At a time when academic literature, in its ever-increasing complexity, more often obfuscates than elucidates the world, Joan Kee's superb first book, Contemporary Korean Art: Tansaekhwa and the Urgency of Method, demonstrates through its examination of a particular section of contemporary Korean art that it is still possible to unite expertise with clarity without sacrificing any of the nuances that characterize first-rate scholarship. Tansaekhwa at the center of Kee's book means “monochrome painting,” or as Kee defines it, “a loose constellation of mostly large abstract paintings done in white, black, brown, and other neutral colors made by Korean artists from the mid-1960s to the mid-1970s” (p. 1). Dense as that definition may sound, the tansaekhwa movement, as Kee shows, represented more than just a highly theoretical and experimental approach to art bounded together by a set of shared visual characteristics.
Although such works were at a glance understood to be paintings due to the suffix “-hwa” at the end of the movement's name, tansaekhwa artists saw themselves to be different from conventional painters, seeking to radically alter the meaning of painting, and Korean art by extension, with their theorization of artistic production—and product—as pangbŏp or “methods.” These “methods” involved the combination of materials both fine and mundane—much of the latter being derived from industries synonymous with the state-planned economy of the Park Chung-hee dictatorship—brought together in such a way that the very notion of painting was called into question. The movement generated outcomes that challenged the idea of artistic product by unabashedly exposing to the viewer the mechanics of production, in an inversely teleological manner, so as to make the viewer question whether the object on display was finished or perhaps even “artistic.”
Tansaekhwa artists’ insistence on making transparent the artistic process and refusal to bend to the definition of art as enforced by the conservative state-sponsored annual art salon—Kukchŏn—were embodied in an oft-invoked description of tansaekhwa: kŭrim anin kŭrim (“pictures that were not pictures”). That obstinacy in pursuing art beyond the confines of the establishment lent tansaekhwa methods a distinctly political tint against the backdrop of repression and authoritarianism, and Kee rightly stresses this fact to counter the widely held assumption that tansaekhwa failed to explicitly address the world outside art in comparison to its much more political counterpart: “Minjung” art of the 1980s.
In the first four chapters of her book, Kee introduces the reader to a series of tansaekhwa’s representative figures who embraced abstraction as a means to reconfigure fundamentals of art such as “medium, materiality, the viewing encounter and the place of the viewer” (p. 30) on the one hand, and call into question the issues of “empire, nationalism, and colonization” (p. 31) on the other. In the last, fifth chapter, Kee situates tansaekhwa in a broader context of the global art market where, contrary to the artists’ own positioning of themselves as Korean artists who did not make “Korean art,” tansaekhwa was “used to promote a distinctly Korean cultural, ethnic, and national sensibility” (p. 31).
As Kee unfolds her coherent and engaging narrative of tansaekhwa, her storytelling comes across as hardly linear. Mirroring the nature of tansaekhwa as elastic and thus multivalent, Kee's narrative takes multiple points of departure and arrival and highlights the complicated position and reception of the tansaekhwa movement in the history of contemporary Korean art. She also displays throughout the book a rare sensitivity to formal qualities of the visual materials before her and exhaustive knowledge of theoretical discussions that surrounded and gave rise to the movement, all while writing a refined but accessible prose without a shred of excess.
The timeliness of Kee's work is obvious when one reads commentaries by current leading figures of the Korean art scene who continue to define both tansaekhwa and the whole of Korean art vis-à-vis global art on both universal and particularistic terms without being aware of the role tansaekhwa played in challenging such binary categories of analysis. For that reason, this book is bound to appeal to a wide range of scholars, not only those within her own discipline of art history but also others who engage with issues of modernity, identity, and nationalism in modern and contemporary Korea and elsewhere. Kee's central question, “Is it possible, then, for the study of tansaekhwa to help us rethink some of the distinctions on which we practice the world at present?” (p. 33), is brilliantly answered in the process of reading—and by the method she utilizes—and there is little doubt that Kee succeeds in problematizing those distinctions that enjoy currency not only in the expanding global marketplace of art (or marketplace of global art), but also in communities of scholars and state actors alike.
