Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2005
Global bioethics is a bold project. In its moderate form, it aims to find solutions to the dilemmas posed by modern medicine and the biological sciences through intercultural understanding of human obligations and opportunities. In its more ambitious form, it endeavors to cover all possible ethical problems arising with regard to life and living things on earth. Given the ambitiousness of even the moderate aim, it is unsurprising that disputes are frequent and agreements are scarce. One of the most contentious issues is whether human rights should play an important role in global bioethics or not.A longer version of this discussion paper will appear as “The Future of Human Rights—Human Rights and Bioethics.” In: van den Anker, C Smith R, eds. Essential Guide to Human Rights. London: Hodder Arnold; forthcoming in 2005.
Global bioethics is a bold project. In its moderate form, it aims to find solutions to the dilemmas posed by modern medicine and the biological sciences through intercultural understanding of human obligations and opportunities.1
Campbell A. Presidential address: Global bioethics—Dream or nightmare. Bioethics, 1999;13:183–90.
Tangwa G. Globalisation or westernisation? Ethical concerns in the whole bio-business. Bioethics 1999;13:218–26.
The Western approach to bioethics depends almost entirely on the human rights discourse that regards individuals as autonomous decisionmakers whose rights to well-being and fair treatment have to be respected. But can this approach be universalized?
Parties in the dispute agree that a global approach to bioethical problems is essential for the future development of human societies. However, they disagree on the values and procedures that should inform this approach. On the one hand, Hyakudai Sakamoto, the President of the Japanese Association of Bioethics as well as the Asian Bioethics Association, has argued that the human rights discourse is a specifically Western approach to bioethics, which should not be imposed on other parts of the world.3
Sakamoto H. Towards a new “Global Bioethics.” Bioethics 1999;13:191–7.
Benatar S, Daar A, Singer P. Global health ethics: The rationale for mutual caring. International Affairs 2003;79:107–38.
This divide is not easily bridged. As already noted, one could say that Western bioethics relies almost exclusively on the concepts of individualism and human rights, and can often be described as anthropocentric (i.e., focused on human rather than plant or animal life). In contrast, the African worldview in bioethics has been described as “eco-bio-communitarian,”5
See note 2, Tangwa 1999.
See note 3, Sakamoto 1999.
The future might lie in a middle way between the two extremes of exclusively focusing on human rights and individuals versus a focus on human obligations and communities. But finding this middle way is a very challenging undertaking, one that at least requires agreement on essential cross-cultural values and principles, even if these were articulated in different terminology, ranked differently, and expressed in different moral practices.
What could the human rights discourse contribute to this undertaking? Whether one calls it a human right or a human capability (Amartya Sen, Martha Nussbaum), “life” is—above all—an individual asset. A mother who starves so that her children can live might make an invaluable community contribution, but she loses the one life she has. Similarly, “bodily integrity” and “health” are individual assets. The pains of violent attacks, torture, rape, hunger, cold, and disease are individual pains of separate human beings. Whatever the merits of altruism, modesty, humility, and willingness for self-sacrifice, there is a need to set limits to what one human can inflict on another (through action, e.g., violence, or nonaction, e.g., refusal of solidarity and beneficence). And the language of human rights is well suited to express these limits.
However, despite the strength of the human rights approach to formulate constraints, the language of human rights has its limitations in global bioethics for at least two reasons.
1. “Human Rights” is not a globally accepted concept and its sense is very weak and foreign in many parts of the world, for instance, in Asia.7
See note 3, Sakamoto 1999.
2. Insisting on rights without careful consideration of equivalent obligations and those able to discharge them could be regarded as highly irresponsible. A right to healthcare has no meaning if nobody exists who can discharge the equivalent obligation. Non-Western value systems could be invaluable in emphasizing the importance of obligations in ethical systems and filling this topic with substantive content, obligations not only with reference to other human beings, but also to other living entities.
Discussions in bioethics are well suited for intercultural dialogue and the exploration of diverse value systems, as the following example shows. Advances in healthcare increasingly move medical activities beyond national borders into a global setting. The fact that bone marrow transplants with nonrelated donors are carried out routinely nowadays has led to international bone marrow registers, to increase the chances of finding perfect tissue matches. But, of course, international cooperation in this area requires the harmonization of legal and ethical guidelines. The procedure of individual informed consent obtained from the bone marrow donor is taken for granted in Western countries. But, Japan, for instance, has a very strong tradition of prioritizing family consent over individual consent. Working out guidelines for international cooperation in the healthcare setting has, therefore, the strong potential to foster constructive dialogue.
And those who believe in global bioethics as an enterprise that will help to secure the values of freedom, equity, solidarity, tolerance, non-violence, respect for nature, and shared responsibility on a global scale8
Annan K. Millennium Report of the Secretary General of the United Nations. Available at: http://www.un.org/millennium/sg/report/summ.htm, accessed 17/06/04.