Analysing the gendered effects of neoliberal social and economic reform today is as relevant as it was in the 1990s. The dominance of neoliberalism has clearly not faded yet, in Peru or elsewhere. Providing a feminist understanding of the differentiated impact of such reforms, and how such reforms may entrench existing inequalities, is relevant in the United Kingdom (see the work of the Women's Budget Group, for example) as much as it is in Peru. But, as Cristina Ewig skilfully shows us, gendered inequality in access to basic services cannot be attributed solely to neoliberal reforms, especially in Peru.
Ewig uses an intersectional approach in order to show how race, class and gender are linked and often reinforce each other in defining privilege and marginalisation, in creating hierarchy, in ascribing voice and participation, and ultimately in determining who benefits from the state and its institutions and is listened to by them. She applies this intersectional understanding of inequality to health sector reform in Peru. This allows Ewig to do much more than ‘just’ provide an analysis of neoliberal reforms, as the intersectional approach enables her to look at how racism, sexism and socio-economic stratification affect the politics of policy-making, the implementation of policy, and the actual differentiated effects of such policies.
Ewig uses a policy legacy approach to analyse how contemporary policy reform draws upon, or breaks with, historically constituted political interests, public expectations and policy learning processes. In doing this, she frames the politics of an increasingly authoritarian and populist regime in a wider context of continuity, instead of exceptionality. In the second half of the 1990s the Fujimori government implemented a series of ‘second-wave’ neoliberal policies that were based both on neoliberal ideals of cost-effectiveness and on democratic ideas of decentralisation and participation. Ewig calls this apparently contradictory approach a ‘softer version’ of neoliberal reform, as compared to the imposition of harsh, top-down, ‘one size fits all’ measures that were implemented throughout the developing world during the 1980s and early 1990s. While this softer version does indeed use more participatory language and has adopted mechanisms that are participatory in name and sometimes in practice, its objectives of cost-effectiveness and economic development have not changed. Of course, ‘participation’ can also mean using cheap (‘voluntary’) labour to provide state services, as multiple studies around the world have shown and as Ewig also notes. Apart from this global continuity in social policy reform, Ewig also uses the policy legacy approach to show how particular reforms, such as increased community participation in the formulation and design of health services, could be genuinely innovative but may simultaneously reinforce existing gendered and racial hierarchies.
Ewig's analysis of policy reform is complemented by my own work on women and social policy, Intersecting Inequalities: Women and Social Policy in Peru, 1990–2000 (Penn State University Press, 2010) and Stephanie Rousseau's work on women's citizenship and neopopulism, Women's Citizenship in Peru: The Paradoxes of Neopopulism in Latin America (Palgrave Macmillan, 2009). Whereas Rousseau focuses on the politics of inclusion and exclusion during the Fujimori regime, and I focused on the policies explicitly directed at poor women, Ewig provides a detailed policy analysis of one sector. As such, her book is relevant not only to students of Peru and/or gendered politics, but also to policy analysts in Peru and beyond. Considering the influence that international financial institutions and bi- and multilateral development organisations in Latin America have over policy, understanding the effects of policy in a particular context where inequality is historically high and intersectional in character is useful to international policy-makers as well.
Currently, politics in Peru, and thus social policy, stands on its head once again. Alberto Fujimori's daughter, Keiko, lost the 2011 elections partly as a consequence of revived attention to the debacle of her father's population programme, as discussed by Ewig in chapter 6 of this book. Meanwhile, the ideological and political course of the incoming government is as yet unclear. It is unlikely that the dominant economic ‘model’ will be abandoned, but the rhetoric used by the newly elected president, Ollanta Humala, in the last few years suggests that there is a chance of more equitable objectives in policy-making. As Ewig shows, however, even equitable objectives may still be constrained by existing inequities; in effect, changing those existing inequities may need a completely different approach. As Ewig argues in her conclusion, a rights-based approach to health care, as opposed to a market-based approach, will not ‘automatically resolve all inequities’ (p. 212). Rather, inequalities based on gender, race and class need to be understood and put on the political agenda. Ewig's book certainly contributes to that, and hopefully students of policy, health reform and Latin American politics will all see the benefit of this.
