In the post–Cold War, “end of ideology” world, “culture” has emerged as an all-purpose explanation for a wide variety of contentious issues. Culture is invoked in debates over the “politics of recognition,” multiculturalism, and indigenous rights; in the conduct of international relations, armed conflict, and development aid programs; in the crafting of immigration and citizenship policies; and in the creation of “diversity” training courses. In these matters and many more, “culture” signifies very basic group and ethnic differences. The explanatory priority placed on culture, understood in this way, is not limited to any particular political faction or ideological orientation. The international relations (IR) theorist accounting for the breakup of a country like Yugoslavia, the French politician worried about the wearing of Muslim headscarves in schools, the indigenous leader demanding the repatriation of cultural property, or the corporate executive anxious to foster “intercultural communication” across a globalized workforce may all be speaking a similar language of fundamental and enduring difference. Like never before, we imagine the world in terms of different cultures.
At first glance, the ubiquitous talk of culture would seem to be good news. “Celebrating difference” is an improvement over ethnocentrism, recognizing “subaltern identities” a step forward from their suppression, and “cultural competence” and understanding better than cultural ignorance and indifference. Yet all is not well, as Joana Breidenbach, an anthropologist, and Pál Nyíri, a historian “from an anthropological perspective,” are at great pains to demonstrate in their Seeing Culture Everywhere. The concept of culture that has risen to prominence, they argue, that has come to have such an outsized causal role in accounts of human affairs, is deeply flawed. In so much of this talk, they contend, cultures are treated as discontinuous and integral wholes, as some “fossilized” essence handed down uninterrupted from the distant past, as a “straitjacket of values” that determine how people act. Breidenbach and Nyíri believe that “culture matters.” The contemporary challenge they see is how to retain sensitivity to cultural differences while avoiding an essentialist, “container view” of culture that can “have the dangerous consequences of a self-fulfilling prophesy” (29) as well as work to obscure other important social forces, from historical change and internal diversity to social exclusion, economic hardship, and the instrumentalization of “particular traditions” by “political and business elites to serve their own interests” (53).
Breidenbach and Nyíri offer no general theory of why the “culture consciousness” they document is so pervasive. Rather, they identify its roots in a number of contemporaneous trends that have brought peoples into greater contact, increased ethnic self-consciousness, and made issues of ethnic difference more contentious: political changes with the end of the Cold War, growing diversity due to immigration, globalization and the rise of the knowledge economy, the “cultural turn” in the humanities and social sciences, the U.S. civil rights movement and demands for minority rights and recognition, new media of communication, and the resurgence of public religion. In this new world, as the old grand narratives have fallen away, they argue, deterministic versions of cultural difference have arisen to take their place.
The six long chapters of Seeing Culture Everywhere analyze the new culturalist grand narrative in a variety of specific cases, beginning at the international and then moving down to the subnational levels. The early chapters contend in particular with the work of the late Samuel Huntington. In the first, the authors seek to show that Huntington's “civilizations”—of his “clash of civilizations” thesis—as well as similar IR discourses of “regional cultural essence,” such as discussions of “Asian Values” and “Eurasianism,” are “useless as analytical categories” (45). All are wrongheaded cultural reductionisms, they argue, that have had negative consequences, including the shaping of a misguided view of Arabs and Islam in the U.S. war on terror. A “dialogue of civilizations” that traffics in the same grand abstractions, they believe, will do no better. The trust-building dialogue they propose is one that stays close to the ground, recognizes that social groups are not monolithic, and allows for the articulation of diverse interests and visions of the good life.
Breidenbach and Nyíri turn next to the world of international development, which has also taken a “cultural turn,” and in two divergent directions. One approach, linked to Huntington and Lawrence Harrison, and sometimes referred to as “neo-Weberian,” explores how culture, as values and norms, has causal significance for economic life. The authors reject this approach out of hand as “mechanistic” and “unproductive,” another instance of cultural determinism. More promising, in the authors' view, is the tentative move in key development institutions to replace universalistic and unilinear “modernization” models with a new responsiveness to recipients of aid and their ways of life, and a reflexive awareness of the cultural dynamics of the donor agencies themselves. As with relations between states, the authors stress the need to treat social groups as heterogeneous and to formulate and implement projects at the local level.
Similar concerns inform the chapter on “culturalizing violence.” Again Breidenbach and Nyíri argue against “abstract notions of group culture” (152), which they ascribe to Huntington, his student Robert Kaplan, and many others, including “self-appointed ethnic leaders.” The authors present several cases of conflict in multiethnic societies, including Rwanda, Bosnia, Afghanistan, and Iraq, to show the historicity of ethnic categories such as “Tutsi” and “Hutu” and the ways in which, under specific political conditions, these categories can be hardened, filled with new institutionalized symbols and rituals, and mobilized by elites for violent ends. These cases demonstrate, they argue, that treating ethnic identifications as timeless and incommensurable is a dangerous political mistake by the great powers because it creates a feedback loop that fosters the very sectarianism and ethnic conflict it then treats as natural and inevitable. Against assumptions of sharp ethnic boundaries, the authors underscore the importance of understanding local practice and the often fluid character of identity and tradition.
The second half of the book includes chapters on multiculturalism, protecting indigenous culture, and efforts to teach cultural competence. The authors show how the challenge of growing diversity and efforts to manage it are playing out in countries around the world. No work, to my knowledge, brings together detailed discussion of this challenge across such a wide range of contexts: the Muslim protests over the Danish cartoons, Australian citizenship tests, the patenting of Maori words and symbols, and representations of the Chinese in “intercultural communication” courses, to name but a few. The effect is not only to powerfully illustrate the claim about “seeing culture everywhere” but to identify common problems. The familiar debate about the tension between protections or exemptions given to cultural practices and the liberal demand to uphold and protect individual liberty often take the cultural practices for granted. The problem is that cultural symbols and rituals can and often do have multiple and shifting meanings. Further, as Breidenbach and Nyíri document, cultural and minority groups do not have sharp boundaries and are internally diverse. State recognition raises thorny questions that do not necessarily have a priori answers—Which groups? Who speaks for them? How is membership determined? and so on—and can have the unintended consequences of promoting rigidity and homogenization, from radicalizing ethnic identifications to transforming living traditions into formulaic caricatures of themselves.
Seeing Culture Everywhere is an important corrective to celebratory accounts of multiculturalism and to the anthropologically uninformed discussions so common in political philosophy and elsewhere. Religious and ethnic difference is one of the major dilemmas confronting modern societies and institutions. We need real understanding and invoking culture as a black box, as a deterministic abstraction, only undermines it. On this point, Breidenbach and Nyíri are convincing and helpful. At the same time, their emphasis on elite rhetoric and lack of general theory gives insufficient attention to “bottom-up” processes and structural changes driving heightened cultural consciousness and activism. They themselves vacillate between a thick view of culture as patterning human relationships and practices (103) and a thin, almost rational-choice view of culture as meanings that individuals selectively deploy (76). They champion the importance of ethnography but then conclude with simplistic checklists aimed to help “professionals to critically interrogate” cultural claims (343). Deterministic views of culture are one part of the problem; weak views are another.
