Kim Bowes describes the position hitherto of private worship in early Christianity as ‘an embarrassing relative, [who] it has proven easier to ignore than to invite to the table’ (9). B. therefore goes on to seat this neglected family member at the head of the table and serves four distinct courses (plus an introduction and conclusion). The four main chapters, although seemingly disparate at first glance, are all source-led approaches well-suited to the author's wider agenda. This is where B. will surely succeed in the intention of not being the final word on the subject but to put the issue of private worship and its impact on the development of late antique Christianity firmly into the existing discourse (15).
This publication provides a narrative for the private religiosity of élite Christians in the fourth and early fifth centuries. In light of the abundance of studies on early Christianity which examine the establishment of the Church, this book and its focus on private expressions of Christian worship is a welcome addition. B. utilises archaeological and textual evidence in order to examine domestic rituals and religious spaces, uncovering the reactions to Christianity of the wealthy élite who were outside ecclesiastical organizations. Roman priesthoods and civic offices were held by members of the same few élite families and therefore religious and political roles reflected the hierarchy of the community (22). This was not the case in the early ecclesiastical hierarchy which meant that the wealthy Christian élite and their friendship and patronage networks had no small impact upon the development and negotiation of what it was to be Christian. B. frames this as part of the wider late antique concern of determining both what was Christian and what was familia (7).
In the introduction, B. addresses the glaring issue of using the terms ‘private’ and ‘public’ because her main thesis relies on this distinction. This is done pragmatically by considering them as relative terms with blurred boundaries; with a sense of meaning rather than as clear-cut divisions. In the first chapter, which sets the parameters for the rest of the book, aspects of public and private in Roman religions (including first- to third-century Christianity) are summarized. Family, friends and patronage are identified as particular priorities and even legal boundaries of public and private were ‘legally precise and practically porous’ (44). Ch. 2 utilises Rome and Constantinople in the fourth and early fifth centuries as the foci for examining private Christian worship. B. categorizes various forms of non-ecclesiastically led and largely domestic-based worship as ‘private’ expressions of piety, including private endowments; domestic churches; privately-run churches; house asceticism; and some aspects of martyr cult. From ch. 2 onwards the focus of this work is entirely on Christianity. If there is scope to extend this work's approach to include non-Christian religions in the fourth and fifth centuries, as a seemingly natural extension of the first chapter, this would surely add a further behavioural comparison to assess ‘public values’. This is one area where the work may stimulate further research.
Ch. 3 is a largely archaeologically-based study which examines various rural sites solely from the Western Empire, including villas, villa temples/churches and mausolea. B. posits that private asceticism adapted the tradition of the élite Roman's otium and so private Christian rituals were taken to élite country estates (126). This led to some tension between these élites and their often lower-status bishops, who were usually based in cities (127). The final chapter adds a further dimension, this time based largely on texts, by examining the polemic associated with the religious ‘private’ in Christian writings as an expression of both heresy and sanctity depending on purpose. Familiar texts and figures from ascetic studies and heretical debate are reinterpreted here to effective ends. By and large the source material and case studies throughout this work (most notably in chs 1, 2 and 4) are well-known but they have been examined in a new and informed way (on this note, the bibliography is extensive, varied and relevant). This is one of the work's strengths because it adds to both the religious and social narrative of the period. This book addresses the question of the nature of the general relationship between individuals, predominantly the wealthy élite, and the expanding collective of the public Church hierarchy (3).
The crux of B.'s argument revolves around the enduring significance of social customs associated with friendship, patronage and kinship (218). These were so intrinsic across the Roman world that they were transferred to Christian religious practices, often to the discontent of bishops and public churches, who were trying to negotiate their own power and influence in this period. The definition of the family was changing but could still be seen to frame private worship through domestic buildings and private endowments in cities and on country estates. I suggest that this book would be of interest not only to religious historians but also to social historians of Late Antiquity through its re-evaluation of the development of Christianity in the fourth and early fifth centuries in terms of the response of private worship, rather than in terms of the negotiation and establishment of the Church. This combined with a sprinkling of humorous metaphors has made for an interesting and stimulating publication.
