No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 July 2005
There is no better reminder of the futility of the single-minded use of military force in support of postconflict stabilization missions than the abysmal security situation in Iraq almost two years after President George W. Bush declared major combat operations there completed. Experiences with multilateral peace-support operations in the mid-1990s and the early years of this decade highlighted for many analysts the need to move quickly beyond a military response to nonmilitary actions that provide the conditions under which postconflict societies can return to a degree of normality. In Where Is the Lone Ranger When We Need Him? Robert Perito makes the case for the necessity of restructuring how the United States undertakes postconflict stability operations. He argues that if it is to be effective, the United States must overcome its traditional resistance to constabulary forces and plan for the coordinated implementation of more broadly conceived stability forces. Perito's view is that this force must have four components: a robust and rapidly deployable military force that can compel warring parties to cease fighting, and if there is a peace agreement in place, to abide by it; an effective civilian, multinational Special Police Unit capable of undertaking law enforcement functions and controlling large-scale threats to public order; police, both civilian and military, that can restore and maintain public order and carry out law enforcement duties but will not usurp the role of an indigenous civilian police force (which would also have as part of its mission more mundane tasks such as traffic control and criminal investigations); and judicial and penal experts, working in courts and prisons, who can process those arrested and restore the public's sense of justice for victims of crimes. In addition, Perito asserts that “[a]ll elements of a U.S. Stability Force must be assembled and ready at the outset of military operations” (p. 328).
Perito brings a wealth of personal experience and scholarly research to this task. Following a career in the U.S. Foreign Service, Perito served as the deputy director of the International Criminal Investigative Training Assistance Program at the U.S. Department of Justice, where he supervised police-training programs for peace operations in Haiti, Bosnia, Kosovo, and East Timor. All of these operations figure in his account in Where Is the Lone Ranger? In addition to this personal experience, Perito brings to the work a scholarly research background that includes an M.A. in peace-operations policy and a year as a senior fellow at the United States Institute of Peace. This confluence of practical and academic experience enables Perito to bring a clear understanding and unique perspective to his analysis and recommendations for what needs to be done in postconflict situations.
The book is organized into an introduction and nine chapters. The initial chapters (“Introduction,” and “Brcko: SFOR vs. Rent-a-Mob”) set the stage for the book, highlighting conceptually and through example the issues that concern Perito. The introductory materials are followed by two chapters (“Constabulary” and “CIVPOL: Police in Peacekeeping”) in which Perito explores what a constabulary is—“armed forces of the state that have both military capabilities and police powers” (p. 46)—and describes how such forces have been organized and used within a variety of Western democratic societies. Five chapters of case studies follow (“Test Case: Creating Postconflict Security in Bosnia,” “Blue Box: The Multinational Specialized Unit in Bosnia,” “Odd Jobs: Constabulary Forces in Kosovo,” “Policekeeping: U.S. Policy on Peace Operations,” and “Nation Building: Biting the Bullet in Afghanistan and Iraq”). From these case studies Perito makes observations and draws lessons that lead to his concluding chapter, “Where Is the Lone Ranger When We Need Him?”
Perito's work is based on thorough scholarship as well as original research. Anyone interested in the subject of the rule of law in postconflict settings or in peace-support operations will find in it much material to follow up. The text of Where Is the Lone Ranger? is extensively annotated with footnotes to published, Internet, and policy literature as well as with references to original interviews conducted by the author. Unfortunately, there is no consolidated bibliography listing the sources consulted. The book has an extensive and useful index that facilitates consulting it about particular issues or missions.
Since the United States first considered participating in peacekeeping operations, there has been a vigorous debate about the appropriateness of its military participating in constabulary activities. The view that such missions would dull the fighting skills of the troops deployed in them and that constabulary functions are not a proper role for U.S. troops has dominated this debate. Where Is the Lone Ranger? provides a corrective reality check to this view by demonstrating the need for constabulary functions in the design of postconflict stability operations. It goes a long way toward establishing the point that mission effectiveness and force protection will be enhanced by designing stability operations that include from the outset constabulary forces and the necessary elements for the rule of law. Some who demur from this view will see Perito's relative lack of engagement with the literature on the negative effects of peace-mission participation on war-fighting skills as a failing. But his careful scholarship and practical analyses go a long way toward showing how that worry is itself a dangerous distraction rather than a core concern in the context of postconflict operations.
Several other books address the topic of the role of police and judiciary in postconflict operations, all of which are cited by Perito. Where Is the Lone Ranger? is unique in drawing together careful analysis and practical experience into a coherent framework for thinking about postconflict stabilization operations. As such, it will be of interest to students and scholars interested in peace operations. For those concerned about the Middle East, where the United States seems sure to be involved in further postconflict stability operations, this book will be of great interest. Indeed, this book is essential reading for anyone interested in improving postconflict interventions.