Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T07:51:25.384Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Pinch-off of a surfactant-covered jet

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2020

Hansol Wee
Affiliation:
Davidson School of Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
Brayden W. Wagoner
Affiliation:
Davidson School of Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
Vishrut Garg
Affiliation:
Davidson School of Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
Pritish M. Kamat
Affiliation:
Davidson School of Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
Osman A. Basaran*
Affiliation:
Davidson School of Chemical Engineering, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: obasaran@purdue.edu

Abstract

Surfactants at fluid interfaces not only lower and cause gradients in surface tension but can induce additional surface rheological effects in response to dilatational and shear deformations. Surface tension and surface viscosities are both functions of surfactant concentration. Measurement of surface tension and determination of its effects on interfacial flows are now well established. Measurement of surface viscosities, however, is notoriously difficult. Consequently, quantitative characterization of their effects in interfacial flows has proven challenging. One reason behind this difficulty is that, with most existing methods of measurement, it is often impossible to isolate the effects of surface viscous stresses from those due to Marangoni stresses. Here, a combined asymptotic and numerical analysis is presented of the pinch-off of a surfactant-covered Newtonian liquid jet. Similarity solutions obtained from slender-jet theory and numerical solutions are presented for jets with and without surface rheological effects. Near pinch-off, it is demonstrated that Marangoni stresses become negligible compared to other forces. The rate of jet thinning is shown to be significantly lowered by surface viscous effects. From analysis of the dynamics near the pinch-off singularity, a simple analytical formula is derived for inferring surface viscosities. Three-dimensional, axisymmetric simulations confirm the validity of the asymptotic analyses but also demonstrate that a thinning jet traverses a number of intermediate regimes before eventually entering the final asymptotic regime.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Definition sketch. (a) A liquid jet the surface $\tilde {S}(\tilde {t})$ of which is covered by a monolayer of an insoluble surfactant. To initiate capillary thinning and pinch-off, the surface of a perfectly cylindrical column of radius $R$ is subjected at time $\tilde {t} = 0$ to an axially periodic sinusoidal perturbation of wavelength $\tilde {\lambda } = 2{\rm \pi} / \tilde {k}$. (b) Domain of interest for 3DA or 2-D analysis. Here, the interface is parametrized by arc length $\tilde {s}$. (c) The 1-D domain. In both the 2-D and 1-D analyses, the axial extent of the domain is $0\le z \le \tilde {\lambda }/2 = {\rm \pi}/\tilde {k}$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Transient evolution of minimum jet radius and surfactant concentration at that location and axial length and axial velocity predicted from 1-D simulations. Computed variation with $\tau$ of $h_{min}$ (green square $\square$ symbols), $z' \equiv z_{1.04h_{min}}-z_{min}$ (orange diamond $\diamond$ symbols), $v' \equiv v_{1.04h_{min}}$ (red circle $\circ$ symbols) and $\varGamma _{min} \equiv \varGamma |_{h_{min}}$ (blue triangle $\triangle$ symbols) for a jet of $Pe=\infty$, $\varGamma _m = 0.3$ and $\varGamma _0=0.15$ in the absence of surface rheological effects. The solid black lines that are superimposed on the simulation results for $h_{min}$, $z'$ and $v'$ as $\tau \to 0$ correspond to theoretical scaling results and for which the indicated slopes are the power-law exponents predicted from theory. The pink dotted line, with the indicated slope of one, is Eggers’ solution, $h_{min}=0.0304\tau$, for either a jet with a clean interface (Eggers 1993) or a surfactant-covered jet without surface rheological effects (this paper).

Figure 2

Figure 3.The 1-D simulation results of the computed variation with $\tau$ of (a) $h_{min}$ and (b) $\varGamma _{min}$ for jets of $Pe=\infty$ and $\varGamma _m = 0.3$ in the absence of surface rheological effects that are subjected to different initial conditions. The pink dotted line in (a) is that for which $h_{min}=0.0304\tau$. All simulation data for $h_{min}$ versus $\tau$ eventually collapse onto this line (Eggers’ scaling law) irrespective of the initial conditions. By contrast, simulation data for $\varGamma _{min}$ versus $\tau$ do not collapse onto a single line, which clearly illustrates that the evolution in time of $\varGamma _{min}$ is dependent on initial conditions. Inset to figure 3(b) shows rescaled $\varGamma _{min}$, viz. $\varGamma _{min}^* \equiv \varGamma _{min}/c_0$, where $c_0=\varGamma _0/h_0$. The collapse of the data obtained from simulations with different initial conditions onto one line $\varGamma _{min}^*=0.0304\tau$, which is also denoted by a pink dotted line, makes plain that as $\tau \to 0$, $\varGamma _{min}=(0.0304\varGamma _0/h_0)\tau$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Transient evolution of minimum jet radius and surfactant concentration at that location and axial length and axial velocity predicted from 1-D simulations. Computed variation with $\tau$ of $h_{min}$ (green square $\square$ symbols), $z' \equiv z_{1.04h_{min}}-z_{min}$ (orange diamond $\diamond$ symbols), $v' \equiv v_{1.04h_{min}}$ (red circle $\circ$ symbols) and $\varGamma _{min} \equiv \varGamma |_{h_{min}}$ (blue triangle $\triangle$ symbols ) for a jet of $Pe=\infty$, $\varGamma _m = 0.3$ and $\varGamma _0=0.15$ in the presence of surface rheological effects ($B_o=2/3$). The solid black lines that are superimposed on the simulation results for $\varGamma _{min}$, $z'$ and $v'$ as $\tau \to 0$ correspond to theoretical scaling results and for which the indicated slopes are the power-law exponents predicted from theory. The pink dotted line, with the indicated slope of unity, is Eggers’ solution, $h_{min}=0.0304\tau$, for a jet with a clean interface (Eggers 1993) or a surfactant-covered jet without surface rheological effects (this paper). The black dashed line, also of slope unity, is the plot of the equation given by $h_{min} =0.0304 \tau / (1+{5B_o\varGamma _0}/{3h_0} )$, i.e. (4.21). The inset shows a blow-up or zoomed-in view of both $h_{min}$ and $\varGamma _{min}$ versus $\tau$ and also helps make clear the difference between these two scaling laws.

Figure 4

Figure 5.The 1-D simulation results on the computed variation with $\tau$ of $h_{min}$ for a jet of $Pe=\infty$ and $\varGamma _m = 0.3$ in the presence of surface rheological effects ($B_o \ne 0$) that are subjected to different initial conditions. Unlike the situations in the absence of surface rheological effects, simulations reveal that when surface rheological effects are important the prefactor in the scaling law relating $h_{min}$ and $\tau$ as $\tau \to 0$ is not only a function of $B_o$ but also of the initial conditions ($c_0=\varGamma _0/h_0$). The inset shows the variation of the rescaled minimum jet radius, $h_{min}^* \equiv h_{min}(1+5c_0B_o/3)$, with $\tau$. The collapse shown in the inset of the data obtained from simulations with different initial conditions onto one line $h_{min}^*=0.0304\tau$ (the pink dotted line) clearly reveals that surfactant-covered filaments in the presence of surface rheological effects do indeed thin according to (4.21).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Transient evolution of minimum jet radius and surfactant concentration at that location and axial length and axial velocity predicted from 3DA simulations. (a) Computed variation with $\hat {\tau }$ of $\hat {h}_{min}$ (green square $\square$ symbols), $\hat {z}' \equiv \hat {z}_{1.09\hat {h}_{min}}-\hat {z}_{min}$ (orange diamond $\diamond$ symbols), $\hat {v}' \equiv \hat {v}'_{1.09\hat {h}_{min}}$ (red circle $\circ$ symbols) and $\hat {\varGamma }_{min}$ (blue triangle $\triangle$ symbols) for a jet of $Oh=0.07$, $Pe=1000$, $\beta =0.3$, $\hat {\varGamma }_0=0.55$ and $B_{s0}=0.0143$. (b) Same as (a) except $\hat {\varGamma }_0=0.5$. Insets: zoomed-in views of $\hat {h}_{min}$ and $\hat {\varGamma }_{min}$ versus $\hat {\tau }$ as $\hat {\tau } \to 0$. In both (a,b), the solid black lines that are superimposed on the simulation results for $\hat {\varGamma }_{min}$, $\hat {z}'$ and $\hat {v}'$ as $\tau \to 0$ correspond to theoretical scaling results and for which the indicated slopes are the power-law exponents predicted from theory. Also in both the main parts and the insets of (a,b), Eggers’ solution, $\hat {h}=0.0304\hat {\tau }/Oh$, is denoted by the pink dotted line of slope unity. Similarly, the new scaling law, $\hat {h}=[0.0304/Oh(1+5B_{s0}\hat {c}_0/3\hat {\varGamma }_0)]\hat {\tau }$, where $\hat {c}_0 \equiv \lim _{\hat {\tau } \to 0} \hat {\varGamma }_{min}/\hat {h}_{min}$, is denoted by the dashed black line of slope unity.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Profiles at the incipience of pinch-off of jets with and without surface rheological effects. (a) Zoomed-in views of microthreads at the instant in time when $t=11.413$ for the same jet as in figure 6(a) and for which surface rheological effects are present. (b) Same as (a) except when surface rheological effects are absent or $B_{s0}=0$ at the instant in time when $t=11.357$. It should be noted that the parameter values in this case are identical to those used in figure 2 of the paper by Kamat et al. (2018).

Figure 7

Figure 8.Results obtained from 3DA simulations using a nonlinear constitutive equation for surface viscosity: computed variation with $\hat {\tau }$ of $\hat {h}_{min}$ (green square $\square$ symbols), $\hat {z}' \equiv \hat {z}_{1.09\hat {h}_{min}}-\hat {z}_{min}$ (orange diamond $\diamond$ symbols), $\hat {v}' \equiv \hat {v}'_{1.09\hat {h}_{min}}$ (red circle $\circ$ symbols) and $\hat {\varGamma }_{min}$ (blue triangle $\triangle$ symbols) for a jet of $Oh=0.07$, $Pe=1000$, $\beta =0.3$, $\hat {\varGamma }_0=0.55$ and $B_{s0}=0.0143$. The solid black lines that are superimposed on the simulation results for $\hat {\varGamma }_{min}$, $\hat {z}'$ and $\hat {v}'$ as $\hat {\tau } \to 0$ correspond to theoretical scaling results and for which the indicated slopes are the power-law exponents predicted from theory. Inset: zoomed-in view of $\hat {h}_{min}$ and $\hat {\varGamma }_{min}$ versus $\hat {\tau }$ as $\hat {\tau } \to 0$. Eggers’ solution, $\hat {h}=0.0304\hat {\tau }/Oh$, is denoted by the pink dotted line. The new scaling law, $\hat {h}=[0.0304/Oh(1+5B_{s0}\,f'(0)\hat {c}_0/3)]\hat {\tau }$, where $\hat {c}_0 \equiv \lim _{\hat {\tau } \to 0} \hat {\varGamma }_{min}/\hat {h}_{min}$, is denoted by the dashed black line.

Figure 8

Figure 9.Time evolution of $c(z,t)$ for jets of $Pe=\infty$, $\varGamma _m=0.3$, $\lambda = 8$ and $h_0=0.9$ subjected to different initial conditions on surfactant concentration. (a) Surfactant concentration is initially taken to be proportional to the initial shape profile $h(z,t=0)$, viz. $\varGamma (z,t=0)=c_0h(z,t=0)$. Here, $c_0=0.15$. Because $\textrm {D}c/\textrm {D}t=0$, $c(z,t)$ must be spatially uniform and temporally constant for all time, viz. $c(z,t) \equiv c_0$. Thus profiles of $c(z,t)$ at different times determined from direct numerical simulations collapse onto one flat line, $c=c_0=0.15$, as shown in the figure. (b) The jet is initially uniformly coated with surfactant at concentration $\varGamma _0=0.15$. The different curves show the evolution in time of $c(z,t)$ and highlight the growing size of the axial extent where the profile of $c$ is flat. Inset: variation of the computed value of $c(z=z_{min},t)$ (denoted by diamond $\diamond$ symbols) with $z_{min}$ where $z_{min}$ denotes the axial location where the thread radius is minimum. The green flat line in the inset corresponds to $\varGamma _0/h_0$, which clearly shows $\lim _{\tau \to 0} \varGamma _{min}/h_{min}=\varGamma _0/h_0$. The red arrows in both the main figure and the inset indicate the direction of increasing time.