That universities in many countries have changed radically in the twentieth century is undeniable. It is high time, therefore, for an assessment of those changes, their causes and their consequences, and books which address the subject are very welcome.
The trends which David J. Frank and Jay Gabler chart are based primarily on an analysis of entries in academic handbooks such as the Commonwealth Universities Yearbook or course handbooks for individual universities. While the shifts they detect over the twentieth century are mostly predictable, Frank and Gabler do turn up a few surprises. For example, the proportion of total academic staff working in the social sciences increased three-fold over the century while those in the natural sciences declined slightly, and those in the humanities fell by about 40 per cent. More particularly, the percentage of total staff working in sociology grew twenty-fold between the 1920s and 1980s (vs. 1.5-fold in political science and only 20 per cent in economics). Remarkably, psychology grew hardly at all.
The problems begin once the authors attempt to explain these and other trends. Their argument (repeated ad nauseam) is that worldwide shifts in the content of academic teaching and research during the twentieth century are due to changes in the ‘framework of globally institutionalized reality’ which ‘provoke world-level reorderings of academic emphases’ (p. 199). What this amounts to is the claim that academic change has been driven by secularization of the world-picture, the rise of humanism and the decline of social hierarchies.
While an argument of this kind might be important in understanding global academic change in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, it seems unlikely that such causes had much impact in the twentieth. A far more obvious candidate is that universities were reshaped by economic and political pressures. Although the authors acknowledge that such pressures may have played a partial role, they are never examined in detail but are simply dismissed as explanatorily flawed and insufficient. The cost of ignoring such alternatives, however, is that the entire case for their favoured explanation stands or falls on how plausible they can make it. One way to bolster plausibility, of course, is by leaving out of the analysis all of the ‘hard cases’. Perhaps this is why the authors have nothing to say about twentieth-century changes in a large segment of most universities – their faculties of engineering, medicine, agriculture and management – since it is here that academic responses to the economy and state are particularly obvious.
Instead the authors focus upon shifts in what they regard as the three basic branches of learning: the humanities, social sciences and natural sciences. Even after thus simplifying their task, however, the way in which they construct their argument is poorly designed to demonstrate their case. Despite their frequent attention to ‘data and methods’, they seem to have overlooked the elephant in the room, namely that their reliance upon highly aggregated statistical information does not allow them to do more than speculate about the causes of change. For example, although they claim that certain trends were worldwide in scope, they do not actually present any comparative data by country to demonstrate this. As a result they sacrifice any opportunity to explore why (as they concede in passing) some countries deviated from the main trends. Looking at such cases in detail would have allowed them to infer the causes of the main trends. By failing to descend from the analysis of statistical changes at the global level to develop a more fine-grained analysis – for instance, looking at the peculiarities of national higher education systems, at major curricular changes in individual universities or at institutional histories of disciplines – they cannot get at the most tangible evidence for the factors which immediately influence human action. The secondary literatures on these lower levels certainly exist; the authors just do not make use of them.
In short, we desperately need good books on the transformation of the university in the twentieth century, but this is not one of them.
