Heading up his long and impressive list of publications in the field of theatre ethnography, Matthew Reason's The Young Audience is described as a monograph, which of course in the literal sense, it is: a work of scholarship, written by a single author. Many voices, however, contribute to this book, producing a colourful and fascinating account of children's experiences of theatre. Children's drawings and interviews are central to the book, stemming from a research study with primary schoolchildren. Interspersed between the main sections of the book are commentaries by children's writer, Philip Pullman, Unicorn Theatre's Artistic Director, Tony Graham and Danish creators of theatre for children, Peter Manscher and Peter Jancovic. Add to this an arresting set of photographs by Lisa Barnard of children watching theatre productions and practical sets of sample questions which can be used to start children talking about their experiences and we have here a book which will be welcomed by teachers and researchers in the arts.
In recent decades there has been an increase in arts ‘outreach’ programmes. Visiting professionals providing arts workshops are becoming part of the landscape in many schools. The first motivation for such programmes was to try to build the audience of the future: by getting children to engage in the arts at an early age, they would, it was hoped, learn to value them and support them in later life. Some Arts Council funding was available to organisations making a contribution to educational work and so gradually educational activities and even whole departments were developed within orchestras, dance, opera and theatre companies. Reason's specialism is theatre but much of what he describes is readily transferable to other arts. As a music education researcher, I have asked myself many of the questions that Reason addresses and coincidentally have used a similar research method to explore the work of an orchestra in partnership with several London primary schools.
The book is arranged in three main sections: Part One, ‘Contexts and Questions’, presents the arguments for children experiencing theatre. Reason discusses the received wisdom amongst policy-makers: that the arts should be used to enhance learning. Theatre practices can be used to enliven any area of the school curriculum, from science to humanities and from citizenship to environmental studies. Participation in expressive arts projects is envisaged as contributing to various aspects of academic achievement and to the development of the ‘whole child’. This idea is certainly espoused by head teachers I have interviewed. However, Reason also describes a shift in attitude towards a ‘more essentially artistic form’, art for art's sake, in which aesthetic quality is of prime importance. Reason points out that the power balance in ‘theatre for children’ is firmly on the side of the providers: children are at the receiving end of whatever adults design for them. Children need productions that are ‘suitable and rewarding for the audiences at that particular moment in their lives’: they should be offered quality and respect, and in order to achieve this it is important to access their responses to live theatre.
Part Two, ‘The Theatrical Experience’, is constructed around the artwork of 98 Scottish children in visual arts workshops conducted by Reason and his team following theatrical performances they had watched. The researchers used drawing and painting activities to give the children a familiar and reassuring platform from which they could discuss their memories of the performance with the researchers and with each other. This methodology is commonly used in such diverse areas as clinical psychology, market research, media research and art therapy and is a way of avoiding directly questioning people who might be reluctant to talk about deep feelings, allowing them to project their ideas or feelings onto the paper. Drawing is also an activity central to most children's lives, something with which they feel comfortable and which they enjoy. The children were consulted as the experts on what they had seen and their opinions and beliefs were respected, with the researchers avoiding any ‘teacher-like’ testing activities.
The interest in this research comes from the children's drawn and spoken reactions to the illusions of a theatrical production: on one hand they showed they knew that what they were watching was not real (‘a person dressed up in a costume’ as one child says) but they also were able to suspend their disbelief, by for example ignoring clearly visible puppeteers and concentrating their attention on the puppet ‘actors’. The great majority of children drew and painted images that they had not actually seen on the stage, pictures from their heads. In talking about their artwork, the children were able to perceive the processes behind the production of the illusion: Reason points out that this is a more sophisticated level of engagement with the medium than is perhaps expected of young children. He writes of ‘theatrical competence’: the children's ability to ‘decode’ a theatrical performance, as Bourdieu would put it.
Part Three, ‘Enhancing Engagement’, describes how the experimental workshops had the effect of developing and deepening the children's engagement with the production they had seen. It investigates what may remain in children's memories after the event and how this can be extended as children play with ideas and maybe think in philosophical terms about what they have seen. He also presents a model for facilitating children's thinking about a production which he calls ‘Talking about Theatre’. Reason describes these chapters as ‘toolboxes’ and has included some useful lists of possible questions to get children thinking. This section will be of special value to teachers, researchers and artists working with children.
Reason questions the nature of teachers' packs which are frequently provided in order that a class may be prepared in advance for the production they are to see. He points out the disadvantage inherent in many such packs: being designed to highlight the relevance of their work to National Curriculum requirements, they can narrow down and ‘educationalise’ the experience. He also suggests that for some children, too much advance preparation may detract from the excitement of the production. However, in the aftermath of the performance he believes that children, as much as any adult audience, should have the opportunity to extend their experience by engaging imaginatively and intellectually with what they can remember. He discusses the rationale for using drawing as a research tool and makes links between the kinds of questions his team employed and the approach used in Philosophy for Children, although aesthetic enquiry moves in very different directions from philosophical enquiry.
The set of model questions gives ample scope for teachers and researchers to facilitate group discussion after a production. My feeling is that this model does not take into account Reason's earlier point that some children may not feel comfortable to engage in this kind of discussion without some mediating task like drawing or painting. His instructions seem to be ruling this out: ‘Sit in a circle with the group and start to explore memories of the performance’ and ‘Everyone in the group should take a turn sharing a memory of the performance’. The variety of extremely individual responses previously captured in the drawing task might be less accessible in these circumstances. That said, however, this is a very useful resource, showing how to develop ideas, explaining possible learning outcomes, offering prompt questions, suggesting activities with prompts on cards and providing a great supply of open-ended questions which should persuade even the most reluctant group to respond. Interviewers wishing to try out the artwork and talking method can draw upon guidance in Chapter Four as well as the many examples of expert questioning quoted in Part Two.
Reason's message in this book is clear: children may or may not be the ‘audience of the future’ – we can't know. But they certainly are ‘the audience of the present’. Whether in theatre, as described here, or in other art-forms such as music or dance, we as adults should make opportunities to help them to discover and understand their experiences of being that audience. As children acquire knowledge, together with the ability to reflect and think critically about what they have seen, they become ‘empowered by their own cultural experiences’. This book demonstrates how, when done well, educational research can have transformative and emancipatory effects on participants.
