When German immigrant John Weyert first arrived in the town of Alpine in West Texas in 1886, the local cowboys surrounded him, pointing pistols at his head, or more precisely, his derby hat. Weyert took the hat off and put it on a post and the “boys” shot it full of holes.Footnote 1 Another unfortunate tourist alighted from the train while it stopped briefly at Alpine, wearing slippers, a smoking jacket, monocle, and similar Derby hat. The cowboys roped him shouting, “I roped it first, now I get to brand it!” and the man's fellow passengers had to ask the conductor to rescue him.Footnote 2 Cowboys in the Panhandle had a field day with Archibald John Marjoribanks, the British baron and owner of the Rocking Chair Ranch. They shot at his feet and continuously made fun of his formal clothes, English horses, and use of fox and hounds to hunt deer.Footnote 3 These stories of cowboy shenanigans, both humorous and harmless, are part of the legend of the manly cowboys, holding the line against the effeminate dudes from out East who dared to invade their territory. They are also part of the reason that the people who surrounded the cowboys, in frontier towns and on the ranches, sought to keep them under control.
It is important, however, to consider what purpose violence served for the cowboy himself. To the working-class cowboy, violence could preserve social harmony, both through defending personal honor and through regulating social behavior of women and minorities. Its use was a clear marker of masculinity, as it allowed him both to show his equal worth with the men around him and to maintain social hierarchies that gave him an advantage over other people. The middle- and upper-class townspeople and cattlemen around them, however, increasingly saw violence as counterproductive. Although parents encouraged aggression in boyhood, they thought that in order to become a real man, a boy should learn proper restraint and channel that aggression into socially acceptable activities. More and more, their idea of maintaining social order left no room for violence, and consequently cowboys faced increasing social regulation of their masculine self-identities.Footnote 4
Both popular and scholarly works have shaped the discussion of cowboy violence. Early scholarly and most popular accounts tended to celebrate cowboys and cattlemen in the Frederick Jackson Turner vein as representative of the spirit of America: they were brave white men taming the frontier and blazing the path for more timid easterners to follow and settle. Their violence was necessary to move the country forward and was perhaps the sole reservoir of white masculinity in the late nineteenth century.Footnote 5 Revisionist historians (and filmmakers) looking at class conflict and trying to write a more inclusive history, exposed the cowboy myth. Cowboys were not free and independent agents; they were often exploited working-class men. They were not all white, and those who were white could be small-minded bigots who were the true savages on the frontier they were supposedly taming.Footnote 6 Ironically, both celebratory and revisionist accounts have emphasized the violence of the cowboys, particularly against Native Americans. Within the context of the New Western History, more nuanced interpretations have recently emerged, placing the cowboy as neither hero nor villain, neither victim nor oppressor.Footnote 7 These accounts have also looked at public reaction to violent incidents and explored frontier court records to show that violence was neither as acceptable nor as prevalent as accounts have portrayed.Footnote 8 It is within this new, more complicated picture that we need to re-examine the nature and role of masculine violence on the cattle frontier. Texas is a natural starting place for this exploration because it was the birthplace of the main cattle industry after the Civil War and because Texas cowboys traveled up and down the trails to other states and territories bringing their culture with them.
Physical violence was very much a part of masculinity in the nineteenth century, especially in the South, where many of the cowboys and cattlemen originated. Violence itself was also part of cattle work. Having to process thousands of cattle at a time, cowboys roped and threw them to the ground in order to brand them in ways that did not always please the cattlemen who owned the livestock. Anthropologists have noted that herding societies tend to have high levels of aggression and violence because their livestock is always vulnerable to loss. In addition, frontier areas where law enforcement is spotty tend to operate more on the rule of retaliation rather than the rule of law. Nineteenth-century Texas met both conditions, and migrants to Texas came from the South as well as from Scots-Irish backgrounds associated with similar cultures. In such an environment, a “culture of honor” is likely to develop, in which honor equates with the strength and power of a man to enforce his will on others, in other words, his status in society. In this culture, a man has to be ready to strike back at all times and must strike back at any insult, no matter how slight, or risk losing credibility.Footnote 9 Historian Amy Greenberg has argued that the frontier tended to attract men who saw violence as a way of asserting manhood. Because most settled areas tended to reject violence as acceptable behavior, “martial” men often fled to the frontier where such attitudes seemed more in tune with the environment.Footnote 10 Honor was thus a major part of masculinity; and honor necessitated violence.
Historian Bertram Wyatt-Brown has described a culture of honor that developed in the South in the nineteenth century that emphasized physical courage and ritual displays of masculine prowess through fighting, grand displays of wealth, and braggadocio, all of which involved conspicuous lack of control over passions. In this culture, it was important for men to stand up against insults perceived or real.Footnote 11 By the late eighteenth century, most southern aristocrats had given up the coarsest forms of violence and channeled their aggression into duels and mental domination, whereas poorer men in the backcountry and on the frontier continued rough-and-tumble fighting in which the goal was to best the other with a show of physical strength. But whether violence was in the form of duels or street fighting, many men believed that it was essential to proving one's manhood and to defending honor.Footnote 12 Historian Edward Ayers argued that southern honor was not monolithic in nature and was as much rooted in the economic realities of the South as the cultural ones, but it did play an important part in personal confrontations.Footnote 13
Moreover, scholars such as Lorien Foote have shown recently that even northern men were willing to use violence to defend their reputations and honor.Footnote 14 Historian Tom Lea reports that Texas cattle baron Richard King was fond of fisticuffs on occasion and relates the story of how King fought an employee he had berated who retorted that King could never be so harsh if he were not rich or a captain. King replied that they should forget his title and just fight, which they did for a half hour, emerging bloody in “mutual admiration.” King was not a typical cattleman in any way, and his actions reflected as much his working-class, New York Irish background as any southern sense of honor.Footnote 15
There were incidents in the 1870s and 1880s that suggested codes of honor still prevailed in Texas. Although violent incidents in many cattle ranching areas went unpunished, crimes against property such as cattle rustling often faced very steep penalties. In the mid-1880s, when Walter W. Meek, a Pennsylvania native, served on the grand jury in South Texas, he was astonished at the prevailing values among his fellow citizens. He reported that horse stealing received the harshest punishment, with some even advocating the death penalty for rustling, whereas murderers received far more lenient treatment. Meek personally believed that murder was by far the worst crime, but he was in the minority.Footnote 16 In honor-based culture, it was more honorable to kill than to steal in some circumstances, particularly if it involved theft of livestock. When C. B. Burnett killed a man who had stolen some of his cattle and who, upon discovery, “approached B[u]rnett in a threatening manner,” the jury ruled the death a justifiable homicide.Footnote 17 In 1878, when the National Police Gazette carried out a campaign against violence, it charged that “the murderer is a hero with the people, press and clergy of Texas.”Footnote 18 In contrast, it was not uncommon for cattle or horse thieves to receive five to ten years in the state penitentiary.Footnote 19
Those incidents that made it to court seldom resulted in convictions.Footnote 20 In 1876, a grand jury indicted W. E. Race and Henry Gadberry for challenging each other to a duel in Uvalde County, but the court dropped the charges because there had been no clear violation of the law.Footnote 21 Will Hale shot a Mexican gambler who had cheated him at cards, and when his victim's brother came to avenge him, Hale shot him as well. Although the authorities arrested Hale, they did not hold him, and the case never came to trial.Footnote 22 Similarly, few cases in the early years of Donely County in the Panhandle ever made it to trial despite the many indictments for murder.Footnote 23
In the late nineteenth century, as industrialization proceeded and the cattle industry became more corporate in outlook, the behaviors associated with honor culture faded from middle- and upper-class lives. They survived, however, among working-class men such as cowboys. Like the Virginia gentry in the colonial era, cowboys sought to prove their prowess by grand boasts at the gambling table as well as extravagant bets. Their attitude was one that made a virtue of risk and irrational and reckless spending. They also were willing to fight for what they considered the slightest insult. Self-assertion and manly pride were marks of status in their society.Footnote 24
Unfortunately, as what had been fighting with fists in the eighteenth century turned into fighting with guns in the nineteenth, the results of such fights were often lethal for the loser.Footnote 25 Moreover when honor was involved, revenge killings were not unusual. According to his autobiography, when white outlaws killed his friend, Texas cowboy Will Hale swore he would kill the men who had done it. It took some time, but Hale finally tracked down his man in Caldwell, Kansas, and killed him in a fight at the roundup.Footnote 26 Hale's autobiography is an interesting document, as many of his stories seemed designed for the most excitement rather than accuracy. However, the stories he chose to tell, true or not, are almost unrelentingly violent ones in which he was the aggressor or the avenger, interspliced with many tales of courtship. If his purpose was to show what a great man he was, Hale did so by showcasing his fighting and killing abilities, sexual prowess, and his defense of personal honor.
In the twentieth-century effort to rehabilitate the cowboy image, it was the concept of honor that most former cowboys stressed, ironically downplaying the violence itself. Charlie Siringo saw gun ownership as a sign of manhood. If a tenderfoot came to a ranch without a pistol, the cooks and other men in camp would not respect him.Footnote 27 Former cowboy William A. Preist explained violence within an honorable context, reporting that few “tough” men killed for money or did so in a dishonorable way. “They calculated that if you [were] not willing to match shooting ability with them . . . they had no business taking part in a difference with them. However, they would not intentionally take undue [advantage] of anyone.”Footnote 28 Brook Campbell, trying to argue that movie cowboy shootouts were not accurate, stressed that while cowboys carried guns “sometimes,” they did it mostly to kill deer.Footnote 29 Most sources, however, suggest that violence between men was a common aspect of life on the ranch and in town and tend to discredit such defenses of cowboy honor.
Violence seemed common on ranches. Ranch manager Frank Collinson reported two men getting into a gunfight over the words to a song when outfits from two different ranches camped together during a roundup. Due to lingering “unpleasant feelings,” the two ranches avoided camping in the same place after that.Footnote 30 Even within outfits men could turn on each other. Will Hale described the men on his father's ranch fighting among themselves in the off-season when they had no work to keep them busy. “It was all Wheeler [the ranch manager] could do to prevent a killing.”Footnote 31 In 1880, a cowboy from the Millett Ranch, in Baylor County, wrote to the Fort Griffin Echo to defend the reputation of the cowboys against charges of undue violence, in the process confirming its frequency. He reported that in the past five years there had only been two murders and that considering the ranch employed between sixty-five and seventy men each spring, all of whom came armed, the fatality rate was fairly low.Footnote 32
With so many guns, violence seemed to be a normal part of cowboy existence. Rancher Hilory Bedford believed that when they returned from fighting the Civil War, men had brought home the habits of war with them. Although he meant the more noble traits such as scorn for false bravado, his observations might also apply to the habits of fighting themselves.Footnote 33 Indeed, as writer Bill Neal suggests, violence and indifference to it on the Texas frontier was less surprising given the many years of violence that had preceded with the Texas Revolution, Civil War, Reconstruction, Indian Wars, and fighting along the Rio Grande.Footnote 34 In the early 1870s, many Texas cowboys resented the lawmen in the northern states because most of them were ex-Union soldiers and the cowboys were ex-Confederates. As a result, cowboys often picked fights when the lawmen arrested them for drunkenness, which could have deadly results.Footnote 35 The casual nature of violence seems surprising to modern readers. In the 1880s, the newspapers regularly reported cowboys killing each other, usually as the result of a trivial dispute.Footnote 36 Jewish cowboy Morris Wilds, a herd boss for the King Ranch and an ace billiards player, lost a bet in Corpus Christi but refused to pay the man who had beaten him. The winner consequently shot and killed him.Footnote 37
Casual violence as well as the negative response it provoked from townspeople and cattlemen alike suggest that honor was not the only factor at play. Historian Ty Cashion argues that popular accounts have exaggerated and romanticized the violence on the Texas frontier as involving honor and heroics. Such stories have obscured both the brutal nature of the violence and the different motivations for it. Indeed some of the violence came from the very efforts of townspeople and the legal system to control it.Footnote 38 In Texas, there was a strong legacy of using violent means to maintain public order, with lynchings of whites as well as blacks quite common. In general the argument for such “informal justice” was that on the frontier, regular courts and police were far away and so it was necessary for the citizens to preserve order themselves. Historian Richard Maxwell Brown has also highlighted similar violence in the cause of “incorporation” across the West. In this scenario, business interests came into conflict with local settlers and elements they could not control in their efforts to build their businesses and towns. Although profit often motivated their actions, they usually claimed to be acting to maintain social order.Footnote 39 This effort to maintain social order also corresponded with new middle-class ideals of masculinity.
In the early years of the frontier, cattlemen did not oppose violence if done for a just cause. Indeed, if leading men carried out violence in the name of social order then it too could be an assertion of superior manly morals. Charles Goodnight complained of the lack of social order in the Panhandle in the early 1880s, particularly in Mobeetie and surrounding Wheeler County, which, he claimed, gamblers and “dance hall people” had organized in secret. According to Goodnight, every county officer except one judge was living with a prostitute, and thus the officials' concern was to prevent law and order rather than maintain it. Moreover, even when the officials were honest men, it was common for cattle thieves and criminals to be acquitted because of the testimony of perjurers, who testified in return for free whiskey and prostitutes provided by the defendant's compatriots. Given this environment, the cattlemen eventually began to threaten extralegal action in the form of lynchings to punish cattle rustlers. Faced with the threat of violence, the thieves agreed to leave the area.Footnote 40
Incorporation gunfighter Pat Garrett worked closely with conservative business interests in the Panhandle.Footnote 41 Although they supposedly brought Garrett and his LS Texas Rangers to the region to round up cattle rustlers, Panhandle cattlemen also wanted to shut down the ringleaders of the cowboy strike of 1884, who were causing problems after their strike had failed. Garrett engaged in several violent encounters with cowboys in the name of restoring order.Footnote 42 In the eyes of cattlemen like Goodnight, such violence would have been more than justified, as it represented the interests of the respectable men in the county. Moreover, in the absence of other authorities, cattlemen were also used to enforcing the law—at least their law—on the frontier.
As the frontier faded and settlement increased, the primary motivation for cattlemen and other businessmen was to establish a proper social order with families and homes as the primary focus.Footnote 43 Violence was not a part of this equation, particularly gun violence. Disarming the cowboys was the logical first step. The usual process was to incorporate the town and then hire police officers and pass concealed weapon laws.Footnote 44 Even the notorious Panhandle town of Fort Griffin started to regulate use of guns within town limits. In 1881, the citizens of Fort Griffin successfully petitioned the governor to declare that Shackelford County was no longer a frontier county so that they could enforce the state laws against side arms.Footnote 45 In 1883, the El Paso Lone Star reported that the movement to disarm cowboys in the city, once derided, was growing in strength and that many ranchers refused to hire men who carried weapons.Footnote 46 Few towns wishing to attract settlers wanted any gun violence, and so most passed laws restricting weapons as soon as they had a large enough population to do so. Reflecting middle-class views of proper masculine behavior, the Fort Griffin Echo warned the cowboys that shooting “does no good but may unintentionally cost a life; it is not an indication of bravery or manly spirit, but evidence of a depraved nature.”Footnote 47
The next concern of the cattlemen was to regulate alcohol use. Numerous violent incidents resulted from drunken sprees, and violence seemed especially common in cow towns where saloons flourished. Although not all cattlemen were temperance advocates in their personal lives, most cattlemen avoided excessive drinking themselves, whether under the influence of wives, trying to set an example for the men, or by choice.Footnote 48 Indeed, self-discipline and middle-class manhood depended on being able to control behavior like drinking. The added fact that excess alcohol could lead to a loss of restraint in other areas made it an easy target. In 1914, the editor of the History of Cattlemen of Texas argued that “the business world will no longer tolerate a worker who drinks to excess and in fact a ‘drinking man’ is looked upon with suspicion in every industry.”Footnote 49 The livestock industry was no exception. By the 1890s, middle-class men saw drinking as a sign of weakness and a barrier to success, and as success defined middle-class masculinity, it was a barrier to manhood as well.
For working-class men, however, the act of buying a drink for a friend was a bonding one and was part of the public performance of masculinity.Footnote 50 Because taverns and saloons were off-limits to respectable women, and generally men went there to be with each other and relax, saloon drinking was a sign of manhood.Footnote 51 Drinking also allowed workers to thumb their noses at respectable society, which disapproved of it.Footnote 52 But violence often stemmed from excessive drinking. Drunken cowboys frequently rode around town discharging their weapons in the air and engaging in fisticuffs.Footnote 53 In 1885, a group of cowboys tried to “take” the town of Marionfield, and a battle ensued between the cowboys and the sheriff and his posse, ending with one cowboy dead and another mortally wounded.Footnote 54 When a group of Texas cowboys in town in Wyoming became drunk and rowdy, one cowboy shot his friend for trying to convince him to sleep it off, and in the uproar that followed another drunk shot the sheriff.Footnote 55 In the 1870s, the homicide rate in Dodge City, Kansas, the ending point for many Texas cattle drives and site of many cowboy sprees, was ten times that of New York City. Most of these deaths were from gunshots, and two-thirds of those killed were unarmed at the time of their deaths.Footnote 56
Cowboys themselves did not think saloon violence was excessive. Former cowboy W. E. Oglesby defended the cowboys' actions saying the shooting in the town was all in fun, usually no one was hurt, and the boys would always go back later and settle for damages.Footnote 57 The latter assertion was likely an exaggeration, but there were cases in which a trail boss paid for the damages his men caused, and at their local saloons men tended to be a bit more circumspect in their actions. Even saloon owners preferred the cowboys' boisterous behavior to no business, and one savvy owner told the cowboys, “Anything goes, boys, but me and the mirror.” He then bet them their drinks that they could not shoot a wine glass at the end of the bar. “Of course that took all the fun out of it, and there was never much shooting in his place.”Footnote 58
Cattlemen, however, saw cowboy drinking as something they needed to control. In the 1880s Panhandle ranchers called in the Texas Rangers to eliminate the problems of unlicensed saloons, which they believed contributed to cowboy violence and general social disorderliness. In at least one case, the effort to restore order in the name of incorporation may have itself provoked violence, as the cowboys in Teepe City promised to put up a fight against the rangers on Christmas night, shooting at anything they saw.Footnote 59 Drunken violence usually backfired on the cowboy when it came to confrontations with the law, but it was part of the ritual of public drinking, and the confrontation itself could also enhance a cowboy's manly reputation. In truth, while most towns passed liquor licensing laws and laws restricting alcohol use on Sundays, they only succeeded in driving cowboy drinking out of public views, not in changing the behavior itself.
For working-class men, fighting was often as much about performance as any animosity toward or insult from the opponent. Violence was not always a sign of hostility, as aggressive exchanges such as charlie horses had always been a masculine way for boys to express friendship.Footnote 60 The violence could often seem out of proportion to the reason for it, and deaths often came as a result of small insults. But in working-class tradition, the emphasis had always been to do as much damage to one's opponent as possible, and the “best” man in a community was often the best and most vicious fighter.Footnote 61 Fights might arise suddenly and for trivial reasons but could end just as quickly. In Taylor County in 1869, cowboy “Jim B.” took offense at the high-toned manners of a city-bred cowboy in his trail outfit. Eventually Jim insulted the man enough for him to dismount and aim his gun at Jim, demanding an apology. Jim pulled his guns and refused to apologize, but the city man killed him before he could get a shot off and then fled. The rest of the men buried Jim and continued on the trail “two men short but with no discordant element among us.”Footnote 62
In working-class settings, the role of violence was thus to resolve social disorder. Violence solved disputes, but when it was over, the two sides were not supposed to hold a grudge.Footnote 63 In a fight, the winner proved his manhood and dominance, but as long as the loser stood up and fought as well, he maintained his own honor, thus there was no reason to continue the argument.Footnote 64 Grudges likewise disrupted the harmony of a cattle outfit. Whereas cattlemen maintained social hierarchies in their relationships, cowboys usually prized reciprocity and equality within an outfit.Footnote 65 Unable to earn approval of their character from people away from the ranch, it was important for cowboys to earn approval from each other in the closed society of the cow camps. As one woman who lived near the XIT Ranch recalled, “The boys were from every walk of life, the educated and the uneducated, but were equal as cowboys.”Footnote 66 Fighting was one way in which all men had an equal chance to prove themselves as men.
In one area, however, white cowboys were concerned about maintaining proper social order. Although they prized equality among themselves, that sense of brotherhood did not usually extend to nonwhite cowboys. Like their cattlemen counterparts, they used violence as a way of maintaining racial hierarchies. Violence against nonwhites was endemic throughout society. After the Civil War, lynch mobs and other vigilante groups also focused on maintaining racial order.Footnote 67 Anglos became increasingly worried that Mexicans and African Americans would try to wreak revenge on them for the way the Anglos had treated them in the past. In the 1870s and 1880s, there was almost racial warfare in the Nueces Strip over cattle thievery on both sides. Anglos mostly attacked Mexican nationals, but they targeted Mexican Americans as well in their zeal. Elsewhere in the state, Anglos kept Mexican Americans racially subordinate though violence, using the Texas Rangers to harass them as well as vigilante lynchings.Footnote 68 The same was also true for African Americans who faced increasing numbers of lynchings in the 1880s throughout the South and Texas.Footnote 69
African Americans were frequent victims of racist violence at the hands of inebriated white cowboys. In 1874, a white cowboy started a fight with a black hod carrier in town. Both went to jail, but upon release the cowboy killed the hod carrier and escaped prosecution. In 1879, when a group of drunken white cowboys came through Ogallala, Nebraska, on their way from Texas, they decided it would be fun to shoot at a black man's feet. No one stopped them until one shot went astray and nearly hit the wife of the stationmaster, at which point the sheriff raised a posse and drove the cowboys out of town.Footnote 70 In Dodge City, a group of rowdy Texas cowboys saw a black man dressed in a fancy hat, bet they could shoot a hole through it, and then shot it from his head. When the man ran off, the boys kept the hat as a souvenir and hung it up in the saloon like a trophy.Footnote 71 Black cowboy Bones Hooks never stayed long in Mobeetie, as it had a reputation of being unfriendly to blacks, despite that fact that before 1890 the majority of African Americans in the Panhandle lived there.Footnote 72
Other ethnic minorities faced similar violence. In 1895, a grand jury indicted Monroe Clayton for aggravated assault in Pecos County for assaulting Cesario Martinez, a Mexican sheepherder, by roping him and dragging him from his horse as well as striking and bruising him. The judge dismissed the case for lack of evidence.Footnote 73 The few Chinese in the state, largely Chinese restaurant owners in West Texas, mostly tried to avoid trouble with whites, but court records show assaults against them as well.Footnote 74 In 1881, as exaggerated fears of a “Yellow Peril” taking over the country spurred discussions of immigration restriction in Congress, the El Paso Herald reported a drunken Anglo cowboy shooting into a Chinese-owned restaurant, promising to drive all the Chinese out of the country and endangering bystanders before local citizens killed him.Footnote 75
Minorities risked further violence for speaking out of turn. When tenderfoot James Shaw and a black cowboy named Albert were the only men to stay with the herd while the rest of the outfit ran away to drink in Dodge City, they were not pleased. Albert rebuked the ringleader of the other cowboys saying pointedly, “Where do you suppose dem cattle would abin if Mr. Shaw and me had went to town,” but his complaint backfired. Shaw drew his pistol on Albert, saying, “It's all right, ain't it, Albert?” Albert was only able to reply, “Yes, sah cos it [is].”Footnote 76 A study of Mexican workers in South Texas showed much the same pattern. Mexicans had to be deferential to whites at all times, although whites could talk to them on familiar terms. They could laugh with the Anglos but never at them, although Anglos could make fun of Mexicans whenever they liked.Footnote 77 Vaqueros on the Kenedy Ranch also valued propriety in social relations, especially with the owners, whom they considered to be living in a different world with different rules.Footnote 78
At times honor could trump social order and cause Anglo cowboys to defend cowboys of color against violence from outsiders. Two cowboys, one black, one white, went into town at the end of the trail, and when a white drunk harassed the black cowboy his buddy jumped in and defended him. When a cattleman berated the white cowboy for defending a black man, he picked a fight with him as well.Footnote 79 In a San Angelo saloon, when Bill Oden refused to serve a black cowboy named Golden, the black man came behind the bar and tried to serve himself, precipitating a fight in which several whites, possibly from his outfit, came to Golden's defense.Footnote 80 When a restaurant at the end of the trail refused black cowboy Bones Hooks service, his white buddy Bob Donald reached for his gun, saying, “I came a thousand miles to kill a so-and-so like you. Bring the boy his meal.”Footnote 81 In each of these cases, the honor of the outfit seemed to outweigh racial hierarchy. Nonetheless, it is clear from late nineteenth-century sources that race played a role in the hierarchy of masculinities. In the opinion of the white majority, white manhood was the epitome of virility and masculinity; thus being a minority automatically meant a man was less of a man. In part, white workers retained a sense of masculinity by considering themselves superior to blacks, Hispanics, and certain immigrant groups.
In addition to controlling the racial social order, cowboys also used violence to regulate gender relations. Self-conscious of their lower status, cowboys were uncomfortable around “good” women, whereas they easily formed relationships with women on the margins of society.Footnote 82 But they clearly did not value these women very highly, and ironically, they were not even able to protect those women they could possess. On the one hand, they would fight to protect any woman they considered worthy of their protection, whereas on the other they were just as capable of violence toward those they deemed unworthy. Despite their generally friendly relations with prostitutes, cowboys (and other frontier denizens) did not see them as proper women, as testified to by the number of incidences of violence these women endured.Footnote 83 A true woman lived in the private sphere of home. Prostitutes operated in the public sphere, where they had no protection from insult and violence.Footnote 84
Some cowboys also believed it was their role to keep women who acted outside of proper boundaries in line. The publications they read in the bunkhouse such as the National Police Gazette confirmed and modeled these beliefs, highlighting stories of women who stepped outside of accepted behavior and the consequences that befell them as a result.Footnote 85 In 1885 local authorities arrested a cowboy in a San Antonio brothel for threatening to kill one of the prostitutes who had abandoned him after he bought her drinks.Footnote 86 Pat Bullis, a line rider from the East Panhandle in the 1880s and 1890s, recalled a number of horrific violent incidents involving cowboys and prostitutes.Footnote 87
One story Bullis told privately illustrates both the dynamics of cowboy relationships with prostitutes and the esteem in which they held respectable women. Bullis and his outfit visited a dance hall in Oklahoma Territory to let loose. A prostitute newly arrived from the East Coast immediately tried to seduce the cowboys, but they were not ready for company, and one told her not to bother them. Rebuffed, the prostitute called him a “son of a bitch.” Bullis explained that this particular term was
dangerous language to use to a cowboy or any Westerner. . ., and in those days it was a “fightin'” word. We couldn't hit a woman, so a couple of the boys grabbed her by the legs, and stood her on her head. Another puncher picked up the spittoon and dumped all it's filthy contents between her legs. The others held her until all that nasty stuff had saturated her clothes and completely covered her body. She took the next train back East.Footnote 88
The hypocrisy of degrading a woman in defense of the purity of womanhood did not touch these men, who thought their actions entirely appropriate. Undoubtedly, the “boys” thought it was their prerogative to police disreputable women, and the story has the tone of any of the many cowboy caper tales in other narratives. Although such stories are rare in cowboy memoirs, it is quite likely that, recognizing such behavior was no longer acceptable, the narrators censored their writings and that there was far more of this behavior than they saw fit to report to decent society.Footnote 89 The shock of a reader a century later at such actions only highlights the difference in perception. Bullis's statement, “We couldn't hit a woman,” highlights that a prostitute occupied a middle ground; she did not merit the respect given other women.
Many cowboys still acted with great chivalry toward prostitutes, when trying to protect them. Teddy Abbott claimed that cowboys would never cheat a prostitute and would beat up pimps and other men who abused them. He even defended one prostitute's honor, almost killing a man simply for calling her a whore. Abbott himself recognized the irony of the situation: “Knight of the plains. Had to protect all females. Lord!”Footnote 90 That a man could protect a woman was a measure of his masculinity, but given that cowboys believed women they encountered were seldom worthy of gentlemanly protection, keeping social order was an alternative way of demonstrating manhood. Thus violence was a way of both protecting womanhood and policing it, but it was also a way for cowboys (and other working men) to assert their masculine dominance over women.
Patriarchal authority often justified violence under the guise of controlling the household. Just as some fathers were abusive parents, some husbands abused their spouses, and there were often few people around to restrain them.Footnote 91 Texas women had made frequent complaints against their husbands for brutal violence in the 1840s and 1850s, and many Anglo Texan men intimidated their wives with their rough treatment.Footnote 92 The frequency of assaults against women in the court records of the late nineteenth century suggest times had not changed much.Footnote 93 Such concepts of masculine power extended across ethnicities. In African American society, patriarchal behavior was common in private relationships, as black men experienced emasculation in the public sphere.Footnote 94 On the Kenedy Ranch, male authority was supreme among vaquero families to the point that the oldest son had more authority than his mother.Footnote 95 Vaqueros could gain a sense of manhood from their role as husbands and fathers in a way cowboys elsewhere could not.Footnote 96 Patriarchal identity within Mexican homes often meant strict control over daughters, and many Texas cowboys who attempted to date Mexican girls had their hope squashed by their fathers. When two Anglo cowboys befriended a Tejano family, they assumed that their attentions to the daughters of the household were welcome. When they eloped with the girls to Corpus Christi, however, the father swore to kill both the cowboys and his daughters because he “believed his girls had disgraced themselves and his family.”Footnote 97
Although cattlemen and cowboys used violence to maintain both honor and order, in later years, when more people settled the frontier, violence seemed counterproductive to most middle- and upper-class men. One of the reasons for the changing view of violence was the decline in the traditional basis for patriarchy. In an industrial world, property loss was impersonal and far more common, thus the concept of male honor was less relevant. Because it was easier to lose property, it was no longer feasible or rational for gentlemen to resort to violence against an impersonal market force. Thus violence among the middle and upper classes no longer had a purpose, at least when aimed at each other.Footnote 98
Religious influences also played a role in tempering violence. As historian Edward L. Ayers points out, southern culture revolved as much around religion as it did honor. Some attempts at social control were indeed sincere efforts on the part of God-fearing, evangelical Christians to save cowboys from hell, based on deeply held beliefs about the sinfulness of violence.Footnote 99 In 1886, ranch manager B. H. Campbell explained how Christian gentlemen behaved in a dispute with G. W. Scarborough, a part-time minister who had contracted to build a fence for the XIT Ranch. Scarborough had demanded payment for the job, saying he had a group of angry men waiting for their pay, which Campbell took as a threat:
I positively will pay no man one dollar nor will I make any settlement nor promise to pay while he is holding over me a threat of bodily harm . . . I am ashamed to [have to] write out such a rule and to such a man. I have had sometimes to explain to a cowboy who never had an opportunity to learn anything better, that it was a crime to demand money of another under threat of harm even tho' the other actually owed him, but I never before had to explain this common-sense proposition to a minister of the Gospel.Footnote 100
Campbell implied that the contract was his word to pay and should have been sufficient for Scarborough. He also made it clear that violence was not the way to settle matters of honor among Christians.
However, as Ayers explains, religion could be too constraining to fit masculine identity.Footnote 101 That was particularly true for working-class men like cowboys. The church was the province of women. Despite efforts of men in the late nineteenth century to assert a new “muscular Christianity,” religion projected an image of home and femininity. Most cowboys had no more use for religion than they did other social niceties from the world of women.Footnote 102 Hilory Bedford tried to bring his men under religious influence as a fatherly gesture and brought a circuit preacher to his ranch in the summers. He also gave sermons himself when the preacher could not come. He noted that the men came out of respect for him but seemed uninterested in the message.Footnote 103 Many westerners had practical approaches to religion. Former cowboy S.A. Wright “didn't make any big pretences towards religion” but “liked to be with nice religious people,” if for no other reason than “a person and their property is a great deal safer among religious people than amongst atheists.”Footnote 104 Nonetheless, as the frontier moved further west, the nice religious people Wright preferred to associate with made up the majority of the townspeople.
By the 1890s, most vigilante justice had given way to more mundane, less violent, forms of control. As the towns' populations of “respectable” people increased, they insisted on law and order. Rather than hire vigilante lawmen, cattlemen established livestock stock associations to prevent cattle theft through roundups and to regulate employee behavior in a more standardized fashion.Footnote 105 Justices of the peace brokered solutions to small conflicts that might previously have ended in bloodshed.Footnote 106 Courts met more regularly and returned more guilty verdicts, and towns placed legal restrictions on disorderly behavior.Footnote 107
By the 1890s, most violent crimes at least gained a hearing in the courts. In 1891, W. D. Browning came to trial for assault with intent to kill after attacking J. B. Atkinson, who had called him a lying son of a bitch in the course of a debt dispute, an affair of honor that might not have reached the court in earlier years.Footnote 108 Nonetheless, convictions were still most likely if the death involved an employee of one of the large ranches, and the killer was from elsewhere. In these cases the ranch owners would marshal the whole outfit to go to court to testify against the killer. When the 1902 trial of George Jowell for the murder of Spur Ranch employee John Lindley resulted in a hung jury, the Spur's lawyer received a change of venue to Armstrong County and told ranch manager Fred Horsbrugh to make sure all the Spur “boys” who had witnessed the attack would show up to the new trial. The tactic seems to have been effective, as the new jury convicted Jowell, who earned a two-year sentence in the state penitentiary.Footnote 109 The increasing involvement of the courts and ranch managers in these disputes reinforced a changing attitude between ranchers and cowboys. For cowboys, violence was still necessary to restore order and honor; for the modern cattlemen, violence destroyed order and was itself, generally dishonorable.Footnote 110
Cattlemen clearly modeled the transition from honor culture and corporate vigilantism to controlled aggression, particularly between generations. While Richard King loved a fistfight, his son-in-law and successor Robert Kleberg frowned on such behavior as showing a lack of restraint. By the 1880s, rational business ideals had, for the most part, come to dominate the cattleman's mentality. King was El Patron to the kineños, but Kleberg was El Abagao (the Lawyer).Footnote 111 Cattlemen increasingly based their masculinity on ideals of channeled aggression and the ability to maintain appropriate social relations. They identified with a larger community beyond the ranch and saw themselves as having more refined sentiments than their employees. Although honor was important, especially to those who had southern backgrounds, ultimately, as they became leaders in the community, they saw their role as requiring them to restrain their impulses. Like the cowboys, they identified self-reliance as a key aspect of their manhood. Unlike the cowboys, however, they had greater opportunity for success as a result of their efforts. Their business success and social status as gentlemen thus reinforced their masculine identity.
Middle-class men in the late nineteenth century expected to be aggressive in the marketplace but tried to control and channel their aggression into activities such as sport or body building in their leisure time. Physical strength was part of the new ideal of manhood but not brute force.Footnote 112 A little youthful aggression was healthy. Richard Mifflin Kleberg, grandson of Richard King, was a good student and popular young man but was at one point suspended from school for fist fighting, an act that only enhanced his manly reputation in his youth.Footnote 113 Such attitudes mirrored prescriptions for proper boyhood behavior from people such as Theodore Roosevelt, who advised that the American boy should be able to hold his own in any circumstances.Footnote 114 But to middle-class men, the distinction between a boy and a man increasingly became the ability to restrain aggression and impulses, as well as a sense of responsibility to family and the larger society.Footnote 115
The mark of a real man by these new middle-class standards was how well he controlled himself. George Littlefield, who practiced restraint as a rule, voiced his indignance when an assailant nearly cut his nephew to death in a fight: “I am sorry you did not have a Pistol and Shoot the Cowardly Devill down at [the] time.” But despite his outrage, he deferred to legal punishment. He warned his nephew to wait before responding: “It would be a good thing to get the Drop on him as He did you and give it to him. But the Law would be against you.” Instead, Littlefield advised, he should wait until authorities arrested the man and pursue a lawsuit after he was already in jail.Footnote 116 Matador Ranch manager Murdo Mackenzie credited the fact that he did not carry a gun as the reason he avoided further violence. When he first took over the ranch, the former ranch foreman threatened his life, but Mackenzie simply confronted him man-to-man without weapons and won him over by calling his bluff.Footnote 117 Middle-class society equated manhood with self-discipline and stigmatized those who did not practice it as less manly.Footnote 118 Not surprisingly, judged by these standards, the cowboys looked more like boys than men and accordingly were in need of restraint.
Cattlemen and townspeople thus tried to impress upon the cowboys that truly masculine behavior was nonviolent. Newspapers praised peaceful resolutions of disputes. In 1877, the Lampasas Dispatch printed letters of apology ending a feud between two ranches, which had resulted in several shootings. The editor commented, “This is manly, and exhibits more true courage than to shoot down an enemy.”Footnote 119 Even cowboys recognized the difference between themselves and the cattlemen. Joe Meador worked as the straw boss on the Stripe Ranch in the mid-1890s, where he described the owner “Captain Morriss,” as “one of the finest men I ever knew to keep out of trouble.” When Morriss expected a group of outlaw cowboys at the roundup, he told his men to leave their guns at home and then talked to the outlaws, telling them that his men were all unarmed. “He told them we were all law abiding citizens and the only way they could take any of the cattle would be by force of arms, and if they did that we would appeal to the law.”Footnote 120 Such an approach might not have been effective in the 1870s, when law enforcement officers and courts were few and far between, but evidently it worked well in this case, proving the value of restraint over force and showing Morriss to be the better man as a result.
As historian William Savage has noted, by the 1890s, journalists routinely castigated the cowboy for his appearance, his violence, and his seeming lack of morals. “He was not the sort of person one would take one's children to see; he was, rather, a pernicious influence best avoided by responsible persons.”Footnote 121 By 1914, the image of cowboys had so deteriorated that John Clay, who managed the Wyoming cattle interests of a Chicago corporation, could say in a speech before the Feeders Convention that “the chief obstacle of the range at that time, . . . was the cowboys, who were mostly illiterate, uncivilized; who drank and thieved and misbranded cattle, and with a kind of rough loyalty, never told on one another in their crimes.”Footnote 122 The very behavior that cowboys believed was manly, the people around them saw as childish or savage, and thus, one by one, the towns had begun to restrain this particular form of unbridled masculinity through legal restrictions on guns and drinking.
As evidence of this transformation of opinion, a unique genre of humorous anecdotes at the cowboys' expense appeared in the mid-1880s. These stories mocked the cowboys' crude violence and masculinity in the face of better and wiser “dudes” who had previously been the object of ridicule for the cowboys. In one such story, three cowboys attempted to intimidate a well-dressed salesman on a train platform by stepping on his feet, but the salesman sent them away “completely cowed,” after shooting three apples in mid-air. The punch line was that the salesman was a rapid shot medal winner.Footnote 123 In another story, “the doodest dood,” who dressed in ridiculous clothes, drank only lemonade, and had come to Texas to fight consumption, bested in a fight one of the toughest men in the local bar, who had made fun of him and tried to force him to drink gin. The dude was so impressive that when he asked the other men to drink lemonade with him they quickly agreed to do so.Footnote 124 These stories were ways of asserting superiority over the cowboys by showing that they were less manly than the “civilized men” who bested them. The Dude, once the victim of cowboy violence for the sake of humor, now used more civilized and restrained forms of violence to keep cowboys in line.
In the cowboy myth that evolved through dime novels and films, the manliest cowboys only use violence as a last resort and only then in the service of defending womanhood or honor. Honor was indeed part of the justification for violence that the historical cowboy used, but it was also an increasingly outmoded way of thinking in the late nineteenth century. Moreover some of the violence that cowboys participated in was far from honorable. We can only really understand how cowboys used violence to define their masculinity if we expand our concept of its role. Violence reinforced social order even as it asserted a man's honor. The emphasis on violence to restore equilibrium in the cow camp or among cowboys in town was a reflection of the need for cowboys to have one place in their lives where they felt in control. The ability to direct and order society was a sign of masculine power. Cattlemen could control all the people around them, whereas white cowboys for their part could control only those weaker than themselves, in particular women and minorities. Black or Hispanic cowboys had even less power in society though perhaps as much within the family setting. The humorous hijinks with the dudes on the train were also an expression of this strain of violent behavior. Dudes were inferior beings in the West, and if they were incapable of dominating those of lower social status, they were also less manly. But ultimately cowboys were not in control of their lives; they were workers in an industry in which their employers tried to restrain their impulses toward violence as ways of asserting their own masculinity.
