Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T23:50:47.312Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Vortex-dipole collapse induced by droplet inertia and phase change

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  26 October 2017

S. Ravichandran*
Affiliation:
TIFR Centre for Interdisciplinary Sciences, Narsingi, Hyderabad 500075, IndiaJawaharlal Nehru Centre for Advanced Scientific Research, Jakkur, Bangalore 560064, India
Rama Govindarajan
Affiliation:
International Centre for Theoretical Sciences, Shivakote, Bangalore 560089, India
*
†Email address for correspondence: ravi@jncasr.ac.in

Abstract

Droplet-laden flows with phase change are common. This study brings to light a mechanism by which droplet inertial dynamics and local phase change, taking place at sub-Kolmogorov scales, affect vortex dynamics in the inertial range of turbulence. To do this we consider vortices placed in a supersaturated ambient initially at constant temperature, homogeneous vapour concentration and uniformly distributed droplets. The droplets also act as sites of phase change. This allows the time scales associated with particle inertia and phase change, which could be significantly different from each other and from the time scale of the flow, to become coupled, and for their combined dynamics to govern the flow. The thermodynamics of condensation and evaporation have a characteristic time scale $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{s}$ . The water droplets are treated as Stokesian inertial particles with a characteristic time scale $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{p}$ , whose behaviour we approximate using an $O(\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{p})$ truncation of the Maxey–Riley equation for heavy particles. This inertia leads the water droplets to vacate the vicinity of vortices, leaving no nuclei for the vapour to condense. The condensation process is thus spatially inhomogeneous, and leaves vortices in the flow colder than their surroundings. The combination of buoyancy and vorticity generates a lift force on the vortices perpendicular to their velocity relative to the fluid around them. In the case of a vortex dipole, this lift force can propel the vortices towards each other and undergo collapse, a phenomenon studied by Ravichandran et al. (Phys. Rev. Fluids, vol. 2, 2017, 034702). We find, spanning the space of the two time scales, $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{p}$ and $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{s}$ , the region in which lift-induced dipole collapse can occur, and show numerically that the product of the time scales is the determining parameter. Our findings agree with our results from scaling arguments. We also study the influence of varying the initial supersaturation, and find that the strength of the lift-induced mechanism has a power-law dependence on the phase-change time scale $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70F}_{s}$ . We then study systems of many vortices and show that the same coupling between the two time scales alters the dynamics of such systems, by energising the smaller scales. We show that this effect is significantly more pronounced at higher Reynolds numbers. Finally, we discuss how this effect could be relevant in conditions typical of clouds.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2017 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Table 1.Typical values for parameters in a growing cumulus cloud: the large-scale length, time and velocity scales ($_{0}$ quantities) are typically orders of magnitude larger than the Kolmogorov scales ($_{k}$ quantities). Typical Reynolds numbers defined as $Re={\mathcal{L}}_{0}{\mathcal{U}}_{0}/\unicode[STIX]{x1D708}$, where $\unicode[STIX]{x1D708}$ is the kinematic viscosity are $Re\sim O(10^{7})$.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Schematic of the interactions that determine a cloud flow. Labelled against the particular interaction are the mechanisms that arise in this study: (1) inertial particles are expelled from vortical regions; (2) phase change takes place only in regions with particles; (3) buoyancy acts selectively in regions where phase change occurs; (4) differential buoyancy results in baroclinic torque and, thus, production of small-scale vorticity.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Positions of the vortices (left: positive-signed, right: negative-signed) at early times, for the case $St_{p}=1$, $St_{s}=200$. The vortices are shown at $t=10,30,50,70$ (a–d, respectively). Due to their mutual induced velocities they move slowly vertically upwards, but they are also seen to move closer to each other and begin to distort from their circular shape.

Figure 3

Figure 3.(a) Trajectories of the oppositely signed vortices. The vortices are tracked by locating the maximum and minimum vorticities in the box. This procedure fails when the parent vortices are annihilated. The case shown has $St_{s}=200$, $St_{p}=1$. The circles are drawn at intervals of $\unicode[STIX]{x0394}t=1$. (b) The horizontal separation between the vortices, showing different regimes of motion: the initial regime where the vortices behave like a standard dipole; the final regime where the vortices behave like the buoyant dipole of Ravichandran et al. (2017); and the short-lived intermediate regime where the system transitions between these two limiting behaviours.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Radial profiles of liquid concentration at early times (indicated next to each curve). Also shown in the figure are the corresponding vertical displacements of the vortex pair from the initial vertical location of the vortex dipole. The size of the region with no liquid grows slowly with time, and the minimum liquid mixing ratio keeps falling.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Horizontal profiles of the temperature $\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}$ (a) and the vapour mixing ratio $r_{v}$ (b) in the initial stages of evolution for the case $St_{s}=200$, $St_{p}=1$. At each time, the vertical location $y$ is chosen to be coincident with that of the vortex centroids. Clearly seen are the (colder and vapour-rich) voids formed because of particle inertia. Also seen, because of the accumulation of the droplets around the vortices in ‘halos’, are higher temperatures regions around the vortices. The profiles, as expected, are symmetric about the horizontal centre ($x=3\unicode[STIX]{x03C0}$). The vertical dotted lines are drawn at the horizontal locations of the ‘halos’.

Figure 6

Table 2.Table showing the times at which the kinetic energy reaches a minimum (which is a reasonable proxy for the annihilation time) for various combinations of $St_{s}$ and $St_{p}$. Combinations for which simulations were carried out are marked with either a ‘$\infty$’, suggesting that the lift-induced mechanism does not operate, or a finite value for the annihilation time. A ‘$\times$’ indicates that no simulation was performed.

Figure 7

Figure 6.A sequence of snapshots showing the lift-induced vortex annihilation (description in text). The snapshots are shown at simulation times $t=80,90,100,110,120$, respectively. Panels (a–e) show the vorticity $\unicode[STIX]{x1D714}$, (f–j) show the temperature $\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}$. The Stokes numbers were $St_{s}=200$ and $St_{p}=1$. Note also that by approximately $t=110$, the vorticity maximum has switched sides, relative to $t=0$. See also figures 2 and 3.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Vapour mixing ratio $r_{v}$ (a–e), and liquid mixing ratio $r_{l}$ for the same time instants and initial conditions as in figure 6.

Figure 9

Figure 8.A sequence of snapshots showing details of the final stages of the annihilation of the vortices. Note that the actual erasure of the original vortices occurs after the kinetic energy has reached a minimum (at $t=105$ in this case; see table 2). Panels (a–c) show the vorticity $\unicode[STIX]{x1D714}$, and (d–f) the temperature $\unicode[STIX]{x1D703}$. at simulation times $t=121,123,125$ respectively.

Figure 10

Figure 9.$St_{s}=200$, $St_{p}=1$. (a) The evolution of the (box-averaged) temperature (left axis) and the liquid and vapour mixing ratios (right axis) as a function of time. The temperature reaches $95\,\%$ of its equilibrium value by $t=25$ (also see figure 5). (b) The kinetic energy (left axis, solid line) and the enstrophy (right axis, dotted line) as a function of time. The dipole collapses at approximately $t=105$, which is the time the kinetic energy reaches a minimum (see also table 2). Around the same time, the enstrophy begins to increase rapidly.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Contour plots of $\unicode[STIX]{x1D714}$ at $t=0,100,200$ (a–c), showing the complete absence of any lateral drift for the vortices, for $St_{p}=1$, $St_{s}=25$. The reason for this is that the temperature difference between the vortices and the ambient is very small (d), even though the liquid-free void keeps growing in size (e).

Figure 12

Figure 11.Plot showing a boundary in the $St_{s}{-}St_{p}$ plane where the lift-induced vortex-dipole collapse can occur as a result of particle inertia and thermodynamics. Crosses indicate that vortex annihilation was observed in the simulation. Noughts indicate that the buoyancy did not cause a fundamental change in the dynamics of the vortex dipole. The dashed line is a plot of the relation $St_{s}St_{p}=80$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.A sequence of snapshots showing lift-induced vortex annihilation for asymmetric initial conditions. The snapshots are shown at simulation times $t=60,80,90,100,110,120$ (a–f, respectively). The Stokes numbers were $St_{s}=200$ and $St_{p}=1$, and the vortices were initially separated by $5d_{0}$ and $0.5d_{0}$ horizontally and vertically, respectively.

Figure 14

Table 3.Effect of the initial supersaturation on the times to dipole collapse. The notation is the same as in table 2, and $t_{1.02}$ and $t_{1.04}$ are the times for dipole collapse for simulations starting with initial supersaturations of $2\,\%$ and $4\,\%$, respectively.

Figure 15

Figure 13.A sequence of snapshots showing the evolution of the vorticity of a system of many vortices at $Re=5000$. The snapshots are shown at simulation times $t=10,20,30,50$ (a–d, respectively). The Stokes numbers were $St_{s}=200$ and $St_{p}=0$. The corresponding vorticity plots for the case with inertia $(St_{p}=1)$ are shown in figure 14.

Figure 16

Figure 14.A sequence of snapshots showing the evolution of the vorticity of a system of many vortices at $Re=5000$. The snapshots are shown at simulation times $t=10,20,30,50$ (a–d, respectively). The Stokes numbers were $St_{s}=200$ and $St_{p}=1$. The corresponding vorticity plots for the case without particle inertia $(St_{p}=0)$ are shown in figure 13. Note that until approximately $t=20$, the systems with and without inertia look similar, since it takes the thermodynamics time to take effect. The arrows point to annihilation events.

Figure 17

Figure 15.A sequence of snapshots showing the evolution of the temperature in the same system as in figure 14. The snapshots are shown at simulation times $t=10,20,30,50$ (a–d, respectively). The Stokes numbers were $St_{s}=200$ and $St_{p}=1$.

Figure 18

Figure 16.A sequence of snapshots showing the evolution of the vorticity of a system of many vortices, with parameters $Re=20\,000$, $St_{s}=200$ and $St_{p}=0$. The snapshots are shown at simulation times $t=10,20,30,50$ (a–d, respectively). The corresponding vorticity plots for the case with particle inertia $(St_{p}=1)$ are shown in figure 17.

Figure 19

Figure 17.A sequence of snapshots showing the evolution of a system of many vortices, with parameters $Re=20\,000$, $St_{s}=200$ and $St_{p}=1$. The snapshots are shown at simulation times $t=10,20,30,50$ (a–d, respectively). The corresponding vorticity plots for the case without particle inertia are shown in figure 16.

Figure 20

Figure 18.A sequence of snapshots showing the evolution of the temperature in the same simulation shown in figure 17 ($Re=20\,000$, $St_{s}=200$ and $St_{p}=1$). The snapshots are shown at simulation times $t=10,20,30,50$, respectively.

Figure 21

Figure 19.The average kinetic energy (left axis) and enstrophy (right axis) in simulations starting with identical initial conditions in identical boxes. Both simulations have phase-change Stokes number $St_{s}=200$. The particle Stokes numbers were $St_{p}=0$ (dashed lines) and $St_{p}=1$ (solid lines). (a) $Re=5000$, (b) $Re=20\,000$. For both Reynolds numbers, the enstrophy increases significantly for the case with non-zero particle inertia.

Figure 22

Figure 20.The kinetic energy spectra for simulations with and without particle inertia for $Re=20\,000$. Dashed lines show simulations with $St_{p}=0$, and are seen to have lesser energy at higher wavenumbers. $k^{-3}$ lines are shown for references.

Figure 23

Figure 21.The kinetic energy and enstrophy fluxes for the simulations with $Re=20\,000$. The enstrophy flux plots (a,b) show that enstrophy is transferred to higher wavenumbers preferentially for the case with $St_{p}=1$. The kinetic energy flux plots (c,d) also show the same behaviour, but for a smaller band of wavenumbers.

Figure 24

Figure 22.Plot of vortex annihilation times as a function of the parameter $(St_{s}St_{p})^{1/2}$. A linear fit is shown, providing a minimum value for $(St_{s}St_{p})^{1/2}$ below which our mechanism will not operate.

Figure 25

Figure 23.The ratio of vortex-dipole collapse times for two different values of the initial supersaturation plotted against the product of the Stokes numbers, showing an as yet unexplained power-law dependence. Note that the $x$-intercept here is roughly the same as the boundary at which the mechanism stops working (see figure 11). We have not found an explanation for the exponent ${\approx}1/3$.

Figure 26

Figure 24.Time required for a void of a given radius to form, showing that the use of the approximate equation for particle dynamics does not lead to great errors. The two measures for the void-formation time (in the case where the particle dynamics is not approximated) are the maximum time required for every particle starting within a given radius to leave that radius ($\max (t_{res})$) and the average time required for an initially uniform-in-space distribution of particles to leave a region within a given radius from a vortex ($\langle t_{res}\rangle$). The two measures do not differ greatly either from each other or from the void-formation time implied by (2.16) (see § 4.1).

Ravichandran supplementary movie

The movie shows the evolution of the four quantities (ω , θ , rv , rl) for the many-vortex case Re=5000, Stp=1, Sts=200. See figures 13–15 in the paper and corresponding text.

Download Ravichandran supplementary movie(Video)
Video 11.8 MB
Supplementary material: PDF

Ravichandran supplementary materials

Supplementary Materials

Download Ravichandran supplementary materials(PDF)
PDF 1.6 MB