The scholarly literature on Jordan has tended to tread a familiar path in recent decades, focusing largely on certain time-honored topics. Among these are Jordan's relations with Zionism and Israel; the state's complicated relationship with the Palestinians; Jordan's role in intra-Arab politics; and regime history, including the political lives of the country's Hashemite monarchs. In particular, the legendary Hussein bin Talal (r. 1952–99)—Jordan's longest-serving king and, indeed, one of the world's longest-serving rulers of the 20th century—long has intrigued Westerners. A number of authors with varying academic credentials have, over the years, written his biography (and he was rare among Middle Eastern leaders for having written an English-language autobiography). Yet most of these writings suffer from a lack of serious and critical examination of their subject and were produced without the benefit of important documentary sources. In the book under review, Nigel Ashton breaks with this trend by providing us with a thorough, scholarly, and nonhagiographic account of the man Western diplomats once referred to as the “PLK” (Plucky Little King), the Middle East's consummate political survivor. The author has done so by utilizing hitherto unavailable documentary sources, having secured remarkable and unprecedented access to the late king's personal correspondence files in the Royal Hashemite Archives in Amman—a feat one doubts could have been accomplished in any other Arab country.
King Hussein of Jordan sheds important light on Hussein's childhood and early life in Jordan and abroad in Egypt and England and details the drama surrounding the assassination of his grandfather, King ʿAbdullah, in 1951, the installation of his father King Talal, and the latter's forced abdication in 1952 due to mental illness. Yet on the whole, the book does not dwell much on Hussein's early years on the throne, and when it does discuss key events from that period, it sometimes does so less than satisfactorily. For example, Ashton's handling of the country's important April 1957 political crisis, in which it appeared that elements within the military had risen up against him, leaves something to be desired and does not explore in great depth what really occurred. Were Hussein and the monarchy truly facing a military revolt? Or were the events instead a “palace coup” staged by Hussein and the old guard? We also read very little about Hussein's behavior during some of the key events in Jordan's history that occurred during the first two decades of his rule, especially the June 1967 war. In the section on the September 1970 fighting between the Jordanian army and Palestinian forces that precipitated a Syrian invasion of Jordan, Ashton does discuss Hussein's secret attempts to contact Israeli leaders. Using American diplomats as intermediaries, Hussein tried to determine what, if any, help Israel might be able to provide to repel the Syrians. However, Ashton goes on to note that “[t]he only significant role Israel played in this process was an indirect one [by providing intelligence data]” (p. 154), omitting the fact that the Israeli air force eventually played an important role in prompting invading Syrian tanks to retreat by staging mock bombing runs against them, though the author curiously mentions this fact elsewhere in the book (p. 187).
Ashton is at his strongest in his analysis of the later years of Hussein's reign. Indeed, a full two-thirds of the book deals with the period after the 1967 war. The biography offers us detailed insight into Hussein's dealings with various American presidents as well as Israeli and Arab leaders. In these pages, the author makes valuable use of Hussein's personal correspondence files, to which Hussein's son, King ʿAbdullah II, allowed him access. For example, Ashton quotes from portions of Hussein's letters to U.S. President Ronald Reagan during the 1980s, including the king's frank reaction to news of the “Iran–Contra Scandal,” in which it was revealed that during the long Iran–Iraq War, the Reagan administration secretly sold arms to Iran even as it publicly assisted the Iraqi war effort. Hussein baldly wrote to Reagan that his attempt to understand the rationale for the U.S. government's actions were “in vain.” Ashton also benefited from interviews with several highly placed sources, including Hussein himself as well as his wife, Queen Noor, and his sister, Princess Basma. One interviewee related a particularly humorous anecdote: Hussein was startled when, during one of his first meetings with President Reagan in November 1981, the latter asked him how the fishing was in the Dead Sea (the water of which is so saline that virtually nothing can live in it, hence the name “Dead”). We also learn some revealing facts about Hussein's cooperation with the CIA in its attempt to foment a military coup against Iraq's Saddam Hussein in 1996 as well as on Hussein's battle with cancer and eventual decision to replace his brother, Hassan, with his eldest son, ʿAbdullah, as crown prince. Ashton provides equally revealing details about Hussein's decades-long, secret relationship with various Israeli leaders, politicians, and intelligence agents. We even learn that Hussein was so taken aback by Reagan's Dead Sea comment that he joked about it with Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres during a secret meeting the two men held in London in April 1987.
Overall, Ashton's biography is a well-written and welcome addition to the literature. It sheds new light not only on Hussein and Jordan but also on the Arab–Israeli peace process, Iraq, and other topics. The author should be commended for writing a penetrating, independent-minded biography despite the fact that the royal family clearly was happy to assist him in his endeavors by granting him unprecedented access to Hussein's archives. And although a political biography, the book provides glimpses into Hussein's personality and home life. Where it is weaker is in describing Hussein's relations with his own subjects. To be sure, Hussein seemed to revel in the world of diplomacy and high-profile politics and was impatient when dealing with more prosaic domestic matters. Yet he was keenly aware of his position as “head shaykh” of Jordan and carefully cultivated the image of the benevolent father of the nation. Given that the book's subtitle is “A Political Life,” one would have liked to have seen more discussion of domestic politics of Hussein's rule.
The book suffers from one additional detraction, which is no fault of the author: it was published shortly after the appearance of Avi Shlaim's biography of Hussein entitled The Lion of Jordan: The Life of Hussein in War and Peace (New York: Knopf, 2008). Shlaim's book first came out in the United Kingdom in November 2007, while Ashton's was published in the United States in September 2008, the same month that the American edition of Shlaim's book debuted. The fact that two scholars based in the United Kingdom wrote biographies of King Hussein, and published them at virtually the same time, is rendered even more oddly coincidental by the fact that the cover photograph of Hussein on Ashton's book is virtually identical with the one appearing on the U.S. edition of Shlaim's book, both photos having been taken at a January 1991 press conference. Scholars therefore can perhaps be forgiven for speaking of both books in the same breath. Coincidences aside, some of the wind was undoubtedly let out of Ashton's sails by the earlier appearance of Shlaim's own lengthy, excellent treatment of Hussein, and the two books cover many of the same topics. However, the merit and unique qualities of Ashton's book remain. If anything, scholars are only more enriched for having two serious biographies of Hussein bin Talal at their disposal.
