The past decade has witnessed a critical reassessment in theatre and performance studies of the temporal and geographical edges of the avant-garde as both theory and practice. Moving outward from Eurocentric canonical studies by Renato Poggioli, Peter Bürger, and Matei Călinescu, the “historical” avant-garde has found itself productively displaced, misplaced, and replaced in recent scholarship. Mike Sell's The Avant-Garde: Race, Religion, War grapples with the term “avant-garde” not as a collection of objects or artists, but as a sociological modality that slides across disparate spaces and times. Focusing on commonly disavowed aspects in vanguard movements, Sell utilizes the tropes of race, religion, and war to create discipline-blurring configurations.
In his introduction Sell constructs a working definition of the avant-garde as “a minoritarian formation that challenges power in subversive, illegal or alternative ways, usually by challenging the routines, assumptions, hierarchies and/or legitimacy of existing political and/or cultural institutions” (41). This essentially sociological definition displaces the avant-garde thing with the avant-garde action: “propaganda by deed.”. It is this performative dimension that opens up a multiplicity of vanguards, not only in art or theatre historical contexts, but also in political, military, cultural, and social formations. Avant-gardes perform this social difference as temporal, fashioning themselves as agents ahead of their time. Race, religion, and war provide three different temporal contingencies through which to map vanguard performances.
In the chapter on race, Sell uses his case studies to examine the ways in which racialized bodies constitute and are constituted by minority formations. A motif throughout the chapter is the slippage between the double meaning of the word “minority” as a cultural formation always outside of power (such as an ethnic minority barred from citizenship) and what Sell terms “vested” (71) minority or cultural formations embedded within institutional confines (such as a minority political party). More conventional objects of study, such as futurism and surrealism, use this double meaning to interrogate the racist and racialist underpinnings of avant-garde institutional critique. Less expected vanguard performances, such as the Afrikaner Broederbond in South Africa and the French Medical Corps in Algeria, demonstrate the ways in which a minority position both on the margins of and within power can further a political project, for better or worse. Arguing for an inherently raced origin of the avant-garde, Sell digs out the racist underpinnings of the nineteenth-century utopian vision of vanguardism promoted by Henri de Saint-Simon. This trajectory moves to Max Nordau's long-neglected fin-de-siècle book on the avant-garde, Degeneration, which provided scare tactics for prudish bourgeoisie parent and budding fascist alike in its assessment of the bodily decadence prompted by avant-garde aesthetics. The insidious nature of the vanguard body, for Nordau, lay within its devolved and epidemiological character; the minority quality of the avant-garde became raced and furthermore threatened to spread even into the domestic confines of the white middle class. Sell provocatively argues that Nordau's work, along with being a racist progenitor of the Nazi entartete Kunst, also serves as the origin of avant-garde theory that begins with the art object and works outward toward the social. Leveling his own institutional critique, Sell ends the chapter by examining potential models for avant-garde scholarship and practice that begin with the social and work inward as a means of disrupting racist genealogies in the field.
The second chapter examines religion's engagement with avant-gardes through its epistemological, institutional, cultural, embodied, and object-oriented dimensions. The religiosity of the symbol uncovers the latent politics in l'art pour l'art, where mystery and obscurity become modes of resistance to the hegemony of capitalist rationality. Positing a Janus face of religion within vanguards, Sell identifies a concurrent rejection and embrace of both religious and antireligious content within examples as disparate as German expressionist playwright Ernst Toller's use of Christian imagery and structure, Artaud's body without organs, the mystical and occult threads in symbolism and surrealism, and the resurgence of Mayan religion in Guatemala. Recent Jewish, Muslim, and Christian fundamentalist movements are examined as embodying simultaneous nostalgia for a pure religious time and embrace of modern military and communication technology. These alternative vanguard genealogies veer far from twentieth-century Europe, but often matrix its history as well.
Sell's final chapter on war takes seriously the military origins of the term “avant-garde,” broadening his analysis to special forces units, guerrillas, and sappers (demolition specialists) and paying special attention to the relationships between military vanguards and aesthetics. Correlations are drawn between aesthetic and military strategies, such as futurism in relation to the Italian occupation of Ethiopia, and the Dirty War in Argentina in relation to the performative politics of Las Madres de Plaza de Mayo and theatrical representations of the desaparecidos in the work of La Pista 4. Sell argues for an aesthetic/representational approach to analyzing warfare in addition to its instrumental, existential, and metaphysical dimensions, and focuses not only on warfare's impacts on culture, but on the cultures of vanguard military formations.
The breadth and diversity of the case studies that Sell examines in these pages necessitates that he rely primarily on secondary source material. Thus, this work is less a contribution to original research and more a valuable, unexpected collage of scholarship unlikely to come into dialogue elsewhere. This collaged technique, recognizably avant-garde in a formal sense, provides a potential model for the future of avant-garde studies. If the avant-garde is less a catalog of things and instead a series of social formations, then the future of avant-garde theory may lie within such an assemblage technique across geography and time.
