Coined in the 1930s, the term “multicultural” is used most often to describe the state of American society since the 1960s when the retention of distinctive ethnic cultures within the United States became widely recognized and prized. In her latest book, The Rise of Multicultural America: Economy and Print Culture, 1865–1915, Boston University professor Susan Mizruchi pushes back the popularly understood origins of multiculturalism, arguing that “American multiculturalism . . . emerged . . . in the late nineteenth century as the extremes of social diversity met an accelerating capitalist system” (4). Using “multiculturalism” in a deliberately anachronistic way to highlight the continuities between past and present, Mizruchi explores the transformation of the United States into a “multicultural modern capitalist society” through its print culture (2). She examines works of fiction and memoir, social reform and journalism, photography and advertising from the end of the Civil War until World War I. Based largely on her noteworthy entry in the Cambridge History of American Literature (2005), this volume is encyclopedic as well, and its sheer breadth is both its greatest strength and its greatest weakness. Mizruchi defines “multicultural America” as not only diverse but increasingly aware of its diversity, and the number and variety of works that she presents on the subject support this claim convincingly. The scope of her study reveals an increasingly pluralistic literature highly concerned over the stakes of the momentous cultural and economic shifts of its time. Mizruchi includes a spectrum of views about these changes. The chapter entitled “Indian Sacrifice in the Age of Progress,” for instance, looks at works by authors both white and Native American whose responses to the further displacement and decimation of Native American lives and culture ran the gamut from excitement over the Indian's entry into “modern life,” to mournfulness over the passing of tradition and ritual, to angry calls for resistance and reform. She provides a similar range of stances on the status of African Americans during this period. In surveying a wide array of attitudes and materials, Mizruchi demonstrates the ways in which these texts both reflected and helped create cultural, class, and ethnic diversity with all of the anxiety and potential this implied.
Although the book includes many new and insightful readings, Mizruchi often stops short of linking them to each other or to her overarching argument about the economics of the cultural shift. The organization of the chapters, although suitable for an encyclopedia, here inhibits the development of a fully realized argument. Most of the works discussed are introduced with a biography of the author or artist, followed by a summary of key texts and a short original analysis. Readers are frequently left to make their own connections among the texts and the multiple perspectives and cultures they represent. This is particularly noticeable in the chapter on cosmopolitanism. The chapter entitled “Corporate America” pairs strong readings of Theodore Dreiser and Frank Norris's representations of capitalist titans with discussions of Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller, but it makes few explicit connections to the previous chapter, “Varieties of Work,” in which Mizruchi discusses working- and middle-class immigrants, African Americans, and women. Her provocative suggestion that “a critical force in the persistence of these extreme inequalities was American multiculturalism” is thus not fully investigated (178). It is taken up indirectly toward the end of the book when Mizruchi demonstrates the ways in which many utopian novels attempted to resolve economic disparity by imagining a homogeneous society where mutual responsibility and equality follow the eradication of racial and ethnic difference. The book as a whole would have benefited from more such integrative analyses along with consideration of the encounters among the different peoples and cultures that cosmopolitanism and multiculturalism imply.
Mizruchi's discussion of marketing is most successful at synthesizing analyses of print culture, economics, and cultural diversity, reading the ways in which ads of the period portrayed and produced ethnicity and “Americanness” while working to persuade diverse audiences to desire and consume the same products. Mizruchi shows, for instance, how the ubiquitous Sapolio soap campaign used representations of the domestic (middle-class housewives) and the foreign (Jews, Gypsies, Panama, etc.) to appeal to diverse audiences while at the same time suggesting that all might be cleansed, Americanized, and harmonized through Sapolio. Providing a very different picture of America, Regal shoes, with its stereotypical Irishman proclaiming “Begora—I'd Be Happy If I Could Only ‘Get a Regal On’” suggests that everyone may want to have and be Regal, but only certain Americans can ever access the upper echelons (152). Here Mizruchi demonstrates quite effectively how concerns over the United States' immigration rates, imperialist ventures, and increasing diversity played out in the marketplace and its print tools. Although further analysis would have been beneficial, the impressive scope of Mizruchi's volume will prove useful for those seeking a survey of the period's multiplicity of texts and perspectives.
