James Madison is the subject of a growing list of books. Long overshadowed by his friend Thomas Jefferson, Madison seems almost as colorless as the black in which he perpetually dressed. He was unfitted for military service; did not marry until he was aged forty-three; and, in contrast to some other Founders, made it a practice “never to deal in public property, land, debts or money, whilst a member of the body whose proceedings might influence these transactions” (16). No one has yet uncovered (or seems likely to uncover) a slave mistress or major scandal, and while Madison did not die rich, he was not bankrupt.
Madison was a career politician who lost only one election in his entire life. The central enigma of his political life is how to reconcile his apparent nationalism at the Constitutional Convention and at the end of his life with his advocacy of states' rights as a Democratic-Republican leader. As he indicates in his subtitle, Professor Broadwater, a history professor at Barton College and the author of a previous book on George Mason, attempts to reconcile these two sides of Madison by emphasizing that he was a Virginia nationalist and by emphasizing his “constructive accommodations to political reality” (xiv). Broadwater also provides evidence that Madison's primary commitment was to civil liberties rather than to a particular mix of state and federal powers, and this commitment might prove to have greater explanatory power.
Broadwater divides his book into seven different chapters. The first centers on Madison's role in the Revolution and the Confederation and his early and continuing advocacy of religious liberty. The next two chapters describe Madison's role at the Constitutional Convention of 1787 and in proposing and ratifying the Bill of Rights. Broadwater then describes Madison's twists and turns as a party leader, as Secretary of State, and as President. A final chapter focusses on Madison's retirement years and on his failure to propose adequate solutions for the issue of slavery.
Broadwater identifies Madison as a pioneer among advocates for religious liberty. Broadwater thinks that “his contribution to the separation of church and state may be less important than what the struggle for freedom of religion meant to him” (9). Specifically, he believes that this interest led Madison “to think more broadly about civil liberties in general.”
Broadwater argues that Madison's primary contributions to the Constitution stemmed more from his ability to learn from state experiences and a belief that national powers could enhance civil liberties (30) than from his “political instincts” (54), which were sometimes not attuned to the interests of small states or to opposition to some of his pet ideas, such as a national veto of state legislation. Madison achieved much of his success by being the best prepared and the best informed (45).
Broadwater includes Madison's work on the Bill of Rights, which he had initially opposed but favored over the possibility of calling a second convention, as part of “five years of remarkably productive statecraft” and accomplishments “rarely equaled in American history” (84). As a party leader, Madison found himself unexpectedly addressing “the problem of minority tyranny within a republican state” (85). Although he had a prior reputation for compromise, Madison hated to admit that his prior advocacy on behalf of national powers was mistaken, and Alexander Hamilton arguably had the better arguments in writings on Washington's proclamation of neutrality.
Madison's marriage to Dolley provided support during his tenure as Secretary of State and as President, but Jefferson's snub of Great Britain's minister Anthony Merry at a state dinner, and Madison's own obdurate belief in the power of embargoes, his Francophile leanings, and his unwillingness to exercise strong executive powers, contributed to the disasters that befell him during the War of 1812. His greatest accomplishment was his “fidelity to republican principles,” which his contemporaries valued over “efficiency” (178).
In retirement, Madison clung tenaciously to the false hope that colonization might solve the problem of slavery. He favored compromise over pure republican principles and continued to pursue what Broadwater describes as “a political golden mean” (210).
The cover of Broadwater's book is graced by a beautiful portrait of Madison by Thomas Sully. Broadwater makes no pretense to presenting a complete account of Madison's life and offers no new interpretation of his subject, but he does a good job of highlighting and filling in various aspects of a worthy life.
