The Igreja Universal do Reino de Deus (Universal Church of the Kingdom of God, IURD) is the prototype of Neo-Pentecostalism. Founded by Edir Macedo in 1977, it has grown into a worldwide religious, financial and mediatic empire, though the majority of the pastors and bishops who lead its branches are Brazilian. Its followers in Brazil are counted in millions and it claims 10,000 churches worldwide, notably in Portugal, the United States, South Africa and Britain, and almost any country you care to mention.
The IURD has been the subject of an extensive literature whose authors can be divided into social scientists who focus on the religious life of its followers, and journalists and dissidents who have reported on its leader's multiple legal imbroglios and the scandals stirred up by expelled or voluntarily departed pastors and bishops. This division is important and raises methodological and ethical issues for scientific research. If scholars are persuaded that millions of true-believing followers are dupes of a camarilla whose sole purpose is the accumulation of wealth and political power, what is there for us to say? Yet how can we ignore the abundant evidence produced not only by the whistle-blowers and journalists but also by public prosecutors?
Nonetheless, we should be grateful to Gilberto Nascimento and his assistants for doing a lot of ‘spade work’ for us. His book documents in detail and with abundant evidence from the press, from interviews and from judicial records, how in less than four decades Macedo built a worldwide religious organisation, a media empire with TV Record at its centre, a massive personal fortune and an indispensable place in his country's politics. After starting in the late 1970s, by 1987 the church already had 356 temples and 27 rented cinemas in Brazil alone. His strategy was to stimulate church attendance through radio and TV, and to gain a political presence to support its development through access to the airwaves, to state-controlled banks and to regulation and legislation, especially in the sphere of tax and communications. The strategy has been stunningly successful: the church now has 300 bishops, several thousand pastors and tens of thousands of obreiros, or assistants, who tend to the millions of faithful during services and help to organise prayer groups, youth groups, seniors’ groups, soup kitchens, women's groups and more.
One constant throughout has been the role of Macedo's close and extended family. At the start, his mother (who Nascimento says had undergone 33 pregnancies, of which 26 ended in miscarriage) offered her apartment, the family's only property, as a guarantee for the hire of the disused funeral parlour which became the church's first premises. His brother-in-law, R. R. Soares, was a close associate, though soon he broke away to establish his own organisation, cable TV-based Igreja Internacional da Graça de Deus (International Church of the Grace of God). In 1986 one of his brothers was elected deputy for Rio de Janeiro and in 1988 another was elected a municipal councillor, both as part of the church's political strategy. One of those brothers later appears as the owner of an account in the United States through which funds from tithes and donations were channelled via a currency dealer in São Paulo, then to be forwarded to tax havens in the Caribbean and back to Brazil. Macedo's father has been twice elected to the São Paulo City Council. The book contains numerous examples of bewildering shifts in personnel between the church, TV Record and other businesses that supply their needs and operate in their orbit: at least at the time of writing, one of Macedo's cousins ran a publishing-cum-recording company working largely for the IURD while his brother ran a transport company. Meanwhile another brother was a state deputy, who replaced nephew Marcelo Crivella when the latter was elected mayor of Rio in 2016. Another cousin worked with Crivella and acted as an intermediary with currency dealers. Crivella himself has been successful as both pastor and politician, setting up the church in Mozambique, Angola and South Africa and then winning elections twice as a senator and serving for two years as minister of fisheries, before being elected mayor of Rio – although in 2021 he failed to be re-elected for a second term.
Nowadays Macedo's wife, daughter and son-in-law are prominent on the IURD's very well-designed websites where they post regular blogs offering advice about how to lead a rational and God-fearing life and especially how to manage love and marriage. His daughter and son-in-law now play prominent roles and the son-in-law is regarded as the heir apparent (though such things can change). The son-in-law's brother is the most powerful figure in TV Record as well as a bishop of the church.
Macedo has leveraged the votes of his followers with devastating effect, enabling him to get ministerial approval for his purchase of TV Record in the 1980s, when then president-elect Fernando Collor in effect ordered TV star-cum-mogul Sylvio Santos to seal a deal that he was resisting. On another occasion he managed to get a debt to the state bank of São Paulo (BANESPA) halved thanks to Governor Orestes Quércia, and somehow even that half was reduced during the (failing) bank's subsequent privatisation.
The book details innumerable lawsuits related to Macedo's financial dealings, others brought by dissident pastors and bishops, and even three murder inquiries involving church personnel, yet few have even reached a conclusion let alone a conviction, except in minor cases when the church or Macedo or TV Record have had to pay fines or compensation. Many simply run out of time. Figuring as accuser rather than accused, the church brings lawsuits to intimidate or punish irritating journalists, though not always to much effect.
And yet, and yet … Nascimento expresses no interest in the millions who attend this church and contribute to its expansion and to the success of TV Record, and the title and tone of the book, falling somewhere between mockery and hostility, betrays his bias. He makes no mention of the elaborate attention paid to ritual, to the fashioning of a distinctive style of preaching, to the devices that bind followers to the church, to the adoption of symbols and language from the Africa-originating possession cults, to preachers’ tireless insistence on the psychological problems suffered by followers and their traumatic encounters with addiction and suicide, to the willingness of followers to contribute regularly and sometimes generously to calls for tithes and donations, to the ambiguous treatment of wealth as a sign of both a corrupt worldly life and also of the gifts of the Spirit … in short, to the many topics that constitute the social scientific study of religion.
Even though church personnel would regard him as driven by malign motives, we have to be grateful to the author for the information provided in the book, including its more colourful episodes. But we must also recognise that it is symptomatic of a patronising attitude prevalent among the intelligentsia to the Pentecostal faithful, who are sometimes taken to be incapable of rational or independent agency. Hence the ethical issues that arise in research on this subject.
