It is potentially a very healthy, good thing when highly respected members of a profession criticize that profession constructively. And industrial-organizational (I-O) psychology has been rather notable in that respect over the years. In their focal article, Schneider and Pulakos (Reference Schneider and Pulakos2022) continue the tradition by calling attention to the relative paucity of I-O research at the organizational level of analysis—that is, studies in which organization-wide phenomena and differences between organizations are the outcome variables of interest.
Brief historical context
There is a venerable history of constructive kvetching in I-O psychology. Perhaps the first iconoclastic I-O psychologist, who was also a Yiddish scholar, Abraham-Aaron Roback (Reference Roback1917), in the first volume of the Journal of Applied Psychology challenged Munsterberg’s (Reference Munsterberg1913) view that our profession should have no concern for the “ends of commerce and industry” (p. 19)—that is, the values and objectives shaping our work should be determined by the businesses for which we work and are none of our concern. “Surely the applied psychologist must have a broader outlook on life,” Roback replied. Similarly, Arthur Kornhauser (Reference Kornhauser1947) rejected the conception of “industrial psychology as management technique” and observed that “industrial psychology as social science remains a puny infant—if not, indeed, still in embryo” (p. 224, emphasis in original). Ross Stagner (Reference Stagner1981) unhappily conceded that there was “some justification” that “psychologists have been persuaded to use their selection skills to exclude from employment applicants with prounion sympathies” (p. 504), and further documentation has been provided more recently by Mike Zickar (Reference Zickar2001). And the predominant scientist–practitioner (S–P) model has long been criticized as being an inadequate values model for I-O psychology because it is contaminated by economic/corporatist values, and it is deficient because it fails to incorporate the moral perspective of the humanist tradition in psychology (cf. Kimble, Reference Kimble1984) and should be enhanced by a S-P-humanist model (Lefkowitz, Reference Lefkowitz1990, Reference Lefkowitz2008).
More recent challenges
Those criticisms from the earlier days of I-O psychology have to do with the normative values of the profession and its intended role in the wider society. Such views may be expected in the early stages of a profession in reaction to members who are concerned with proving its economic worth—for example, Tiffin (Reference Tiffin1956) was gratified that “industry is now accepting and paying for industrial psychology” (p. 372). In contrast to those normative critiques, the more recent challenges we have posed to ourselves have mostly been technical–methodological or scientific problems or as training or professional “branding” issues.
Here are some recent challenges: (a) I-O psychology has an “identity crisis” because we are not “differentiated from other like disciplines…. We are not perceived as positively as competitors in the market place (Ryan, Reference Ryan2003, p. 21; also Ryan & Ford, Reference Ryan and Ford2010); (b) even though we are experts on organizational justice, we don’t actually do much in order to promote it in organizations (Greenberg, Reference Greenberg2009); (c) I-O psychology lacks an individualistic (person-centric) appreciation of the individual at work (Weiss, & Rupp, Reference Weiss and Rupp2011); (d) despite the fact that a major focus of I-O psychology is on intelligence, we have contributed relatively little to understanding the construct (Scherbaum etal., Reference Scherbaum, Goldstein, Yusko, Ryan and Hanges2012); (e) the research samples studied in I-O psychology are skewed against the inclusion of several marginalized and/or stigmatized groups (Ruggs etal., Reference Ruggs, Law, Cox, Roehling, Wiener, Hebl and Barron2012) and are overrepresented by managers and underrepresented by lower-level employees (Bergman, & Jean, Reference Bergman and Jean2016); and (f) The employability of I-O psychologists could be enhanced by improving our graduate training (Byrne, Reference Byrne, Hayes, McPhail, Hakel, Cortina and McHenry2014).
However, in each of those instances it has been alleged that there is an underlying values issue playing at least a contributory role along with the “technical” problems and proposed solutions (cf. Lefkowitz, Reference Lefkowitz2010, Reference Lefkowitz2009, Reference Lefkowitz2011, Reference Lefkowitz2012, Reference Lefkowitz2013, Reference Lefkowitz2014, respectively). To summarize those arguments briefly, the normative issues consist of various facets of “corporatist values [that] contribute to a distorted view of who we are, what we do, and what we should be doing, as well as to misdiagnosing the consequent adverse manifestations, even when the symptoms are recognized” (Lefkowitz, Reference Lefkowitz2013, p. 46).
The potential normative bias in organizational outcomes
The text of Schneider and Pulakos’s (Reference Schneider and Pulakos2022) essay focuses on “organizational outcomes,” an “organizational frame of reference,” an “organizational mindset and methods,” and so on. However, it seems clear enough both from the title of the piece and from their focus on “financial performance, meeting business objectives, and creating value” (p. X) that “outcomes” refers to traditional economic/business/financial indicators—although the authors also include less traditional outcomes such as company-level customer satisfaction. Therefore, the conceptual and methodological expansion proposed by Schneider and Pulakos would remain enmeshed in the corporatist value system reflecting a managerial bias (Baritz, Reference Baritz1960; Katzell & Austin, Reference Katzell and Austin1992; Kornhauser, Reference Kornhauser1947; Lefkowitz, Reference Lefkowitz2017; Zickar & Gibby, Reference Zickar, Gibby and Koppes2007).
The significance of recognizing the values bias is that it largely determines what we believe we should study and what we deem unimportant (or never even think of). That is, which organizational outcomes are to be included in this suggested expansion of our focus? Schneider and Pulakos (Reference Schneider and Pulakos2022) offer a fruitful approach to an answer: “every individual-level variable can be aggregated to other levels of analysis” (p. X).
However, at the organizational level there are potential outcomes that don’t exist at lower levels, may take a different form, and/or might not be chosen because they don’t directly contribute to the organization’s success as traditionally defined. Consider the following potential organizational outcomes: the company’s economic influence on the local communities in which it operates; its effect on the local labor force and compensation rates; its general “citizenship behavior” in the community; its demonstrable concern for generally unrecognized stakeholders (such as “false rejects”); and fairness/justice aspects of its human resources practices such as compensation, policies regarding alleged harassment, discrimination, bullying, retention policies, and so on.
Will it occur to us to include—that is, aggregate to higher levels of analysis—something like organizational citizenship behavior or organizational justice?
I-O psychology studies as legitimate and important facets of employees’ job performance their organizational citizenship behaviors (OCBs)…. By extension, we cannot ethically ignore the moral qualities and actions of the organizations to which we devote our efforts—in effect, organizations’ citizenship behavior—with respect to the society that legitimizes and supports them…. Just as we study employee perceptions of organizational justice vis-a-vis an organization’s internal human resources activities …, we should also be concerned with the social justice implications of the organization’s external actions, which characterize the probity of its role in society. (Lefkowitz, Reference Lefkowitz2017, p. 2, emphasis added)
Another example illustrates that the recommended organizational-level approach could be implemented in areas and with respect to stakeholders outside the customary concern of most organizations and I-O psychologists:
In evaluating a selection system we ought to consider … its impact on all of those affected. We always have an instrumental concern for increasing the proportion of those selected who are successful on the job (“true positives”) in relation to those hired who are unsuccessful (“false positives”). But we should also be concerned about the proportion of incorrectly rejected applicants who have been denied employment (“false negatives”) because of the imperfect validity of those predictors. (Lefkowitz, & Lowman, Reference Lefkowitz, Lowman, Farr and Tippins2017, p. 579, emphasis added)
In other words, considering organizational-level outcomes would not be merely a methodological and/or theoretical advance; it can open a Pandora’s box of notions that I-O psychology has heretofore scrupulously avoided facing—such as the moral justification of the organizations in/for which we work (Mumby, Reference Mumby2019) and our possible complicity in their excesses (Lefkowitz, Reference Lefkowitz2019). That would be in keeping with a call for I-O psychology to incorporate in its values structure “both scientific/technical competence and societal consequences” (Lefkowitz, Reference Lefkowitz2017, p. 384).
