At a time when the production and publication of “big biographies” has become apparently rare, we are fortunate that the Harvard University Asia Center has seen fit to publish Richard Smethurst's much-anticipated biography of Takahashi Korekiyo. The product of some twenty years of interest, research, and consideration, Smethurst's ruminations upon the troubled economic history of Japan in the 1930s repeatedly led him to consider the merits and deeds of its most enigmatic finance minister (p. vii) and, in doing so, to discover a most remarkable life. And Takahashi Korekiyo, the houseboy, indentured servant, and manager of a failed Peruvian silver mine who became the imperial Japanese government's financial commissioner, president of the Yokohama Specie Bank, governor of the Bank of Japan, decorated peer, prime minister, and long-serving (seven-time) minister of finance, is certainly a remarkable and noteworthy individual in Japanese, if not world, history.
The book is divided into thirteen chapters, conceived thematically, as much as chronologically, to reveal “important” episodes in Takahashi's life, from his remarkable beginnings in the 1850s to his violent end in the intrigues of the decadent 1930s. Fittingly, matters of economy and finance are accorded greater significance than others. In this connection, Smethurst discusses Takahashi's role in the famous Russo-Japanese War loans, which the Japanese government secured from an Anglo-American consortium, with two chapters for both 1904 and 1905. Similarly, careful consideration of Takahashi's role in guiding Japan through the Great Depression, and an assessment of Takahashi's culpability in the rise of Japanese militarism conclude the book. In contrast, twelve or so years of his earlier government service, or his profound intellectual debt to Maeda Masana, for example, merit but single chapters. Most individual chapters read very well as stand-alone essays and, as such, are sometimes in danger of anticipating the revelations of future chapters. Nevertheless, readers will find much to interest and test them here, and enjoy more than a few surprises.
Beyond the impressive depth and breadth of the inquiry, a great strength of the biography is the way in which Smethurst uncovers the details of Takahashi's life, his startling successes, and many failings, without ever allowing the discussion to become trivial, boring, or trite. Moreover, Smethurst's maturity and sound judgment guide us through material that could have been sensationalized by lesser hands. For example, Takahashi's adventures in the Andes, or the protracted loan negotiations between Japanese financial bureaucrats and their Anglo-American counterparts (particularly with the “German-Jewish-American financier” Jacob Schiff, p. 302), could have all so easily read like an adventure novel. Smethurst's sophisticated prose and ever-enquiring analysis, however, reveal the deep significance of these various train of events in Takahashi's life. And we note: Almost everything Takahashi got involved with has significance in Japan's economic and financial history.
Naturally, some criticisms may be leveled at the work. As a biography, it is a professional biography, replete with all the cast and characters of its times, with only minimal discussion devoted to the private and personal lives of the Takahashi family. There is no attendant time line or quick guide to the key events in Takahashi's life, and there are just two very important tables to bolster Takahashi's economic credentials. This leads me to question the use of the epithet “Japan's Keynes” in the last part of the title, when, as the first part of the title makes clear, Takahashi was evidently so much more than an economist. Perhaps my most serious concern is the way in which significant findings are presented in summation. For example, when Smethurst writes, “Japan's leaders reluctantly withdrew their demand for a Russian indemnity at Portsmouth in 1905. But not all of these men recognized, as Takahashi did, that Japan should build its empire within the framework of what was acceptable to the British and American imperialists” (p. 196), or “few government leaders recognized, as Takahashi did, that Japan was more of a paper tiger than a real one” (p. 208), I would still like to see direct references to primary historical sources supporting these conclusions.
Perhaps these proclivities of the historian, however, hint at a greater truth: Smethurst has avoided the minutiae and crafted a biography for the diverse and wide-ranging readership of all those in the humanities and social sciences. Sensitive in tone, yet confident in its findings, Smethurst succeeds in presenting us with an intimate portrait of Takahashi—a constant dose of reality in the most unreal of times. Consequently, without subscribing to the “big men” school of history, we must, nevertheless, reaffirm Takahashi's distinguished place in the firmament of Japan's prewar oligarchs. Moreover, Smethurst asks that we reflect upon Takahashi's remarkable life and learn from this entirely sensible, “pragmatic and non-dogmatic” (p. 306), cosmopolitan and innovative soul. As the first, and very welcome, English-language biography of Takahashi, it is an exciting read, sure to provoke discussion and thus a highly recommended addition to every library of modern Japanese history.
