too human façade.”Footnote 84 This description of an epiphanic narrative as one in which characters struggle to discern the divine presence and in which the deity’s posture to those characters hinges on the characters’ attitudes and actions toward the deity generates clear resonances with the Johannine narrative, as I will show in Part II. Many of these other accounts conclude with the deity departing, having judged (often in a violent manner) those who failed to recognize their presence, while providing means for continued access to their presence (often through establishing a cult) for the pious.Footnote 85
Yet it is at this point that John’s distinctive portrait of Jesus as not merely a deity’s apparition, but as the God of Israel’s presence extended into a fully human life becomes significant.Footnote 86 In common epiphanic narratives, the deity was expected to return to heaven.Footnote 87 While the Jewish Scriptures understood God as having a heavenly dwelling place,Footnote 88 they repeatedly accent an expectation for the God of Israel to dwell in Israel’s midst in a particular location – the tabernacle and then the temple.Footnote 89 God’s withdrawal of his presence from among Israel signified judgment.Footnote 90 John depicts Jesus as providing unprecedented access to, and sight of, the glory of God; Jesus is the only one who has seen God (6:46), and Jesus alone so fully makes God’s presence manifest that he can tell his followers that if they have seen him they have seen the Father (14:9). In this way, John depicts Jesus as the fulfilment of expectations for encountering God’s presence. Yet, because John simultaneously highlights Jesus’s rejection, death, departure, and absence, the authorial audience would expect John to provide an explanation for these narrative features that matches the significance John attaches to Jesus’s presence and addresses the natural connections between the withdrawal of God’s presence and his judgment.
Returning to my earlier metaphor of a high-wire act, I contend in this study that the Gospel’s plot operates along the tension the narrative generates between divine presence and absence. As I have argued above, Johannine scholars frequently recognize the tension in the Gospel between the significance of Jesus’s presence and his absence. Yet they often treat that tension as a conceptual one, a tension that remains problematic for the audience until it is resolved and no longer exists. A high-wire act, however, depends on tension being present in the wire: The tension in the wire must remain for the wire to support the performer’s movements. Likewise, I argue that John does not deny an ongoing dimension to Jesus’s absence but instead makes the tension resulting from that absence integral to the overall narrative. John does this by recasting Jesus’s absence as not merely the absence of the physical Jesus in se, but as divine absence. This recasting allows the narrative to accentuate the tension between Jesus’s presence and absence and to use it for two rhetorical purposes: to inculcate belief among those considering the Gospel’s claims and to strengthen Christ-followers struggling to remain faithful in Jesus’s physical absence. Specifically, the tension generated through the motifs of presence and absence amplifies the consequences of belief and unbelief, consequences which then serve to strengthen the audience’s group identity and make participating in that identity attractive to the audience.
Perceiving how John develops and employs this tension between divine presence and absence throughout the narrative depends on a reconstruction of the authorial audience’s symbolic world. As I alluded to above, even a cursory review of Johannine scholarship confirms that understanding John’s Christology requires careful attention to ancient conceptions of deity and, specifically, to the ways in which deities were present and active in the world. Most scholars undertaking this task, however, primarily seek to clarify how John’s Christology would have been comprehensible to a diaspora Jewish audience that maintained a view of their God as the one supreme deity in negotiation with the pressures and influences of Greco-Roman cosmologies.Footnote 91 Yet if understanding how Jesus uniquely reveals the God of Israel in the world requires attention to ancient conceptions of deity and divine presence, then should not scholars likewise investigate this same symbolic world when considering how John portrays Jesus’s departure and absence?
My study seeks to fill this scholarly lacuna. If, as I contend, an ancient audience of John’s Gospel would have understood Jesus as the enfleshed divine presence, then properly conceptualizing how that audience would have perceived the Gospel’s stress on Jesus’s absence requires comparisons to ways ancient audiences would have explained experiences of a deity’s inaccessibility and perceived absence. Given this emphasis on the authorial audience’s symbolic world, Part I seeks to reconstruct the broad contours of the symbolic world (focusing primarily on motifs of divine absence and departure) through which the authorial audience would have interpreted the two poles of the tension that John employs throughout his narrative. Part II turns to John’s Gospel, examining how it develops and leverages a tension between divine presence and divine absence throughout the narrative in line with its rhetorical aims.
