Following Aulus Gellius’ paradigmatic description (NA 16.13.8–9), Roman colonies have traditionally been regarded as those political communities, ‘rather small miniatures and in a way reproductions’, where, in contrast to municipia, the inhabitants had all the laws and institutions (iura institutaque omnia) of the Roman people. While Gellius acknowledged the difficulty of distinguishing coloniae and municipia in the western provinces of the Empire, he would not have encountered an analogous problem across much of the eastern Mediterranean under Roman rule. In the Greek East, local municipal life was based on a system of Hellenistic poleis with councils (βουλαί), people (δῆμοι) and magistracies (ἄρχοντες) mostly predating Rome's provincialisation. It was not until the mid-first century b.c. that Roman colonies began to be established in regions such as Achaea, Macedonia and Asia where Greek institutions and language dominated. The Colonia Iulia Augusta Philippensium settled on the former site of the Argead Philippi provides us with such an example. As evidenced in the epigraphic materials recently edited by C. Brélaz, Corpus des inscriptions grecques et latines de Philippes II (2014), the new political community was largely composed of legionary veterans with Roman onomastics, who referred to their council as an ordo decurionum; their people was a populus and the magistrates of the colony were headed by the IIviri. Latin public inscriptions became predominant and the colonists could attend a religious space identified as a Capitolium in the urban centre. Within the territory of the colony, however, the inhabitants of the vici still showed significant Thracian traces, while offices with a Greek origin such as the agonothetes and gymnasiarch are also documented in the corpus. In a.d. 361/2, by contrast, Himerius would dedicate a Greek speech to the city in which its royal Macedonian heritage and the role of Philip II in its foundation were extolled.
C. Brélaz and J. Demaille analyse the interesting institutional, cultural and cultic evolution and heritage of the Roman colony of Philippi in this volume, and their paper can be considered a model for the issues covered in all the other contributions. The book results from a conference organised in Strasbourg in 2013, which sought to study the interactions between eastern Roman colonies and the environment in which they were settled. The list of contributors is impressive. As B. notes in his introduction, the settlement of Roman colonists in the Greek East has generated increasing interest in the last three decades: one thinks, above all, of F. Millar in H. Solin and M. Kajava (eds), Roman Eastern Policy and Other Studies in Roman History (1990), 7–58; M. Sartre, Electrum 5 (2001), 111–52; and G. Salmeri, A. Raggi and A. Baroni (eds), Colonie romane nel mondo Greco (2004). Nonetheless, previous approaches did not achieve the level of detail and geographical completeness presented in this book. There are seventeen chapters, ranging from Albania to Syria and Judaea, and even including cities in Italy which show a significant Greek heritage. This regional breadth is also reflected in the variety of modern languages used in the volume, with French leading (ten papers plus introduction, conclusion and indexes), then English (five) and Italian (two). Readers will find helpful bilingual abstracts at the beginning of each of the papers.
Apart from the coherent introduction and conclusion provided by B., the book largely presents a collection of case-studies of the best documented Roman colonies in the eastern provinces. As is common in these cases, papers vary not only in length and geographical scope, but also in depth and quality. While all the authors manage to discuss the central topic in their contributions, not all of them successfully incorporate one of the clear conclusions that can be extracted from this book: that is, the environment of the eastern Mediterranean was not only ‘Greek’, nor were the colonies solely composed of Latin speakers from Italy. While this reality becomes evident in papers such as that of N. Belayche (focused on cultic interactions in Pisidia), it remains somewhat overlooked by those who merely document the continuity of Roman political institutions and the increasing visibility of Greek inscriptions. The dependence of the volume on epigraphic evidence is predictably heavy, alongside the discussion of coinage, archaeology and, to a lesser extent, literary sources. The main drawback appears when simple catalogues are provided; in itself, the number of inscriptions is seldom statistically significant, and several of the conclusions to the papers lack the theoretical nuances advanced by B. in his own contributions. A noteworthy exception is A. Kuhn's discussion of the phenomenon of ‘colonial Hellenism’ applied to the civic life of Alexandria Troas. While this colony in north-west Asia Minor could have deserved more detailed study (as in the case of Corinth, the subject of papers by J. Goeken and B. Millis), there are other instances where the lack of co-authored studies is not easily justifiable. The most obvious case is Antioch by Pisidia, where H. Bru and G. Labarre cover very similar topics. Conversely, the chapter on Berytus by A.-R. Hošek appears to this reviewer too much focused on the evolution of the Hieropolitans, rather than on the urban centre from which they separated in the third century a.d.
E. Deniaux presents an overview of the evidence from Dyrrachium, Byllis and Buthrotum, and A. Rizakis discusses the inner political implications of the foundations of Buthrotum and Patras at the end of the republican period. N. Giannakopoulos’ study of the materials from Kassandreia and Pella is very comprehensive. The remains of the Roman colony of Sinope are less abundant, and the concluding remarks made by C. Barat are not always compelling, particularly as regards the arguments based on the Antikythera findings. In the case of Knossos, M. Baldwin Bowsky's classification of the non-material evidence is probably too narrow and the concept of ‘normalisation’ questionable, although his brief analysis of sigillata usage is potentially interesting. Likewise, B. Isaac's prudent approach to the nature of Caesarea Maritima in the light of inscriptions is correct, but he could have provided a longer discussion of the particularities of Aelia Capitolina. Finally, whereas E. Miranda De Martino's paper on Naples and the survival of its Greek cultural identity appears very pertinent, the model presented by K. Korhonen on the Augustan colonies of Sicily is not so obviously relevant.
For its level of expertise and geographical completeness, this volume should be read by scholars with an interest in local interactions between the diverse populations of the Graeco-Roman world. The book is well edited, with helpful indexes, a very comprehensive bibliography and a negligible number of typos (e.g. 132). The reader should, nonetheless, be aware that the book does not resolve an important set of questions, indicating the future research potential of the topic. The issue of double communities (with Roman colonies and Greek poleis co-existing) is only tangentially covered; É. Guerber's exhaustive paper on Apamea Myrlea does not settle the discussion of the local citizenships of Roman colonies, not least because he overlooks the case of Pasikrates, Dio Chrysostom's father. Even so, these papers will hopefully encourage further investigation of material that has continued to grow since 2013: for example, A. Filges, Münzbild und Gemeinschaft (2015), on colonial coinages in Asia Minor; new corpora of inscriptions from Albania and Macedonia (e.g. CIGIME III); and recent studies on the territory of Antioch of Pisidia, which show an even higher degree of Greek, Roman and indigenous interaction and variety.
