Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:14:48.416Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Effect of velocity ratio on the interaction between plasma synthetic jets and turbulent cross-flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 February 2019

Haohua Zong*
Affiliation:
Faculty of Aerospace Engineering, Delft University of Technology, Kluyverweg 1, 2629 HS Delft, The Netherlands
Marios Kotsonis
Affiliation:
Faculty of Aerospace Engineering, Delft University of Technology, Kluyverweg 1, 2629 HS Delft, The Netherlands
*
†Email address for correspondence: h.zong-1@tudelft.nl

Abstract

Plasma synthetic jet actuators (PSJAs) are particularly suited for high-Reynolds-number, high-speed flow control due to their unique capability of generating supersonic pulsed jets at high frequency (${>}5$  kHz). Different from conventional synthetic jets driven by oscillating piezoelectric diaphragms, the exit-velocity variation of plasma synthetic jets (PSJs) within one period is significantly asymmetric, with ingestion being relatively weaker (less than $20~\text{m}~\text{s}^{-1}$) and longer than ejection. In this study, high-speed phase-locked particle image velocimetry is employed to investigate the interaction between PSJAs (round exit orifice, diameter 2 mm) and a turbulent boundary layer at constant Strouhal number (0.02) and increasing mean velocity ratio ($r$, defined as the ratio of the time-mean velocity over the ejection phase to the free-stream velocity). Two distinct operational regimes are identified for all the tested cases, separated by a transition velocity ratio, lying between $r=0.7$ and $r=1.0$. At large velocity and stroke ratios (first regime, representative case $r=1.6$), vortex rings are followed by a trailing jet column and tilt downstream initially. This downstream tilting is transformed into upstream tilting after the pinch-off of the trailing jet column. The moment of this transformation relative to the discharge advances with decreasing velocity ratio. Shear-layer vortices (SVs) and a hanging vortex pair (HVP) are identified in the windward and leeward sides of the jet body, respectively. The HVP is initially erect and evolves into an inclined primary counter-rotating vortex pair ($p$-CVP) which branches from the middle of the front vortex ring and extends to the near-wall region. The two legs of the $p$-CVP are bridged by SVs, and a secondary counter-rotating vortex pair ($s$-CVP) is induced underneath these two legs. At low velocity and stroke ratios (second regime, representative case $r=0.7$), the trailing jet column and $p$-CVP are absent. Vortex rings always tilt upstream, and the pitching angle increases monotonically with time. An $s$-CVP in the near-wall region is induced directly by the two longitudinal edges of the ring. Inspection of spanwise planes ($yz$-plane) reveals that boundary-layer energization is realized by the downwash effect of either vortex rings or $p$-CVP. In addition, in the streamwise symmetry plane, the increasing wall shear stress is attributed to the removal of low-energy flow by ingestion. The downwash effect of the $s$-CVP does not benefit boundary-layer energization, as the flow swept to the wall is of low energy.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Bottom plate of the test section: (a) top view and (b) side view. The coordinate system used throughout this study is indicated in blue. Not to scale.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Sketches of (a) actuator cavity and (b) discharge circuit. PSJA is modelled as an air gap in the discharge circuit. P1 and P2 indicate, respectively, the measurement stations of discharge voltage and current.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Electrical waveforms measured at an initial capacitor voltage of $V_{0}=2.5~\text{kV}$: —— (red), instantaneous capacitor voltage; – –○– – (blue), instantaneous discharge current. (b) Non-dimensional energy deposition at increasing initial capacitor voltage.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Fields of view in two-component planar and three-component stereo PIV measurements. The magnitude of total velocity ($U_{xyz}$) at a time delay of $t=300~\unicode[STIX]{x03BC}\text{s}$ with regard to discharge ignition is displayed as contours. High-velocity regions ($U_{xyz}/U_{\infty }\geqslant 1$) are cropped to visualize the bending jet.

Figure 4

Figure 5.(a) Mean velocity profiles and (b) Reynolds normal stresses measured at $x/D=2$ and $z/D=0$. DNS data from Wu et al. (2017) at $Re_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}}=2900$ are compared.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Phase-averaged velocity fields in case 1 (a–e, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}=0.028$) and case 4 (f–j, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D716}=0.28$). The dimensionless convective time is identical in each row and increases linearly from $t^{\ast }=1$ to $t^{\ast }=5$ in a step of 1 time unit (a–j). Direction and magnitude of the in-plane velocity ($U_{xy}$) are displayed as contours and vectors. The thick black lines near the jet exit are contour lines of $U_{y}/U_{\infty }=-0.1$. The thin red lines in panel (j) are streamlines.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Evolution of the spatially averaged exit velocity ($U_{ey}$) in one period for all the tested cases. Scales of $y$-axis are changed to adapt for the different velocity range.

Figure 7

Table 1.Jet formation parameters for all the tested cases.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Phase-averaged velocity fields in case 4 ($r=1.6$): (a) $t^{\ast }=1$; (b) $t^{\ast }=1.5$; (c) $t^{\ast }=2.0$; (d) $t^{\ast }=3$; (e) $t^{\ast }=4$; (f) $t^{\ast }=5.5$; (g) $t^{\ast }=7$; (h) $t^{\ast }=10$; (i) $t^{\ast }=12$. The magnitude and direction of the in-plane velocity ($U_{xy}$) are displayed as contours and vectors. The black lines in panel (b) indicate the front vortex ring detected with a criterion of 10 % of the peak $Q$-value. The blue lines in panels (d–f) are contour lines of $U_{x}/U_{\infty }=-0.1$. The red dash-dotted lines in panel (g) are contour lines of $U_{y}/U_{\infty }=-0.2$.

Figure 9

Figure 9.(a) Contour of wall-normal velocity ($U_{y}$) at $t^{\ast }=1$ for case 4. (b) Boundary-layer velocity profiles at $t^{\ast }=1$ and $x/D=1$, 3, 5 (red dashed lines). The velocity profiles of the unactuated boundary layer are indicated by solid blue lines. The thin dark lines superimposed on the background are contour lines of streamwise velocity ranging from $U_{x}/U_{\infty }=1.0$ (top) to $U_{x}/U_{\infty }=0.4$ (bottom) in steps of $-0.1$. (c) Streamwise variation of the boundary-layer shape factor ($H$) at $t^{\ast }=1$. The baseline value (1.4) is indicated as a thick black line for comparison.

Figure 10

Figure 10.Time evolution of vorticity contour in case 4 ($r=1.6$): (a) $t^{\ast }=1.5$; (b) $t^{\ast }=2.0$; (c) $t^{\ast }=3$; (d) $t^{\ast }=4$. Vortices indicated by the black lines are detected with a criterion of 10 % of the peak $Q$-value. The blue dashed lines are contour lines of $U_{x}/U_{\infty }=-0.1$. The red solid lines are streamlines that originate from the centre of the exit orifice.

Figure 11

Figure 11.(a) Propagation of the FVR in cross-flow: ○, windward vortex centre ($x_{v}^{+},y_{v}^{+}$); ▵, leeward vortex centre ($x_{v}^{-},y_{v}^{-}$). (b) Variation of the dimensionless vortex circulation ($\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E4}$) against time: $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E4}^{+}$, upstream side circulation in cross-flow condition; $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E4}^{-}$, downstream side circulation in cross-flow condition; $\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E4}_{0}$, vortex circulation in quiescent condition.

Figure 12

Figure 12.(a) Trajectories of plasma synthetic jets in cross-flow at $r=1.6$: $\cdots \cdots$, middle streamlines at increasing time delay; ▵, vortex ring centre trace ($x_{v},y_{v}$); ——, jet trajectory fitted from the envelope of middle streamlines; – – –, jet trajectory fitted from the vortex ring centre trace. (b) Time variation of the normalized back-flow area ($A_{b}/D^{2}$) and the mean back-flow velocity ($U_{b}/U_{\infty }$).

Figure 13

Figure 13.Spatial–temporal map of the boundary-layer shape factor in the $xy$-plane. The black thin lines and blue dashed lines are contour lines of $H=1.4$ (baseline value) and $H=1.37$, respectively. The white arrow indicates a propagation velocity of $0.7U_{\infty }$.

Figure 14

Figure 14.(a) Contours lines of the time-averaged streamwise velocity: –$\cdot$–, baseline condition; ——, case 4. From the top down, $U_{x}/U_{\infty }$ varies from 0.9 to 0.5 in steps of $-0.1$. The blue dashed curve shows the jet trajectory fitted from the trace of the vortex ring centre. (b) Streamwise variation of normalized wall shear stress and boundary-layer shape factor in time-averaged flow field: – – –, $k_{\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}}$; ——, $H$. Boundaries of the jet exit are indicated by two thin lines. The baseline value for $H$ is 1.4.

Figure 15

Figure 15.Time evolution of the phase-averaged velocity fields at $x=2D$ (b,e,h). The corresponding velocity field in the symmetry plane is shown in (a,d,g). Dimensionless convection time: (a–c) $t^{\ast }=3$; (d–f) $t^{\ast }=4$; (g–i) $t^{\ast }=5.5$. The thick red lines superimposed on contours indicate vortices detected with 10 % of the maximum $Q$-value. The thin blue lines in (a,d,g) and the thin dark lines in (b,e,h) are contour lines of $U_{x}/U_{\infty }=-0.1$ and $U_{xyz}/U_{\infty }=1$, respectively. The black dashed lines and red solid lines in (c,f,i) plot, respectively, the wall-normal variations of the upwash velocity at $x=2D$, $z=0$ and the $Q$-value variation along the white lines placed at the vortex centre in (a,d,g).

Figure 16

Figure 16.Phase-averaged velocity fields at $t^{\ast }=7$: (a) symmetry plane; (b) $x=2D$; (c) $x=5D$. Thick red lines indicate vortices detected with a criterion of 10 % of the maximum $Q$-value. Thin blue lines are contour lines of $U_{y}/U_{\infty }=0.2$. In panel (a), arrows indicate the directions of in-plane periodic fluctuation velocity components, namely ($\tilde{u} _{x},\tilde{u} _{y}$). As a comparison, arrows in panels (b) and (c) indicate the directions of in-plane phase-averaged velocity components ($U_{x},U_{y}$).

Figure 17

Figure 17.Time evolution of the circulation of a $p$-CVP and the circulation difference between upstream and downstream sides of the FVR.

Figure 18

Figure 18.Pseudo-3D vortical structures generated by PSJs in cross-flow at $r=1.6$: (a) axonometric view; (b) top view; (c) side view.

Figure 19

Figure 19.(a) Spatial–temporal map of the boundary-layer shape factor at $x/D=2$. The black thin lines and blue dashed lines are contour lines of $H=1.4$ (baseline value) and $H=1.37$, respectively. (b) Time evolution and (c) spanwise variation of the boundary-layer shape factor at selected locations/time instants.

Figure 20

Figure 20.Time evolution of vorticity contour at $r=0.7$: (a) $t^{\ast }=1.5$; (b) $t^{\ast }=2.0$; (c) $t^{\ast }=3$; (d) $t^{\ast }=4$. Plotting methods are inherited from figure 10.

Figure 21

Figure 21.(a) Propagation of the FVR in cross-flow at $r=0.7$: ○, windward vortex centre ($x_{v}^{+},y_{v}^{+}$); ▵, leeward vortex centre ($x_{v}^{-},y_{v}^{-}$). (b) Variation of the dimensionless vortex circulation ($\unicode[STIX]{x1D6E4}$) in both quiescent air and cross-flow.

Figure 22

Figure 22.(a) Normalized traces of the FVR at different velocity ratios. (b) Time variation of the pitching angle ($\unicode[STIX]{x1D6FC}$) of the FVR.

Figure 23

Figure 23.Pseudo-3D vortical structures generated by PSJs in cross-flow at $r=0.7$: (a) axonometric view; (b) top view; (c) side view.

Figure 24

Figure 24.Spatial–temporal variations of the boundary-layer shape factor measured at $x=2D$ for increasing velocity ratio: (a) $r=0.7$; (b) $r=1.0$; (c) $r=1.2$. Solid and dashed lines correspond to contour lines of $H=1.4$ and $H=1.37$, respectively.

Figure 25

Figure 25.Streamwise variations of (a) time-averaged boundary-layer shape factor and (b) dimensionless wall shear stress in the symmetry plane for increasing velocity ratio. Two grey lines ($x=\pm 0.5D$) are added to indicate the location of the exit orifice.

Figure 26

Figure 26.Conceptual models of PSJs in cross-flow. (a) Regime A, high velocity and stroke ratio. (b) Regime B, low velocity and stroke ratio.

Figure 27

Figure 27.Possible flow regimes pertaining to (a) pulsed jets in cross-flow (Sau & Mahesh 2008) and (b) conventional synthetic jets in cross-flow (Jabbal & Zhong 2008). Markers pertain to the present study: ▵, mean velocity ratio ($U_{p}/U_{\infty }$) against stroke ratio; ○, peak velocity ratio ($U_{0}/U_{\infty }$) against stroke ratio.