In War on the Gulf Coast, historian Gilbert Din offers an exhaustively researched and highly detailed account of Spain's confrontation in the Floridas with William Augustus Bowles, a contest which lasted roughly from 1788 until Bowles's death in a Havana prison in December 1805. An emeritus professor of Fort Lewis College (Colorado) trained at the University of Madrid, Din is the author of several highly regarded books on the Gulf Coast, including Spaniards, Planters and Slaves (1999) and Francisco Bouligny: A Bourbon Soldier in Spanish Louisiana (1993), among others.
Din argues that the Spanish contest with Bowles has not received the attention it merits and the “neglect of both Bowles and the Gulf Coast Spaniards has produced a gargantuan misunderstanding about him and his real character” (xi). Born in frontier Maryland in 1763, Bowles saw Revolutionary War service in West Florida as a teenage British Loyalist. From Pensacola he absconded to Creek country in the late 1770s, where he took at least two indigenous wives, including the daughter of mestizo Lower Creek leader William Perryman. He returned to Pensacola as it fell to Bernardo Galvez in 1781, and was sent to Havana and ultimately to New York to await the war's end. He subsequently joined the Loyalist exodus to Nassau, where he continued his self-education and indulged his acting talents. Bowles returned to Creek country in 1785 and claimed to have been elected to a Creek war council in 1787. With backing from Nassau merchants and officials, who hoped to wrest control of the southeastern Indian trade from Panton, Leslie and Company, a British Loyalist firm which had extracted exclusive southeastern trading privileges from the Spanish, Bowles launched an ill-fated filibustering expedition in 1788. He returned in 1789, when he claimed to have been elected director general (eastajoca) of the Creek Nation. Din disputes the claim and criticizes earlier biographers, especially J. Leitch Wright (1967), for accepting it too readily (29).
In Din's view, Bowles's “deep-seated ambition was to gain charge of what is now the American Southeast and create an indigenous polity,” the state of Muscogee, “over which he would exert control,” albeit under British protection. For nearly two decades, “he labored to rouse Creeks and Seminoles into supporting him with the surreptitious introduction of arms and goods, battled the Spaniards and pleaded for British governmental intervention” (x–xii).
After traveling to Canada and England in 1790–91 to gain official sanction, Bowles returned to the Gulf Coast in 1791 and managed to capture and loot the Panton store at Wakulla in January 1792. Duped by the Spanish into traveling to New Orleans (for Wright an example of “Spanish duplicity”), he was subsequently sent to Havana and then on to Spain itself. Bowles spent two years in the Philippines before he managed to escape off the coast of Africa. With Britain and Spain at war, Bowles gained a measure of unofficial British backing for his Muscogee enterprise and returned to the Gulf Coast in 1799. In May 1800, with the support of dissident Seminoles, he was able to capture the poorly defended and supplied Spanish fort of San Marcos de Apalache. Pensacola commandant Vicente Folch y Juan directed the fort's recapture in little over a month. Bowles then turned to raiding Spanish holdings and to creating a makeshift “Muscogee navy.” The 1802 Peace of Amiens ended Anglo-Spanish hostilities and undermined unofficial sanction for Bowles. An unfriendly regime in Nassau denied political support or trade goods and an August 1802 treaty negotiated at San Marcos de Apalache ended Lower Creek and Seminole allegiance to Bowles. He was apprehended by Indians at a council meeting at Hickory Ground (near present-day Montgomery) in May 1803 and turned over to the Spanish, who sent him to New Orleans and ultimately to Havana, where he died in captivity in 1805.
Although the book is deeply researched and judiciously argued, the writing is sometimes dry and disjointed. The story is told largely from the Spanish point of view and perhaps even with a certain rooting interest. Din displays an impressive familiarity with recent literature, including ethnohistory and historical archaeology. He does not mince words about whom he does and does not care for: Bowles is “a rascally adventurer;” Folch is “arrogant and power-hungry.” Din closes with a careful recounting of the legal cases against Tomás Portell for surrendering Fort San Marcos in May 1800 and Bowles for capturing it (among many other misdeeds). He makes a spirited case for Portell's defense. In all, Professor Din offers a worthy addition to the fascinating history of a region undergoing wrenching transition.
