In his book, The Art of Not being Governed, An Anarchist History of Upland Southeast Asia (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2009), James Scott writes: “In a critique of overly state-centric histories, Anthony Day points us in just this direction: ‘What would the history of Southeast Asia look like, however, if we were to take the turbulent relations between families as normative rather than a departure from the norm of the absolutist state which must ‘deal with disorder’?” (p. 36). Jeffrey Hadler is also thinking along these lines as he presents us with an excellent, well-researched, and beautifully written book (written with a strong sense of irony) focusing on “peculiar families” (p. ix). This book won the prestigious Harry Benda award for Southeast Asian Studies in 2011.
In this brilliant ethnographic, historical, and comparative sociological study of Minangkabau families and society in Sumatra, Hadler examines, interrogates, and provides us with a very different narrative and history on the “interiors and shapes of the family” which is a strong corrective to the “orderly families” constructed by Muslim reformists, Dutch colonialists and their efforts to shape patrilineal and male-dominated households, and Suharto New Order rhetoric on Javanization and hierarchy within national politics and family structure.
Hadler begins by looking at writings by and about prominent and inspiring leaders from Minangkabau who were of the first generation of “Indonesian Nationalists”—Tan Malaka (b. 1896), communist revolutionary philosopher; Haji Agus Salim (b. 1884), statesman and foreign minister; Mohammad Hatta (b. 1902), first vice president; Muhammad Yamin (b. 1903), nationalist philosopher; Muhammad Natsir (b. 1908), Islamic politician; Hamka (b.1908), theologian; Sutan Sjahrir (b. 1909), socialist and first prime minister; Rasuna Said (b. 1910), revolutionary leader and politician—and the kinds of families that these dynamic and imaginative minds were raised in: what was the philosophy and concept of “home,” perantauan (migration and travelling), power, democratic ideals, and egalitarianism in their Minangkabau households? What was the shape and exercise of female power, matrifocality, and matriliny in these homes? Hadler argues: “it is mother-centeredness that grounds the family” (p. 6). While this is a fascinating argument, we hear little about the histories of the mothers of these famous men mentioned above, or of their sisters' thoughts, in this book.
In Minangkabau “[t]he matriarchate—a combination of matrilineal inheritance and matrilocal residence as well as relative gender egalitarianism—was sustained” (p. 33). What is the history behind the resilience of the matriarchy, which persisted in spite of the efforts by Muslim reformists—in particular during the Padri Wars led by Tuanku Imam Bonjol and the neo-Wahhabis (starting in the early 1800s up to 1832)—to purify Islamic practices by eliminating “corrupting” indigenous practices, and policies by Dutch colonialists to eliminate female-dominated structures and replace them with male-head-of household regimes for the purposes of effective taxation? Hadler's conclusion, after providing convincing evidence based on Minangkabau sources, including the memoirs of Tuanku Imam Bonjol, Dutch colonial sources, and, most interestingly, comparative sociological studies (from other matrilineal societies in Sri Lanka; Negeri Sembilan, Malaysia; and Kerala, India), is: “The Minangkabau matriarchate is hard to kill” (p. 177).
What I like about this book is that unlike the predominance of state-centric histories of Southeast Asia, which view the family from the perspective of the state, or from anthropological accounts romanticizing “matrifocality,” it is centered on the family itself. Hadler notes that in one state-centric scholarly work, the family was ignored altogether: “Marsden's encyclopedic History of Sumatra bears no mention of Minangkabau family structure or the shapes of their houses.” He also demolishes Marsden and Raffles' fantasized and romanticized inventions of what “Minangkabau culture” is supposedly about. Then, he begins from the perspective of the family to see how the state (both colonial and post-independence) and Islamic reformists can become so intrusive, sometimes in very violent ways, into family structures. In his conclusion, Hadler writes that, from a state perspective, “The history of West Sumatran politics is of recurring defeat. But the story of Minangkabau culture is one of survival” (p. 180).
Hadler's story of culture as one of survival and resilience examines the changes within Minangkabau homes, their concept of childhood, the intense debates about the role of women in society, fatherhood, and the constant, dynamic re-definitions of house and family (pp. 10-5). Hadler goes into itemized detail on the financial costs and the art of building a house, and the ways in which the Dutch colonial state invented, homogenized and codified elaborate rumah gadang (the iconic longhouses) into “official regalia” and marked them as official residences for kepala laras (larashoofd—native administrative heads). Those native elites were fashioned by the Dutch to be “capable of managing a colonial bureaucracy” (p. 51). Hadler explores how those families (and those of “regular” households, missed by colonial researchers though noticed by a young scientist named Albert Bickmore, who, despite, or perhaps because of, his limited research budget gave them attention; see page 50) view the state and religious groups in their violent attempts to kill the matriarchate and replace it with patriarchy, for example, in the discussion of the text “To Question the Education of Natives” (p. 54) written in 1893 by a member of the native elite.
Hadler's unpacking of Thomas Stamford Raffles and William Marsden's production (or rather invention of) “phantom” knowledge about Sumatra, and how their “authoritative” knowledge had seriously bad implications for later Indonesianist scholarship, is insightful. He writes: “If the historiography of central Java is a romanticized narrative of syncretism, accretion, and continuity, then Minangkabau is a story of bad luck and disruption” (p. 41). He provides a balanced, if not a more sympathetic reading of Tuanku Imam Bonjol's memoirs, in particular after 1832, when the hajji returned from Mecca where the Wahhabi had fallen and the laws as studied by Haji Miskin were invalid, and when he was captured by the Dutch, ending the Padri Wars. The hajji was “no longer a man blessed with the certainty of the zealot. . . his memoir becomes a text of doubt and trepidation” (p. 30). This particular history lesson may resonate with and be particularly useful for the Acehnese, who also have a tradition of matrifocality which has come into conflict with the policing of Acehnese morality through the current implementation Shari'a law in that region.
This book is an important contribution in the fields of Southeast Asian histories/studies, feminist ethnography, Islamic studies, and family studies for many reasons. It is useful for Islamic studies because it provides a thoughtful, rigorous ethnographic study that is a strong corrective to what Lila Abu-Lughod has eloquently written against: the trend of popular scholarship on “saving poor Muslim women.” Southeast Asian Muslim matriarchates provide a contrasting example to “core-Islamic centers” in the Middle East, when it comes to studies on sexualities, families, and genders. It is also very useful and innovative book for students of gender studies, feminist theory, family studies (on family resilience), and childhood development, especially in so-called more “advanced” First World industrialized societies, such as Korea and Japan, for example, who often tend to assume that economic development translates to more egalitarianism and democratization. On the contrary, in this study, Hadler demonstrates how an indigenous Minangkabau concept of family—matriarchy and a significantly powerful role for women in the home and the public sphere—can teach the world about a different imaginary for the role and space for women, mothers, and girls, and re-imagine “peculiar families” as “normative,” rather than “shameful” (p. 8), “retrograde” (p. 31), anachronistic, or “a source of real concern” (p. 41).
In terms of methodology, the author could have provided more female narratives, oral histories, women's agency, thoughts, and voices, which could give us a very different picture of the shape of state violence, Islamic reformism, and everyday politics. Even the classical Malay texts such as the Hikayat Raja-Raja Pasai (which Hadler cites on page 11) could have been read more thoroughly for female agency and women's narratives. He could have relied more on oral histories, oral narratives, interviews, discussions and conversations with an increasing number of a young generation of new social scientists from Minangkabau producing new bodies of knowledge on this topic, including Mina Elfira, Dina Afrianty, and many others, who not only critically analyze patriarchy, but have to survive it. It would have been useful to hear the perspectives of Minang women on this, as Hadler's representation sometimes seems to be frozen in time, and a bit on the romanticized side. I wonder how Minangkabau women, or for that matter women in other parts of Sumatra, especially Aceh, will read, interpret, discuss, and react to this book in the context of everyday politics under increasingly strong Shari'a policing not only in Aceh, but Indonesia more generally. I hope that the Indonesian translation of the book will be read carefully by the Shari'a bureaucracy and police, especially in Aceh, and also by people in East Timor, where matriarchal societies are also found, and yet whose current post-independence nation-building program, dominated by the hegemonic paradigms of global governance gender and development outfits, have yet to re-discover the history and resilience of matrifocal, matrilineal, and matriarchal societies.
