Opening
We write from the unceded Country of the Eastern Kulin nation as a research collective working at an urban university in Naarm (colonially known as Melbourne, Australia). The place we write from is a highly urbanised environment which is nonetheless full of cultural memories and living stories of connection to this and other places near and far. How did we get here? We come to this writing from many different cultural pathways and historical inheritances of intergenerational experience which can be named as First Peoples, Indigenous, migrant, diasporic, and settler. We also come from many career stages and roles across the university. Our jobs range from sessional and contract roles through to permanent academic, professional, administrative, and leadership positions. These roles lodge us within particular strata of the university’s corporativist living architectures and timescapes. But they do not define who we are, individually or collectively. We organise our authorship alphabetically by last names without preference to the usual hierarchies of first, second, and third. We shift sporadically between “we,” “you,” “I,” and “us,” scrambling the distinctions between voices and persons as any interesting conversation always does. This polyvocal intermixture of perspectives forms the collective voice expressed across the sections of this paper, drawn from individual and collective writing processes over the past year of weekly gatherings. We view this as the inseparability of a living, relational ethics from our emergent and cooperative method of inquiry. Our positions and positionalities are both present and opaquely folded into this mix. As individuals, we remain undefinable in our propensity to deviate from the roles we either make for ourselves or are obligated to play. As a collective, we remain undefinable in our capacity to speak in a plural voice that varies continuously as we carry our many cultures and sub-cultures with us into the university, tainting the work we do with something the university can never capture nor control.
Gathering
We congregate weekly in a two-hour block carved from schedules already spoken for before we even begin to speak. The timelines of our calendars touch in a choreography of landings across actual and digital arrivals, always just in and out of time, and so it never matters if we come late or leave early. Our first space is a glass walled conference room similarly carved from the runaway train of continuous urban redevelopment. This situates us quite literally within the locus of state, municipal, corporate, and university vectors of capital which are already transforming this part of Naarm’s central business district into a flagship knowledge and innovation precinct. We incubate the culturally regenerative university (CRU) amongst a writhing nest of other startup bids for the future of the city, each trying to get an edge on the next wave of capital investment. Suspended in our glass box, we ramble around living concepts that give voice to cultural regeneration as an inherent way of being in the world, as we watch the furniture being lifted out of the room to make way for the next new thing. Our ramblings follow no prepared notes but flow from our lived understandings, experiences and views about what a CRU could look like and feel like. As a continuous elaboration of a relational ethics and method, our organic conversations are recorded regularly with new builds and retrofits being constructed around us as we speak. In some video recordings we even see the furniture being removed in the background. We scramble to find a new space to gather as we are evicted from the glass box that has held our collective thoughts and timings. What becomes available is a new glass box, this time adjacent to the library, which turns out to have no heating in winter. We shift again to a warm, cloistered space in the Office of Indigenous Education, Research and Engagement, located in the old chancellery on the far edge of the urban campus. The paradox of this migration is not lost on us. We nestle and nourish the CRU in the folds of the paradox that curves back on its own infinite horizon.
How to invoke the CRU with humility and grace in an urban university context that has lived its own histories and already decided what its future will be? How can we turn living concepts of the CRU into re-oriented purposes and directions for action? In some ways it helps being in a glass box in the middle of a city where the ruination and redundancy of settler colonial and capitalist cultures are most palpably smelt. The smell of decay masquerading as renewal is inescapable. But what comes to matter is how the smell provokes a shared sense of urgency and obligation to turn our living concepts into actions that operate critically on both the material and discursive infrastructures of the university. In working incrementally towards the reconnection of language to place, land, and Country, we see the translation of concepts into action as not just about doing, but also about slowing down, listening, watching, and expressing aspects of a problem and a possibility space specific to where we live and work. This is perhaps where something like a pedagogy or a method begins to crystallise: in the slow time when the urgencies of life call to those who gather here in ways that are irreducible to any universal cause or explanation.
The very act of slowing concepts down – so as to interrogate and reroute their trajectories – within this accelerated timescape of already made decisions about the university’s futures, is in itself a political act with potentially significant consequences. Slowing down helps reveal how concepts have their own ways of inhabiting places, and can play a range of different roles in how the stories and memories of a place are shared and understood. Slowing down makes time for language to settle back down into the ground conditions which fertilise its capacities to matter here, now, for those who gather. By working to reconnect concepts to Country and place in specific contexts, we move from a definitional engagement with language towards a more material, vital, relational and situated engagement with what concepts can actually do. For example: what does the translation of concepts and stories of Country look like in an urban setting? This city has story and memory, including the living stories of Aboriginal politics and activism in Naarm, ongoing community and political organisation which have led to processes of Treaty (First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria, 2025), truth-telling through the Yoorrook Justice Commission (2025), and self-determined revitalisations of linguistic, educational, cultural, historical, creative, and community infrastructures (Couzens & Darroch, Reference Couzens, Darroch, Kleinert and Koch2012; Couzens et al., Reference Couzens, Gaby, Stebbins and Allan2020). Urbanism is not, by default, a barrier to overcome but can actually amplify these living stories of cultural regeneration led by First Peoples in and beyond Naarm (Nicholson, Reference Nicholson2018). Songlines also invite stories from different Country to become connected with one another (Country et al., Reference Country, Burarrwanga, Ganambarr, Ganambarr-Stubbs, Ganambarr, Maymuru and Daley2022), weaving with local stories that gather, spiral, and eddy in the urbanised place where we live and workFootnote 1 and where metric time as a scarce commodity is hardly enough for all the functions we are expected to serve.
Rambling in stolen time!
Within the context of time and its scarcities, we find ourselves gathering again each week in the glass walled room to slow down our concepts and practice an art of “undercommons study” (Harney & Moten, Reference Harney and Moten2013). Study in the undercommons of the university is an improvised kind of thing. It resists the call to order of “teaching and learning” and the incessant empire-building of “research,” “impact,” and “engagement” which reduces the informality of collective thought down to “a focal point on the administrative agenda” (Rousell & Chan, Reference Rousell and Chan2022, p. 704). Because who really teaches, learns, researches, and engages anything within the calculative model that orders and governs our time? Instead, we follow Harney and Moten’s proposition for deformalised study in the undercommons, “a call to dis-order…or wildness [that] shows up in many places: in jazz, in improvisation, in noise” (Halberstam, Reference Halberstam, Harney and Moten2013, p. 7). All we really want to do is talk and walk and ramble around together in place and on Country. Moten (Reference Moten2018) names this kind of study “a constant improvisational assault on the understanding that was sent to regulate it, as anti-administrative, ante-executive action” (p. 163).
Over the past year we have recorded what emerges organically from our free and wild ramblings of undercommons study. As a counter-archive of what matters and who speaks to and for the university, the recordings witness our collective thought process shifting from the question of “what is the culturally regenerative university?” to the questions of who?, where?, when?, and how? Rather than seeking definitional clarity or consensus, we have committed to holding a durational interval of time open as an invitation for the CRU to find its way in. This is an oblique commitment to a means without ends, the summoning of a precursive leap into becoming the who?, where?, when?, and how? of the very changes the university must undergo. What happens when we refuse the command to define, and pour that time back into the tending of relationships?
One simple thing that keeps happening is we keep coming back. Even though we haven’t defined an idea, outcome, or objective of this research we keep coming back. In coming back, we submit to an ethics of not knowing what will be discussed or actioned at each juncture. We keep coming back and we keep stealing time from the university which is already located on stolen lands. Because don’t you know that time undefined is time spent without return on the university’s investment that is us? And so we pour ourselves into a debt we cherish, and the ethics of a gift we collectively practice as a method of relational inquiry and accountability. We study together in ways that undermine our positions and positionalities as defined by the university’s ledgers and workload models, just so we can have a little more time together to work on the wickedest problems the university faces.
Remember the morning we read passages out loud from The Undercommons? We stumbled and rambled over these words in all-capital bold letters:
THE ONLY POSSIBLE RELATIONSHIP TO THE UNIVERSITY TODAY IS A CRIMINAL ONE. (Harney & Moten, Reference Harney and Moten2013, p. 25)
The criminality of our collective study commences continuously from a vernacular politics which acknowledges that we must all become criminal just to make it through a day under the capitalist-colonial regime. The land is already stolen. We steal it back in time. Our debt follows Country’s curve of relation to infinity. It’s a debt we breathe and never stop owing. We smuggle our regenerative cultures into the university and let our conversations ramble around in stolen time. We explore such ramblings in the following sections which feature fragments of our relational approach to talking, listening and writing. The fragments are written independently by different members of the collective, left unresolved and unmerged by design: not a singular engagement with the concept, but several, sitting alongside one another as they do in our weekly conversations. The fragmentation of our relational whole(ness) functions as concept work, collective inquiry, ethics, and analytic practice. We begin the fragmentary ramblings with our polyvocal expressions of culture.
Culture as polyvocal expression
Cultural with respect to the pursuit of a CRU may be thought of as a combination of values (what is important?), actions (what do we do?) thoughts (what and who do we think about?) and senses (what do we feel?). Universities as sites of knowledge production, dissemination and transferral to students face the challenge of perceiving such activity as regenerative. The momentum is forward albeit contained within the norms and accepted canon of the academy’s disciplines. This creates a kind of inertia. Cultural in the context of CRU requires members of the university to be intentionally contemplative of other knowledge traditions and ways of being in the world as having equivalency and agency. Cultural then refers to values, actions, thoughts and senses grounded in self-reflection whilst appreciating the contributions of peoples and non-human actors which have been traditionally discounted and or extracted within universities. Cultural is how we articulate ourselves in relationship to places, peoples, animals, environments and enact care.
* * *
For me, the “cultural” in CRU is not something absent, damaged, or in need of repair. First Nations culture continues – held in Country, in language, in practice, and in the authority of our Elders and Knowledge Holders. What “cultural” signals is the recognition of sovereign knowledge systems that exist in their own right, with their own governance, Law, and protocols. It is not about inclusion, but about repositioning the university in relation to what already endures. As Aunty Dr Lilla Watson reminds us, “If you are here to help me, your time is misplaced. But if you are here because your freedom is bound up with mine, then we must work together.” This positions relational accountability – not benevolence – as the ground for engagement.
* * *
Raymond Williams (Reference Williams1976), one of the founders of Anglo communication studies, has described “culture” as one of the most complex words in the English language (p. 76). It derives from many tributaries of meaning that do not simply narrow to contexts where it is said Indigenous peoples “have” culture(s) and/or “do” cultural practices, whereas non-Indigenous peoples haven’t and don’t. It seems that our project’s use of “culture, ”and its adverbial cognate, “culturally,” are working as either a euphemism or a placeholder term for “Australian Indigenous.” In this way, it feels analogous to many uses of, or handling of, the word “race” – that Indigenous, Black and Brown peoples “have” a race, but those who are not identified as such, do not. Critical Race Studies illuminates the blind-spot from which the category of “race” has conventionally been named and seen (see for example, Moreton-Robinson, Reference Moreton-Robinson2015, p. xviii). Might the use of “culture” and “culturally” be making the same move: “culturally” being used as the placeholder word for the knowledges, practices and protocols of Indigenous people(s) that will regenerate the university/ies? What might be gained by thinking the references or usages of the words “culture/culturally” in across the university more widely? What might be gained by naming the CRU project for what it is: regenerating universities – that is, reviving, reimagining, refreshing, renewing these places – from the knowledges, practices and protocols of Indigenous people?
* * *
For me, culture is being, culture is belonging, culture reveals what we can become. Culture is deeply woven into pasts, people and place. Culture is a historically informed representations of human life and livelihood over time. It evolves through historical experiences: movement of people, trade, revolutions and interactions between and among civilisations. Each historical period leaves layers that shape the next. Culture is the fabric that shapes what institutions are, what they stand for, and how they are seen from the outside. In the context of the CRU project, cultural regeneration appears to be generally understood as a relational process of fore-fronting Indigenous knowledges into the living fabric of institutional life. It requires relational, place-based practice embedded in ongoing accountability to Indigenous communities (Styres, Reference Styres, Smith, Tuck and Yang2018). It invites institutions to slow down and prioritise deep listening. Cultural regeneration is generative as it produces new forms of knowing at the intersection of Indigenous and Western epistemologies which can offer universities a future that is ecologically, historically, culturally and ethically more resilient (Whyte, Reference Whyte2020). The reality of uncommon, ununiform human and institutional pasts and the diverse ways in which they are experienced and interpreted present both benefits and challenges for developing culturally regenerative universities. Culturally regenerative universities draw from diverse and complex pasts to determine and reshape responsive and respectful approaches to contemporary challenges and problems. This Sankofa view of looking back to look forward suggests that the past is not dead but is living and valuable foundation for responsible and responsive action. Regenerative histories within the context of culturally regenerative universities privileges the primacy of useable and reusable past in the formation of current and future-focused culturally driven institutions and communities (Boadu et al., Reference Boadu, Essiaw and Ciaffaglione2026).
* * *
Cultural regeneration, for us, isn’t restoration, it’s not about returning culture to some prior state of health. It’s closer to what happens when a system finds new capacity through its entanglements with what surrounds it. Culture regenerates when communities develop richer, more reciprocal relationships with the data, materials, infrastructures, and more-than-human actors that constitute their world. It’s always partially speculative, always in process, never declared complete.
What I”ve learned is that exclusion is almost always the default. That participation is necessary but not sufficient, that communities need not just voice but authorship over the categories that shape what counts. And that the hardest thing to regenerate isn’t a practice or a place but a sense of collective agency.
* * *
I am not sure that the university can engage with Indigenous worlds and knowledges respectfully. It may be impossible. But trying is necessary and the co-operative inquiry project is doing this.
Differential encounters
Kombu-merri and Waka Waka social theorist, Mary Graham, has written about the values and principles that undergird Aboriginal knowledges, practices and protocols in the Australian settler colony in ways that neither essentialise nor binarise Indigenous and settler worldviews. More so, she describes these values and principles in and through the encounter between, the coming together of, Indigenous and settler worldviews. She understands them as encounters of fundamental difference that must be made when the land on which they occur is a shared one, albeit not evenly shared. Graham’s ideas about fundamentally different worldviews encountering each other on a shared space enable the possibility for thinking how settler dominated spaces like universities might rethink, review, revise and reimagine their purposeful activities in and through these undergirding principles of reflectiveness, purposiveness, reciprocity and obligation. Taken together, these organising principles name a “custodial ethic” of and for Country (Graham, Reference Graham2008, p. 183). These principles are grounded in the place where the activity occurs and are thus place-based – emergent from the location of their happening and focus (Wooltorton et al., Reference Wooltorton, Stephenson, Ardzejewska and Collard2025). These principles do not essentialise an Aboriginal worldview nor do they demonise a settler worldview so they can avoid the risk of extractive possessiveness (Moreton-Robinson, Reference Moreton-Robinson2015). Rather they are articulated as organising principles for situated action and decision-making (Graham, Reference Graham2023, p. 11). How might we transpose these organising principles for action and decision to the place of the university and its myriad kinds of actions and decisions that make it the place that it is? How might we think of a “custodial ethic” for the university as the becoming of a shared place – in Graham’s words, an “Australia Becoming” – that would necessarily be a becoming otherwise than what and where we are today? In this sense, Graham is describing a form rather than a content of place-based knowledge actions and decisions that might be useful for us in our handling of “culture” and “culturally” in the CRU project.
While the university consists of a multiplicity of projects, there are certain widely held norms that are intrinsic to our research and education culture. Performance is measured by ideas of “discovery” and “originality.”Footnote 2 These order words are colonial norms dissociated from place (Country), from the very possibility of relations of respect between peoples and between worlds. They come from the world of Eurocentered modernity/coloniality. They are expressions of what Aileen Moreton-Robinson (Reference Moreton-Robinson2015) calls a logic of patriarchal white possessiveness which constitutes a regime of appropriation. The measures of “discovery” and “originality” are pervasively deployed and wielded in university rhetorics, funding body rhetorics, scholarly journals and publishers.
To change the university into an institution that engages respectfully with the wisdom of Indigenous knowledges requires giving up colonial norms to find different ways to make knowledge and learn ways of listening to Indigenous worlds and peoples (Wooltorton, Reference Wooltorton2025). It means listening to and following foundational teachings: “Care for Country and Country will care for you” (Bill Neidjie). This is a teaching of regeneration that involves making and participating, that involves generations and twines past and future into the living present.
“Cultural regeneration” means working to dismantle the competitive, “universalist” (Eurocentric) model of research and teaching to make different practices and partnerships. This involves an ongoing questioning of what we mean by education and research. It requires thinking about the immense violence of past and present extractive practices in research and “resource” extraction – how to acknowledge this and find different ways of doing (Tuhiwai-Smith Reference Smith2021, xii). Work with Indigenous knowledges must be done in good ongoing relationship with Indigenous knowledge holders as the final authorities and guardians of their Countries, their worlds of sense. Inculcating this culture is central to what the CRU project seeks to regenerate. But what does regeneration mean? To this question, we ramble on and on.
Regenerate what?
If our purpose is to regenerate our universities, we land first on the meanings we ascribe to “regenerate.” What we do know is that we want change. The term sits within a lexicon of other words for change: a bucket of possible ways of thinking how the circumstances, routines, objectives, and ways of working to achieve them need to be different – to change, or be changed – due to the consequences piling up around the current way of universities.
* * *
Regeneration is intrinsic to life on Earth. The concept of regeneration applied to universities is action seeking to make this fact more visible. This action is cognisant of multiversal knowings of the world and replaces the capitalised goal of “more” with kindness, care and sharing based on the understanding there is “enough.” For universities to participate in a culturally regenerative process and agenda their members must acknowledge institutional, disciplinary and professional status as an exercise of power. The accepted functions of universities will require revision as the obstacles to sharing are diminished. The CRU will be responsible for care of places, peoples, animals and environments, and by doing, show other institutions and organisations how to be in good relationships.
* * *
Like a fertile ecosystem that feeds and nurtures itself in a continuum of circular, regenerative re-creation, CRU then, is not regenerating First Nations culture. Rather, it is concerned with regenerating the conditions through which our sovereign cultural systems can exercise full authority. This includes the reassertion of First Nations governance, the strengthening of language and intergenerational transmission, and the recognition and creation of our own institutions – such as community-controlled language centres, cultural knowledge hubs, keeping places, on-Country learning sites, sovereign research collectives, and First Nations-led universities and academies grounded in Law and Country. Regeneration here is nation-building: restoring the social, cultural, and institutional infrastructures that enable our autonomy and continuity as First Peoples.
Extending the concept of a regenerative ecosystem, and the inclusion and positioning of First Nations knowledges, the university could be a place where the multiversity of knowledge systems are recognised, included and valued. Not a model, but a negotiated, ethical practice in a place and space, that supports flourishing through a sovereign self-determined ethos and practice free of the pervasive colonial paradigm.
* * *
The everyday meaning of regenerate suggests restoring or renewing something that once existed, yet universities were not built from Indigenous cultures, nor were they built for them. For me then, cultural regeneration is not about restoring something that has been lost, but about creating and sustaining conditions that have never truly existed within these institutions: conditions where belonging does not require leaving your values, identities or ways of knowing at the door; where we recognise that not everyone arrives with the same access, opportunities or motivators; and where those realities are designed for rather than treated as exceptions or afterthoughts.
Cultural regeneration is not a return to what was, but a transformation of what counts as legitimate knowing, grounded in genuine relationships of care and respect, in spaces that are thoughtful, reflexive, and responsive. In doing so, the university shifts from being the sole authority on knowledge to becoming a learner itself, through many ways of witnessing, listening, knowing and relating.
From my experience, though, the question still remains: what does it actually take for the institution to take this seriously?
* * *
The word “regeneration” suggests that what comes always comes from a place, a situation and interaction between subjects in which power relations are always in play but may do some surprising things. Collaboration and co-operation are not free from relations of power; there is no outside of power.
Regeneration is not linear progress and a metrics of chronos; to me regeneration suggests another sense of time. Regeneration is making that draws on and gives back to places, peoples and beings participating in making. It resonates for me with the teaching of Gagadju elder Bill Neidjie that all dwellers on earth are obliged to care for Country and that the law of Country “never changes” (Neidjie, Reference Neidjie1989, 2–3, 19, 35–36). In regeneration I also hear the rhythmic refrain “Country time every day” from Alexis Wright’s (Reference Wright2018) “Hey Ancestor!”. Wright’s poem, first published on the “old white fella day” 26th January 2018, teaches of connection to Country, every day, from time immemorial that unfolds a world irreducible to the stolen time of the colony.
* * *
Reproducing what already exists crashes into an understandable politics of disillusionment. What already exists – as multiple and accelerating inequalities, decaying infrastructure, extractive platform economies, species extinctions, strained biosphere, contracted selves, thinned social relations, captured attention – is not “down to” universities: but neither are universities above or apart from the last half century of shaping populations, their social relations, and the conditions they inhabit.
So, what is it that we are wanting to regenerate? Is this giving renewed life to what universities have been in a better past? Or, if we need to avoid nostalgia for productive institutions that were beset with elitism, exclusionary epistemologies, is it reorienting that is wanted; reorienting the direction and purpose of universities? This purpose could be pedagogy, the cultural techniques and knowledges forming what it is to be human at this time; to redress the displacement of purpose over recent decades, as universities have moved to hybrid enterprises, businesses with surviving but tenuous connections to public, civic objectives and ethos.
This redress might involve a rewilding of pedagogy and learning that enables social relations and person formation not limited to producing what already exists, and not “the university” but spaces for collective sense-making, familiarised with many knowledge systems, always situated in the Land within which this meeting and sense-making takes place and thus in touch and governed by Indigenous knowledge. This is in tune with our conversation-sparked formulations captured above: sense-making that is intentionally contemplative of pluriversal knowledge traditions, building from a multiversity of knowledge systems, informed above all by Lilla Watson’s reminder that because your freedom is bound up with mine, then we must work together. This pedagogy could be signalled as a planetary pedagogy infused by and rhyming with Indigenous knowledge systems and wisdom (Daley et al., Reference Daley, Greenfield, Hussey-Smith, Lee, Lester, Magner, Rousell, Speed, Stead, Steele and Thomas2026). None of these calls to rethinking and regenerating the pedagogies living in universities are to scold – unproductive: to rewind to an innocent beginning – a-historical fantasy: or to indulge in the hedonism of good ideas – egoistic. Neither are they made thinking it sufficient to acknowledge the context of working on Indigenous land; nor of taking from Indigenous knowledge to remake without permission and collaboration. Find ways to act and make sense together, in these needed civic-public-communing places where people and social relations are continuously formed, but overdue for regenerating their orientation. To regenerate is also to attend to the forces through which place-based orientations are made. Among the concepts that have helped us think with this task, actionism has remained a productive provocation.
Actionism
The concept of “actionism” was introduced by Vicki Couzens in one of our first gatherings and has continued to resonate and agitate as a touch point for our work. Actionism calls us to recognise the vital materiality of language, and with this recognition we also begin to see that concepts are living things that have very real effects in place and on Country. What is the university other than a place-based rematerialisation of language in both conceptual and physical form? We are languaging the university into being with each breath, and hence there is no Archimedean point outside the university from which to critique it, because it is we ourselves who both form and are formed by its languaging. Actionism helps us see that our task is not to other ourselves from the university, but rather to connect the language which authorises and empowers the university back to the unceded Country and place in which we are collectively situated. In connecting language back to Country and place, we begin to see that our relationship with the university is immanent rather than transcendent. We begin to see how divergent and contested histories are alive in the present, their fragments connected by an archipelagic bridge to the pluriverse as a crossroads between worlds (Rousell et al., Reference Rousell, Boadu, Hussey-Smith, Kelly, Mayes, Moss and McCandless2026). By actioning the nexus where language meets Country and place, we transform the university and ourselves from the inside out.
* * *
Whilst we consider and theorise beyond discipline boundaries, it is valuable to witness the variety of thinking and questioning shaped by individual preferences on how to think about the world and by extension the use of discipline language. It is a conversation of transdisciplinarity occurring in real time as concepts and terminology are shared, unpacked, reshaped and reshared.
* * *
Coming into the group I believed it would be a way of joining with others interested in acknowledging the problem(s) that the sector, and thus our university, faces in terms of its social licence: to be a place that is open and receptive to a wide range of peoples and ideas; to make the institution more porous and flexuous in its knowledge-production and knowledge-translation roles regarding global challenges (climate breakdown, Indigenous-settler relations, automation, wealth inequality, among others). Perhaps more so, I imagined that the group would focus on how to regenerate (renew, reimagine, revision, revise) the almost pervasive feature of university “culture.” For example, the automation of teaching (and therefore, of learning) is now of a level that deadens rather than enlivens in-person education; surely contributing to a downturn among younger people of the value of undertaking a degree at all; and surely contributing to the widespread alienation from learning and socialising at the university by those who do undertake one. The process of writing an article with others, variously six to sixteen others – from across different parts of our university within a group that has affiliations with five other institutions through a methodology of knowledge building and sharing called “co-operative inquiry” – has reminded me of the care needed with terminology.
These fragments function as concept work, collective inquiry, ethics, and analytic practice. Their strength lies in their refusal to resolve into a single argument. The fragments sustain productive tension between perspectives and allow concepts such as culture, regeneration and sovereignty within the context of a university to remain contested, situated in place, and emergent through relational practice. The fragments constitute inquiry as ongoing and generative; voices are intentionally left unresolved; disagreements are productive rather than problematic; and knowledge is situated rather than universal. Together, they demonstrate that knowledge about culturally regenerative universities may require languaging that is itself regenerative, relational and polyvocal.
Conclusion: reconnecting concepts and language to country and place
How do we value minor improvisations and flourishings of cultural regeneration rather than grand, universal solutions? We started with wholly improvised conversations and, over the past year of meeting weekly as a research collective, we have gradually crafted these into an open set of practices which might be called pedagogies or methods. But we might also just call them ways of actioning living concepts which invoke the CRU by working to rematerialise the connections of language to Country and place. These ways of working are now regularly facilitated by different members of the collective in our weekly sessions. We conclude with a brief description of our current practice as a research collective, and an invitation to join the conversation:
Improvisation and the video archives
Our conversations are improvised and recorded each week. In the first four months these conversations were wholly improvised and much of our interaction remains improvised. The recordings of our sessions and our memories of past exchanges become an archive (living archive?) that nourish ongoing discussion and activity. Over the past four months we have built up a significant archive of recordings where many different voices and concepts are given expression from across many different cultures and areas of the university. We plan to edit and curate the video archive which represents our different expressions of concepts and language into short vignettes which give shape to the CRU we are calling into being. With permission from the original contributors, the vignettes can then be taken into a range of different contexts as transformative expressions of actionism, including in courses, staff meetings, research workshops, and community spaces to integrate the concepts and language into place-based practice on Country. We have started to incorporate engagement with our video archive into some of our practice, including the writing of this article.
Polyvocal concept writing
As concepts and diverse expressions of languaging come up in our improvised conversations, we add them to a shared document where each of us contribute to polyvocal concept writing. Each of us writes in a different colour so that our contributions can converse and respond to one another rather than assimilate into a single voice. The aim of this practice is not to define the concepts, but rather to connect concepts back to Country and place through living examples of how they are playing out in different ways across the university and also in local communities. By seeing how concepts are playing out in our teaching, research, and engagement spaces, we also begin to see how concepts can be “bent” toward culturally regenerative ways of being, knowing, and doing. This practice builds on a tradition of keyword projects (Braidotti & Hlavajova, Reference Braidotti and Hlavajova2018; Theodore et al., Reference Theodore, Jazeel, Kent, McKittrick, Jazeel., Kent., McKittrick., Theodore., Chari., Chatterton., Gidwani., Heynen., Larner., Peck., Pickerill., Werner. and Wright2019; Williams, Reference Williams1976), but offers a twist on previous approaches through its adherence to place-based and culturally responsive ways of languaging concepts as plural, living entities.
Tabling of permissions
This practice entails the assembly and ongoing updating of a living document which lists all the entries in the video archive and polyvocal concept writing. For each entry, specific permissions for re-use from the original speaker and writer are recorded and evidenced. This includes permissions for others in the collective to share the videos and concept under specific circumstances (such as teaching or public presentations), in specific places (such as inside or outside the university), and with specific instructions and caveats specified by the original speaker and writer (such as acknowledgements and citations). For example, we have facilitated permissions to share videos with different groups at different times, such as at CRU consortium online gatherings, internal academic staff meetings, and at keynote workshops for international conferences like the American Educational Research Association. In each case, the context and purpose of the sharing is explained and discussed in ways that value and respect the relational knowledges being shared. While this practice might be viewed as merely administrative at first glance, we propose that the minutiae of conducting ethically rigorous work with systematic integrity, diligence, and dedication is integral to bringing the CRU into being. Through this practice, we are recoding the ways that the university’s administrative structures value and respect the relationship of language to Country and place.
Making a day
This practice asks you to write, draw, or storyboard a day in the life of your institutional location. What does it take to “make a day” in your university context? What thresholds do you need to cross in order to “pass”? Where do you find places of refuge for collective study and rambling? When do you steal your time from? Where do you see opportunities for actionism and cultural regeneration in your context? By critically considering and creatively responding to these sorts of questions, we can begin to see how our days can be made otherwise through living concepts of the CRU.
Institutional weather mapping
This practice involves the creation of weather maps which chart the fluctuations of political atmospheres in and through our every day institutional contexts. This practice emerged when several of us went to an international conference to offer an invited workshop on “building relational communities of solidarity.” We realised that relational solidarities need to be aware of the atmospheric pressures of political movements that strive to order them apart. This includes attending to the protean, racialising heuristics of the university as akin to weather systems (Parisi & Dixon-Román, Reference Parisi, Dixon-Román, Mörtenböck and Mooshammer2020; Rosiek, Reference Rosiek2019; Sharpe, Reference Sharpe2016), producing what Simmons (Reference Simmons2017) calls “settler atmospherics” that normalise the white logistics of the colonial-capitalistic university. Institutional weather mapping asks you to draw how these political pressure systems are moving and shifting within your university contexts and your own work. How do these prevailing weather conditions influence and impact what it takes to make a day? Where are the micropolitical possibilities for actionism and cultural regeneration? How and when do you steal time to nourish your relationships with First Peoples and Country as First Teacher? At what point do you need to take refuge, go rogue, become criminal?
In closing, we conceive the reconnecting of language and concepts to place and Country as a relational, place-responsive practice that fosters cultural regeneration in a university. Through our improvisational dialogue, polyvocal writing, ethical protocols of permission and institutional weather mapping practices, the collective demonstrates how concepts become living entities that gain meaning through their connections to Country, community and lived experience. In doing so, we generate culturally regenerative ways of being, knowing and doing that create spaces for collective reflection, actionism and transformation. Our collective work aims to contribute toward a CRU in which language, concepts and knowledge are continually renewed through their grounding in place, ethical relations and continuing dialogue with Country.
Acknowledgements
RMIT University acknowledges the people of the Woi wurrung and Boon wurrung language groups of the eastern Kulin Nation on whose unceded lands we conduct the business of the University. RMIT respectfully acknowledges their Ancestors and Elders, past and present. RMIT also acknowledges the Traditional Custodians and their Ancestors of the lands and waterways across Australia where we conduct our business.
Financial support
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Ethical statement
This article was guided by RMIT human ethics registered under the standing ethics approval from Notre Dame Australia: HREC Reference Number: 2025-009.
Author Biographies
Alinta Jade Andrews is a Pairrebeenne/Trawlwoolway woman with ancestral ties to Tebrakuna Country, north-east Trouwerner. She is a Senior Learning and Teaching Specialist in the College of Design and Social context.
Gideon Boadu is a Senior Lecturer in Curriculum and Pedagogy at RMIT University. His research focuses on history curricula, public histories, history education, and digital histories.
Vicki Couzens is a Keerray Woorroong citizen of the greater Maar nation. Vicki is Lead of Yoonggama, the First Nations Transdisciplinary Research Cohort. She is an Associate Professor in the School of Media and Communication, RMIT University. Her research advances revitalisation of Maar languages and community creative cultural expression praxis, through Indigenous methodologies grounded in relationality, yarning, and land-based learning.
Linda Daley is an Associate Professor of Literary Studies at RMIT University whose teaching and research focuses on the interrelations of ethics, politics and aesthetics and particularly from feminist, anti-colonial and planetary perspectives.
Rebecca Hill is an Associate Professor in the School of Media and Communication, RMIT University. She conducts research on philosophies of place and time in continental philosophy, feminist theory, decolonial theory and critical Indigenous studies.
Cathy Greenfield is Associate Professor of Communication, in the School of Media & Communication, RMIT University. Her research deals with the role of media in the government of populations, across a range of topics such as populism, financialisation, ecological sustainability, and political economic literacy.
Gabrielle Murray is the Principal Advisor Academic for the Office of Indigenous Education, Research and Engagement at RMIT University.
David Rousell is Associate Professor of Education for Regenerative Futures at RMIT University. He teaches and researches in the areas of climate justice, art and design, ecological philosophy, and education futures.
Chris Speed is Professor of Design for Regenerative Futures at RMIT, Melbourne, Australia, where he collaborates with a wide variety of communities and partners to explore how design provides methods to adapt towards becoming a regenerative society.
Wendy Steele is a Professor of Environmental Sustainability and Critical Governance in the Centre for Urban Research and leads the Planetary Civics Inquiry at RMIT.
Gary William Thomas is a Yui and Australian South Sea Islander man from North Queensland. He is the Pro Vice Chancellor, Indigenous Education, Research and Engagement at RMIT University.
