Readers of David Cook's works on Islamic apocalyptic literature will know that he is an inveterate collector of texts. Through diligent reading and clear translations, Cook has brought a great deal of material into the public eye. For that, we owe a debt of gratitude.
Understanding Jihad continues in this vein, albeit with a broader set of materials. In this volume, the reader will find wide coverage of texts from those genres most characteristic of Islamic tradition: chronicles of the Prophetic campaigns, punditry urging Muslims to resist injustice, treatises dealing with spiritual practice, and, of course, juridical opinion. The chapters are, for the most part, arranged so as to effect a historical or chronological presentation; within each chapter, materials are further classified according to specific issues or, in some cases, by geography.
To my mind, Cook's approach—let us call it “collection and classification of texts”—is best demonstrated in chapters 4 through 6, which deal with modern and contemporary materials. “Jihad during the Nineteenth Century: Renewal and Resistance,” for example, moves deftly from a treatment of the Wahhabi ikhwān to the Indian subcontinent, to Nigeria, then to the Caucasus. Cook presents the reader with basic information about the leadership, campaigns, and basic texts relevant to Muslim struggle in each of these cases. Similarly, in the chapters on “Radical Islam and Contemporary Jihad Theory” and “Globalist Radical Islam and Martyrdom Operations,” Cook provides solid information about writers and movements in the 20th and 21st centuries. The latter chapter includes a very interesting section in which contemporary miracle stories and martyrologies (many of which are attributed to Dr. Abdullah Azzam) are discussed in relation to juridical or parajuridical justifications for fighting in Afghanistan and other fields of struggle. In this section, and indeed throughout these chapters, Cook's persistence gives the reader a sense of the breadth and scope of Muslim discussion of these issues and raises interesting questions about the interrelation of different themes and contexts in which various groups raise the banner of jihad.
It must be said, though, that a clear and convincing assessment of these interesting questions will have to await another book. Readers duly impressed by the amount of material presented in this volume will be equally frustrated by the author's failure to state or to develop a coherent or consistent thesis. Cook's method of collection and classification deserves its due. How, though, should we organize a conversation about the materials he presents? Insofar as Cook offers an answer to this question, it is by way of engaging the debate between interpreters who assign priority to “spiritual” meanings of jihad and others who argue that primary meanings of the term are military. Certainly, there is some sense to Cook's desire to engage this debate; after all, one can cite authors (Muslims and non-Muslims alike) on both sides.
In the end, though, this seems a sterile discussion. As Cook notes, no one can deny the military valence of the term jihad, and he spends much of the first chapter, as well as several pages of an afterword, arguing that the military meaning is primary. At the same time, evidence from hadith literature and early references to martyrdom, as well as more recent apologetic writing, indicates that “jihad did [and does] not necessarily entail actual fighting” (p. 32). The question is, how are we to understand these rather distinctive referents of the term?
Cook's approach leaves the reader with the impression of inconsistency. We have military and nonmilitary uses of the term jihad; each must have some degree of validity. Is this validity a matter of historical context? Shall we say that some, evidently most, Muslims have and/or do use the term in one way or another, call for a virtual show of hands, and render a verdict? Or is there a way to bring these uses together, so that each makes sense, in its turn? Cook's passing references to jihad “theory” might suggest a way toward this last possibility. Unfortunately, his worries about the apologetic valence of nonmilitary interpretations of jihad lead to an almost total identification of such a theory with the military references of the term. We are still left with a kind of “preponderance of evidence” mode of settling the debate.
Why not, though, take seriously the idea that the root meaning of j-h-d suggests “struggle” or “exertion” that is, in the religious context, directed “in the path of God”? Why not say that any of several means of struggle may be considered appropriate to this task, depending on contextual factors? Why not, in other words, argue the case that in Islam, the first order of faith is neither fighting nor “spiritual resistance,” but obedience to God? The problem of jihad, as with other human endeavors, is thus a matter of discerning or comprehending the will of God in particular situations.
Among the plethora of books on jihad published since 9/11, David Cook's stands out in its ability to extend readers' awareness of the breadth of Muslim writing about the topic. Unfortunately, those same readers must continue to wait for a book that will guide them into the view of human responsibility that animates this writing and that brings together its various strands.
