Multiple forms of violence perpetrated by a wide range of actors have become a pervasive and unavoidable reality for millions of people in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC). Increases in lethal violence, but also in other forms of crime and victimisation, have been recorded in the region since the late 1980s. Since then, LAC has experienced the greatest increases in fatalities and become the most violent region in the world. In this context, Tina Hilgers and Laura Macdonald intend to ‘shed light on the nature and causes of violence in the Americas’ (p. 4) in Violence in Latin America and the Caribbean. By inviting political scientists, sociologists and geographers to reflect on how violence in particularly relevant cases from across the region intersects with economic, political, institutional and cultural processes, the editors not only identify important factors shaping contemporary violence in the region, but also make an extremely valuable and timely invitation to rethink the research agenda on violence.
The key argument of the book is that differences in levels and manifestations of violence in localities across LAC are explained by unique ‘intersections between individual and group identities, social and political configurations of power, political institutions, economic characteristics and history at the local, regional and national levels’ (p. 7). Nine chapters engage with this argument and provide compelling illustrations of how these intersections shape multiple forms of violence in four cities and eight regions in Meso-America, South America and the Caribbean.
As they explore commonalities among the cases, the editors argue that contemporary violence in the region is shaped by social structures, such as colonialism and slavery, and by long-term historical divisions, which have intensified due to neoliberal policies and globalisation. The way democratisation and decentralisation unfolded in the region is also identified as a contributing factor, as it created conditions and incentives for perpetuating anti-democratic practices and for the use of violence by powerful actors at local and subnational levels. Some of the chapters also illustrate how democratisation had unexpected consequences on policing, which remains trapped in notions of public security that lead to the criminalisation and violent repression of marginalised groups. While these findings confirm what other studies of violence have shown, an interesting contribution to our understanding of the dynamics of violence in the region is the unpacking of the role of clientelism in reproducing violence and shaping responses intended to address it. In this regard, Hilgers and Macdonald argue that structural and direct forms of violence in the region also respond to patterns of social embeddedness and complex networks that connect actors willing and able to exercise violence to society and state institutions. As two chapters on Mexico City (Markus-Michael Müller; Lucy Luccisano and Macdonald) and one on Kingston (Yonique Campbell and Colin Clarke) clearly illustrate, clientelism as a hierarchical and unequal connection between citizens and the state has perpetuated police violence, divided communities, fuelled violence for political gains and increased the capacity of the state to control marginalised communities that are targeted by repressive and more ‘preventive’ policies.
By highlighting new relations between clientelism and violence, this book rightly draws our attention towards the power structures in which violence is immersed and to the ways in which it becomes lucrative to powerful actors. These are crucial issues, especially against the backdrop of extremely unequal societies. It is a weakness that the implications of the argument are not sufficiently explored in the analysis of ‘anti-violence’ policies in the region, as it has the potential to help break the myth that the solution lies in dealing with the ostensible way in which the marginalised become violent, rather than in addressing the way in which the powerful instrumentalise and benefit from violence.
This limitation, however, does not obscure the book's extremely valuable contribution to rethinking the research agenda on violence. Violence in Latin America and the Caribbean is built around thought-provoking questions that help revitalise the study of the problem and the potential solutions. By questioning what the relevant types of violence are in each case and by using a broad definition that includes structural and direct forms of violence, the book breaks with the uniformity with which we tend to refer to ‘violence’ and reminds us of its multiple expressions beyond homicides. This probably explains why the book not only includes chapters on Kingston, Rio de Janeiro and localities in El Salvador and Colombia, places commonly associated with the crisis of violence in the region, but also two chapters on Argentina, a country with comparatively low homicide rates. This book also asks who the victims of violence in each context are, placing identity, as well as space, as imperative variables to consider. Although other scholars have shown how experiences of violence vary across race, gender, age, ethnicity and class divides, these variations need to be studied more systematically.
In terms of methodology, the editors explore how we might improve the way we study violence. Supported by the authors’ contributions, they demonstrate the importance of considering different scales of analysis and focusing on subnational contexts, as well as the benefits of cross-disciplinary and qualitative research. Jean Daudelin's chapter on the limitations of the current research agenda is particularly valuable and strengthens the book's contribution. It highlights, among other issues, the problems and blind spots produced by relying on homicide rates to understand the complex phenomenon of violence, and from conflating lethal violence and crime. It is also extremely refreshing that the editors include contributors’ honest reflections on the challenges involved in undertaking fieldwork on violence, especially in terms of access, safety of researchers and participants, and ethical problems derived from producing knowledge on such sensitive and emotional topics.
As a whole, Violence in Latin America and the Caribbean presents a more complex picture of the problem of violence in the region, recognising its dynamic and multifaceted nature and how it is inserted in locally defined historical processes of social change. For some, especially those concerned with ‘measuring’ the problem and ‘testing’ responses, this sort of complexity might seem less appealing. However, challenging static and compartmentalised analyses of violence that isolate it from economic, political and cultural processes, as this book does, is a necessary step towards finding new avenues for research and, more importantly, identifying new constructive ways to address the current crisis of violence and security in the region.
