The Chilean Sociedad de la Igualdad or Society of Equality (1850–1) was short-lived, but it has enjoyed a reputation far beyond its duration. Sympathetic historians have seen it as the cornerstone of labour organising in Chilean history, as the beginnings of a leftist political tradition in the country, and even as the start of Chilean modernity. James Wood asserts that all of this is well and good, but he makes it clear that he is most interested in how the association appeared on the scene in the first place, and not so much in what came after or how its long-term significance has been interpreted. His point is that there is a tradition of popular republicanism, going back to the very beginnings of independence (1818), that has led, through successive stages, to the emergence of artisans, not only as a significant political force but also as proponents of an alternative, more egalitarian view of republicanism and democracy. This evolution, in turn, has much to say about Chilean political history in the post-independence period.
Independence brought new ideologies and competing formulas of state and nation-building, but in Wood's account none were more significant than republicanism, which permitted the expansion of the public sphere and provided an opportunity for the popular sectors to establish their identity and pursue their own aims. The pillars of this republicanism were constitutional law, which recognised artisans as active citizens (and therefore eligible to vote); the Civic Guard; and the practice of elections (p. 240). In the early phase the main concern of artisans and Civic Guard personnel was equality, by which they meant primarily equality for voting purposes. Over time, this emphasis would turn to more specific labour concerns and to forms of mutual-aid organising.
One of the principal sources utilised by Wood, in addition to pamphlets, government documents and secondary sources, is the press of the period, which is indeed as rich as it is colourful. The author examines such papers as El Hombre del Pueblo, El Descamizado and La Barra, as well as several papers that have the word ‘artisan’ in their title, as a way to identify the elusive working-class voice in the loud chorus of political hawking of the press during the period. Wood recognises the problem of eliciting this voice – and well he might, if one considers that Domingo Faustino Sarmiento was known to impersonate both an artillery lieutenant fighting at Chacabuco and a young woman inculcating the virtues of reading – but in the end proceeds as if he has indeed found it. These artisans (and civic guardsmen) are protagonists of their own history, and their republicanism represents an alternative view to the elite versions that have dominated Chilean history and historiography. Disarmingly, Wood concedes that some of these non-elite sectors tended to embrace ‘a corporatist alternative to liberal republicanism’ (p. 150), and admits, concerning the Sociedad de la Igualdad, that ‘most artisans and laborers did not join the association’ (p. 209). If this is the case, how could they ‘implement an alternative, more egalitarian and democratic vision of the republic’ (p. 187)?
Unfortunately there are numerous mistakes that mar an otherwise smooth reading. Wood speaks of the arrest of Santiago Ramos ‘by the federal government’ (p. 133, and again on p. 137) in the 1840s – that is, the era of the centralist 1833 Constitution. He refers to José Miguel Infante as a ‘war hero’ and lists him as a ‘General’ in the index. Infante could be quite lethal in his attacks, but he never wielded anything other than a pen. More serious, perhaps, are the errors of interpretation: Wood speaks of the Universidad de Chile as teaching students from its inception in 1843, when in fact it did not do so until decades later (he gets it confused with the ‘delegación universitaria’ at the Instituto Nacional). Wood also appears to believe that the staged press polemic on orthography between Andrés Bello and Sarmiento was real (p. 156), when in fact the two were co-authors of the 1843 reform. Although Wood is not alone in this regard, he continues to misconstrue the charges against Francisco Bilbao for immorality, blasphemy and sedition (p. 170) as if they descended from a thunderous and omnipotent Church and state, when in fact they came from a very specific, and very liberal, press law of 1828. The Church, it must be understood, had no ability to prosecute civil cases, so its role was confined to preaching and publishing tracts against its perceived godless enemies. By the 1850s, the Church was itself a target of the state, to the point that the Supreme Court condemned its archbishop to exile.
These errors of fact and interpretation can fortunately be corrected, but the deepest flaw of the book would require reconceptualising and rewriting. Wood is unequivocal about ‘the fraudulent nature of Chile's republican electoral system’ (p. 172). He apparently relies too heavily on Domingo Amunátegui Solar's deeply flawed – and obsolete – La democracia en Chile (Universidad de Chile, 1946). Wood quotes Solar as an authority and derives from him the central notion that runs through the book: ‘There is not much point in studying the outcome of elections in nineteenth-century Chile. They were foregone conclusions, rigged in some way by agents of the government or the landowners' (p. 18). Although he often cites sources (albeit not all that could be cited) by the leading scholar of Chilean elections, J. Samuel Valenzuela, Wood appears to ignore Valenzuela's fundamental point: elections are significant well beyond what the actors of the period, or subsequent scholars, made of them. There is much empirical research that must be conducted, and has been conducted, before elections can be dismissed in this fashion. Creating effective electoral systems has been, and continues to be, one of the most difficult challenges of any representative political system in the world, but Chile, in Wood's account, appears to have seen far more than its comparative share of manipulation and corruption, a view which is indeed essential to the argument of the book. If one adds the features of ‘patriarchy’ and ‘elitism’ (pp. 242–3) that allegedly characterise the country's nineteenth-century history, and that close the assessment of The Society of Equality, there is room to wonder about the purpose of adding yet another iteration of the same foregone conclusion.
