Aging populations, the influence of rating agencies, and regulatory developments have recently revealed long-term problems inherent in defined benefit plans. In some cases, these plans have also been augmented with implicit embedded options written by the sponsoring corporation or plan beneficiaries; naturally the more options involved, the higher the complexity related to the structure of ownership in the pension fund. Also, new retirement vehicles are emerging in the pension arena, which are redefining old concepts of risk sharing. For instance the Dutch ‘collective defined contribution systems’ have the appearance of a defined contribution plan for the plan sponsor, but they resemble the characteristics of a defined benefit plan from the beneficiaries' viewpoint. Risk sharing happens among the actives and retirees.
This book explores many of these themes drawing on the author's PhD thesis, focusing on how to contain risks by redesigning the structure of pension plans. Derivatives theory offers insight into the value of embedded options frequently found in pension funds such as traditional defined benefit plans or the collective defined contribution plans. The analysis seeks to uncover the extent to which wealth redistributions are triggered whenever embedded options are existent. For instance, in Chapters 2 and 3, the author discusses a complex corporate defined benefit scheme using an asset-liability framework. In the Dutch context, conditional benefits indexation is common practice in response to a plan's deteriorating financial position. The effect of inflation can only be partially mitigated since benefit enhancements will depend on how much assets have appreciated. If the asset-liability ratio exceeds a certain threshold, full indexation in line with the consumer price index is awarded to the beneficiaries. In the way indexation is discretised, the resulting payoff structure can be thought of as a digital option allowing cuts in indexation with the beneficiaries being the writers of the option. Another feature found in some pensions consists of the mandatory payments that corporations must make to fulfill previously defined funding ratios. That option would be written by the employer (or mandated by law) to cover funding deficits. Yet a different option emerges if a pension fund can default on commitments made previously; here the put is written by plan beneficiaries. The analysis investigates the sensitivity of the option values with regard to changes in the credit quality of the corporate sponsor, and the values are also compared for various funding ratios. The study reveals a large dispersion in risk bearing and the value distribution of funding surpluses based on the structure of equity ownership.
While both chapters try to give conceptual insight into the value and sensitivity of various embedded options involved in the pension plan, the setting, the design, and the assumptions of the underlying asset liability model remain partially unclear. The reader faces results from a black box and has a hard time reconciling the results with his own intuition. The underlying assumption of complete markets is highly questionable in light of the underlying liability structure.
By contrast, the next two chapters consider collective defined contribution schemes where the employer is not a risk taker. What is interesting is that retirees and actives face unclear financial conditions of wealth redistribution and risk sharing. One approach examines a pension scheme that excludes wealth redistribution; it takes fair value option transactions into account and introduces various designs for risk-sharing principles inside the collective defined contribution plan. Two additional chapters discuss the possibility of using derivatives to hedge positions within pension funds. Interest rate and equity derivatives are also taken into consideration.
Overall, the book's contribution is to apply techniques commonly found in risk management and option theory to defined benefit and collective defined contribution plans; in so doing, it provides a guide for new risk management approaches for managers and academics alike. One might argue that the book's audience would be limited to international experts with a particular interest in Dutch-style pensions, since the schemes and indexation options discussed are typical to the Dutch arena. But since the problem of redesigning pension schemes is a substantial task for pension finance for years to come, this book will be useful to readers seeking a discussion of the consequences of risk sharing and implicit wealth redistribution among pension plan stakeholders.
