The Hindu deity Skanda-Kārtikeya, also known as Kumāra, Mahāsena, Murukan, etc., is traced at least to the Mauryan period, and is written into Sanskrit literary and ritual traditions associated with medical, religious, and warrior cults. He appears as a multifaceted and transreligious deity on coinage during the Kuṣāṇa period. Skanda is eventually absorbed into the ever-growing pantheon of Śiva, as his son and leader to his marauding followers (gaṇas). Although remaining a relatively popular, secondary deity into modern times, Skanda's independent cult declined fully by the seventh century CE.
Richard Mann's long-anticipated study of Skanda is a welcome addition to scholarship on premodern Indian religions, South Asian art, social history, and Eurasian numismatics. This is a reworked version of his 2003 McMaster University dissertation written under Phyllis Granoff, and traces of her rigorous discipline and attention to detail are found throughout the volume. It also represents Mann's subsequent fieldwork in India and recent efforts to further substantiate earlier findings.
The study is arranged chronologically. After a brief introduction summarizing the study, chapter 1 examines possible pre-Mauryan evidence. Chapters 2 to 4 consider Epic traditions. Chapters 5 to 7 look at numismatic and other material evidence. Chapter 8 explores medieval textual sources. Chapter 9 treats inscriptional, numismatic, and other material evidence from the Gupta period. The conclusion provides a recap, and the bibliography, index, and plates round out the monograph. Included are forty-three quality black-and-white figures with sixty-three individual photographs—about one-third are previously unpublished—representing a range of sculptural, relief-narrative, and especially numismatic depictions of Skanda.
Bringing material evidence to bear on literary evidence, Mann revisits Skanda's “decline.” He places this development before and during the Gupta era—right when traditional scholarship has argued for Skanda's rise to prominence. In his view, the process of domesticating Skanda into the Brahminical ritual world thus occurred earlier than typically thought, and was integral to his appearance in the Epics. In Mann's interpretation, the Mahābhārata—understood against a backdrop of material evidence—emerges as the key to understanding Skanda's decline as an independent cult figure.
Mann's examination of Epic material is among the most rewarding aspects of the monograph. He considers Skanda's appearance in the Mahābhārata and his synthetic construction out of medical demons (grahas) and subsequent displacement by the military figure Mahāsena, through the hands of Brahminical redactors and theologians. In the case of Śiva, theologians may have sought to elevate a god's status within the emerging Hindu pantheon, but in the case of Skanda, they sought to control and homogenize a figure who had been popular and widespread.
Among the challenges of integrating literary and material evidence, however, is the insertion of literary sources into a strict chronological structure, given the uncertainties in dating the relevant texts and traditions. Indeed, it might have been better to structure the volume along thematic lines, oriented towards the challenge of interweaving literary and material data, so as better to highlight the intersection of disciplines within Mann's introductory and concluding remarks. The discussion of Purāṇic material in chapter 8, for instance, might have been better integrated into the sections dealing with Epic material. As is, Mann's treatment of literary sources suffers from some lack of consistency across different corpora. On the one hand, he maintains a largely unstated but sophisticated assumption about the layering and redactional process of constructing the Epics that is not applied to the Purāṇas. On the other hand, he cites Hans Bakker (p. 179) to justify his skeptical approach to dating the Purāṇas, but does not apply the same level of skepticism to the Epics, despite the relatively late manuscript attestation for nearly all the texts here considered. An integrated section on literary evidence would help iron out such discrepancies.
Given the significance of Mann's topic and findings, it is unfortunate that the introduction and conclusion are sparse; both could have been developed more rigorously to engage specialists across different fields. Additionally, Mann's attention to detail is commendable but sometimes risks seeming pedantic; he overturns every scholarly rock no matter its overall merit. Chapter 1, for instance, discusses Indus Valley seals and their tenuous links to the cult of Skanda; such nonessential material should be relegated to footnotes.
Despite minor shortcomings, Mann's monograph is ultimately convincing, surveying past and current scholarship alongside relevant premodern evidence to offer a revised narrative about the rise, development, and decline of Skanda. Mann, moreover, has done an enviable job of collecting and examining nonliterary sources, including sculptures, relief-carvings, coins, and inscriptions. In particular, Skanda's ambiguous adaptability within shifting sociopolitical and religious contexts (e.g., Aries/Mars; pp. 140–48), comes to life through the material evidence. Mann's study is indispensable for scholarship on the formative history of Hinduism, and it will be an important resource for scholars interested in cross-cultural comparisons and connections across Eurasia.
