Catherine M. Cole's Performing South Africa's Truth Commission: Stages of Transition explores South Africa's transition from apartheid to democracy through an examination of the vehicle most closely associated with this momentous transformation, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC). Over the past fifteen years innumerable articles and books have been devoted to analysis of the TRC; conclusions drawn in this significant collective of texts range from praise of the TRC to its outright condemnation. Cole's book represents a valuable and unique addition to this body of writing since her critique refuses to focus on the successes, limitations, and outright failures of the TRC. Instead, Cole approaches the TRC in all its complexity from a performative perspective, evaluating the commission's work as an ongoing process.
Cole analyzes the three committees that constituted the commission, concentrating chiefly on the Human Rights Violations Committee. This committee solicited from victims, and offered to the public, heartrending testimony in its aim both to uncover “the truth” associated with gross human rights abuses perpetrated from 1960 to 1993, and to facilitate the complicated dynamic of reconciliation. Cole uses performance theory to explicate the public rituals of the TRC as it moved throughout the country, from villages to towns and cities, during 1996–8. She also explores through this performative lens work in diverse media, including televisual representations of the TRC. Thus while Cole engages with the previous work of many academics on the subject of the TRC, she asks new questions through her examination of the enactment of the commission—questions, for example, about witnessing, truth telling, and spectating; about the performance of justice, the role of translators, and the complex dynamics of possible reconciliation; about the interaction between memory and storytelling, the ramifications of traumas generated by confrontation with the past, and the consequences of (at times) placing victims in direct contact with perpetrators. Most important, Cole foregrounds the way the TRC functioned as a public space, unlike the many truth commissions held in other countries behind closed doors.
Employing Diana Taylor's thinking in The Archive and the Repertoire (Duke University Press, 2003), Cole argues that while the archive (consisting of documents, letters, maps, and other concrete objects) is significant, the repertoire (consisting of embodied memory, performance, dance, singing, gestures, and other fleeting events) is also vital but has often been undervalued. Cole therefore foregrounds the notion that embodied practices possess meaning and should be investigated. As such, in Chapter 2, “Justice in Transition: Political Trials, 1956–1964,” Cole analyzes three significant political trials that took place in that nine-year span: the Treason Trial, the Incitement Trial (which put a spotlight solely on Nelson Mandela), and the Rivonia Trial. Her detailed examination of the trials centers attention on their performative dimensions and the manner in which apartheid structures were unable to contain oppressive politics; she observes how, in response to these trials, counterdiscourses and rituals emerged that relate to aspects of the TRC. She also observes that practices instituted during the dark days of apartheid provided genealogical roots and a context for the TRC.
Importantly, Cole differentiates between the final report the TRC published in December 2009—a report, she notes, that has hardly been read and that she considers deeply flawed—and a series of television programs, called the TRC Special Report, produced by Afrikaner journalist Max du Preez. Rather than presenting readings of reported testimony off the page, these televised documentaries offered the public a repertoire of rich visual and verbal material, as well as the opportunity for viewers to engage in complex acts of witnessing. The public mostly experienced the Human Rights Violation Committee hearings through television, thereby becoming what Cole calls “implicated witness[es]” (92). She argues that “the commission performed one of its core values, ubuntu [humanness and interconnection], by folding together the teller and the receiver of the narratives the commission presented. There are two levels of witnessing here” (92). Cole watched all eighty-seven episodes of the television documentary, which provided in-depth coverage of the testimony enacted from varied accounts featured during the hearings. The programs chose specific stories, provided historical context, and shaped both the performance of the narrative and the spectator's experience of witnessing it to explicate and clarify terrible tales of brutality and loss. Utilizing methodology that includes theoretical, theatrical, performative, historical, and cultural perspectives, Cole maps the TRC in an entirely new and different way, exploring a range of voices—many of which were previously silent or silenced—and noting sites where silence and invisibility continue to prevail, especially with regard to gender issues.
Although there are many theatrical productions related to the TRC, Cole chooses to analyze REwind: A Cantata for Voice, Tape and Testimony, a composition by Philip Miller commemorating the tenth anniversary of the TRC. An example of what Constitutional Court judge Albie Sachs terms “living memorials of reconstruction” (quoted in Coles, 135), this cantata encompasses music, songs, sounds such as screams and wails from recorded testimony, projections, and the poignant dynamics of reconciliation. Cole cites aspects of Miller's process, both ethical and artistic, in creating this powerful work, and analyzes how it foregrounds the problematic conjunction of memory with history and with the retelling of narratives.
Cole meticulously fulfills her stated aim to engage in “scholarship that honors the complexity of the interpretive process; scholarship that looks for truths embedded in testimony that run counter to the commission's mandate; interpretations that shelve the interminable assessment of the commission's virtues or faults; books and articles that actually quote testimony” (90). She demonstrates her strengths as an outsider-insider, as both an American scholar who has thoroughly researched her subject in great depth and breadth, and as a performance studies academic who has immersed herself in the history, sociology, arts, and performance events of this momentous space and time of transition in South Africa. This invaluable book must be read and deserves its place in libraries and on personal bookshelves.
