‘Public science’ – a complex mixture of experimental demonstrations and philosophical consumption – emerged in the eighteenth century to take the new sciences from limited academic circles to a broad and increasingly enthusiastic audience. Lecture courses proliferated as itinerant showmen, instrument-makers and entrepreneurs exploited increasingly dramatic effects (electricity was exemplary) to entice audiences and teach morals of natural theology and public utility through experimental demonstrations. By the late century, lectures and displays in colleges, laboratories and cabinets de physiques, along with pleasing experiments in books of rational recreations and a busy trade in demonstration instruments, had helped to make natural philosophy entertaining, fashionable and authoritative. Enlightenment, as the contributors to this volume ably demonstrate, was as much a dramatic experience as an intellectual adventure.
Gathering papers from a conference held in the Cité des sciences et de l'industrie in Paris in 2003, Science and Spectacle in the European Enlightenment offers a variety of perspectives on the culture of public lectures and experimental shows in Britain, France, Germany and Italy in the eighteenth century, with a focus on experimental physics, chemistry and anatomy. Although several of the authors have since published detailed monographs on the themes presented here, the volume provides a valuable addition to the literature on public science, whose contours and concerns are succinctly evoked in the editors' introduction. Here, Bernadette Bensaude-Vincent and Christine Blondel rightly point to the variety of practitioners, venues and goals which constituted enlightened ‘public science’, and hence to the need to keep an open mind about who and what constituted ‘science’ in the eighteenth century. Different venues for public science variously emphasized education, entertainment and commerce. Lecturers, ranging from lowly itinerant showmen to professors at elite colleges, served vocational instruction, particularly in chemistry; amusement, in boulevard theatricals and dramatic electric shows; or utility, in demonstrations of physical principles and practical mechanics for industrious entrepreneurs. Typically shows incorporated all three interests, together with a fervent religious impulse to display the wonders of the divine creation.
The ten individual contributions expertly reveal this culture in all its variety, exploring the careers of lecturers, their performances, audiences and travels. Larry Stewart and Liliane Pérez consider the utilitarian dimensions of public science in laboratories, workshops and toyshops, where practical knowledge and technique were infused with drama to appeal to curious, commercial and consuming audiences. Jessica Riskin emphasizes the role of sensationalism in establishing public science, as assumptions that learning occurred through sensory experience promoted the value of striking experiments as tools of edification and amusement. Michael R. Lynn offers an original geography of public science in late eighteenth-century Paris, revealing the links between performance and place in French shows, and the ways a lecturer might be propelled through differing locales during his or her career. Paola Bertucci and Oliver Hochadel consider electricity, the favourite effect of enlightened experimental shows. Both authors reveal the importance of itinerant shows for the spread of enlightened science into new regions. Bertucci traces the growth of a fashion for electricity in Italy, noting electricity's appeal in aristocratic salons and among women, while Hochadel focuses on the extraordinary career of the itinerant electrician Martin Berschitz and his often tense interactions with the highly placed professor Georg Christoph Lichtenberg. Hochadel nicely reveals the divergent paths the identity of ‘lecturer’ could take in the eighteenth century, at least according to Lichtenberg, for whom Berschitz appeared as an Austrian ‘ignoramus’ and ‘windbag’ whose alleged swindles might damage Lichtenberg's professorial reputation.
The remaining papers explore the public culture of chemistry and anatomy in the eighteenth century. Christine Lehman stresses the educational role of lecturing by following the changing nature of public chemistry courses in Paris, from professional apothecaries' lectures around 1700 to more general discussions in the 1770s. While Lehman proposes that chemical lecturers gained credit for the laborious skill needed to perform chemical operations, Jan Golinski draws attention to the sublime aspects of chemical experiments, principally in the work of Joseph Priestley. Recalling the sublime aesthetics promoted by Edmund Burke and more often found in art criticism, Golinski argues that understanding Priestley's vision of the sublime, provoking admiration and surprise in audiences, helps to explain the political and theological controversy surrounding Priestley's works at the end of the century. Lissa Roberts also urges a closer tie between chemistry and other cultures of spectacle. Exploring the successful career of chemical lecturer Guillaume Rouelle at the Jardin du Roy, Roberts suggests that Rouelle achieved success by balancing appeals to the senses and reason which resonated in the changing context of French theatre and enlightened theories of performance. A more ambiguous performance is discussed in the concluding essay by Jonathan Simon. Anatomical demonstrations using wax models were common spectacles in the eighteenth century, and as Simon shows, those of anatomy professor Honoré Fragonard drew a large crowd. Exploring the macabre, erotic and philosophical resonances of Fragonard's wax anatomies, Simon suggests the audience for enlightened anatomy was diverse, while these remarkable figures were intended to display not only amusing and educational spectacles but also the virtuosity of their makers – a goal no doubt common to demonstrators in other arenas of natural philosophy.
‘Europe’ in this collection amounts to familiar nations, and it remains to be seen how public science extended into Scandinavia, Iberia, Eastern Europe and Russia in the eighteenth century, not to mention the European colonies. Nevertheless, this is a valuable collection for its insights into public science, commerce and enlightenment. Several contributions suggest important new directions for research, notably in considering the broader ‘entertainment environment’ in the eighteenth century in order to better reveal relations between scientific lectures and other forms of spectacle.
