For many of us, allergies are a pervasive part of everyday life, colouring our experience of both time and place, marking the cycle of the days and seasons, and determining where we may or may not comfortably visit (I cannot call on friends with cats; my daughter avoids homes with guinea pigs). Despite their ubiquity, however, allergies have hitherto largely escaped the attention of medical historians, whose gaze has tended to focus on more dramatic diseases: major killers and moral scourges, rather than the kinds of aches and pains, rashes and wheezes that we cope with on a daily basis. The almost simultaneous appearance of two excellent if rather different books on allergy is testimony to the way that medical history is now widening its field of vision to include the more quotidian and parochial role of illness and medicine in our lives. But historians of the mundane are still able to address big themes, as these explorations of the history of allergy make clear.
For Mark Jackson, time is of the essence. Specifically, he treats allergy as a window on modernity. Central to his story is an account of changing scientific and clinical understandings of allergy: from 1906, when Clemens von Pirquet first coined the word ‘allergy’ to denote the processes underlying both normal and exaggerated immune reactions; through the mid-twentieth century, when allergies were generally regarded more narrowly as abnormal immune reactions against specific agents; to the end of the millennium, when allergy was reframed in evolutionary terms as a natural bodily response to an increasingly unnatural and hostile environment. Jackson does not cast this as a simple story of scientific progress, however. Rather, in good contextualist fashion, he locates different ideas about allergy in their multiple and changing institutional and social settings, to show how knowledge was both tailored to the demands of local practice and informed by wider cultural assumptions and expectations.
Laboratory research provided one site for the production of such knowledge, but other locales have been just as important, if not more so. In particular, clinicians' encounters with allergy, and their concern not only to understand but to treat it, have been crucial in constituting allergy as an object of knowledge and practice. But the very pervasiveness of allergy means that actors from many other social spheres have also had a stake in understanding and defining it. Not just the professions of science and medicine, but government agencies, charities and, above all, industry have taken an interest in allergy, either because of the burden it places on the economy or because of the profits that can be made from it. By the late twentieth century, allergy had come to represent both a global health problem, threatening the economic vigour of developed and developing countries alike, and a global market, in which multinational pharmaceutical companies grew wealthy on the sales of a growing range of allergy remedies. New institutions of global health surveillance continue to add to our knowledge and representations of allergy, as too do the marketing divisions of industrial corporations.
Moreover, while lay ideas about allergy have drawn heavily on scientific and medical discourses, they have also enjoyed an exuberant life of their own, not least as metaphors for representing relationships between individuals, society and the natural world. These metaphorical meanings have in turn been incorporated into more scientific or clinical thinking about allergy. Most obviously, both scientific and lay representations of allergy exhibit a striking tendency to suppose that allergy is peculiarly a disease of civilization – a supposition that has been repeatedly reinvented as prevailing ideas about the character and problems of civilization have shifted over time. In the 1920s, allergy was attributed to the increasingly sensitive and refined constitution of the upper classes, who were widely believed to suffer far more than their lumpen inferiors; at once a bane and a blessing, allergy was above all a mark of the physical distinction on which social distinctions were held to be founded. During the 1950s and 1960s, more egalitarian psychosomatic interpretations predominated, signifying the stresses and tensions that result from subjugating our animal nature to the demands of civilized life. More recently, concerns about the effects of an increasingly degraded and toxic environment on adaptive but ultimately fragile biological and social organisms have prevailed.
In its chronology, in the spread of institutional and social spaces that it spans, and in the way that it embodies the tendency of modern society to reflect on its own nature, allergy is thus coextensive with modernity. And in Jackson's capable hands it provides a powerful means of illuminating the character of that modernity, with its heterogeneity of social worlds and epistemic cultures linked together by the production and circulation of diverse forms of goods and currency, knowledge and practice. Allergy is implicated in all these forms of interaction, to the extent that it might justly be seen as part of the constitution of modernity itself.
If Jackson's perspective is predominantly temporal, Gregg Mitman is more concerned with place. For Mitman, allergy provides an opportunity to explore how health and illness have been shaped by, and in turn have helped to shape, our environment. His stories are salutary. With the emergence of hay fever as an affliction of the wealthy during the nineteenth century, resorts sprang up in New England and Michigan, and later on the high plains of Arizona and Colorado, where sufferers could find an atmosphere free from pollen and other irritants. These resorts would provide fertile ground for the growth of American environmentalism. In the North and East, preservation of a pollen-free environment provided the incentive to reforest cleared-over land and restore something more like the landscape that had existed before white settlers replaced timber with farms. On the Western plains, by contrast, hay fever colonists were themselves among the agents of environmental degradation, irrigating the desert to plant golf courses and trees that produced the very pollen they had migrated to avoid; only belatedly did a more acute environmentalist mentality gain ground, in reaction against the growth of smelting and other industries which contributed mightily to the irritating qualities of the air.
The interior environment of American homes likewise owed much to their inhabitants' efforts to control their health. From the 1920s, dreams of a totally regulated indoor environment were stimulated by the advent of domestic air conditioning, improved materials and techniques for manufacturing houses and their furnishings, and novel methods of removing or suppressing dust and other allergens. Even as those dreams seemed likely to be fulfilled, however, concerns mounted that hermetically sealed homes could increase exposure to organic chemicals and provide favourable conditions for house dust mites: far from being a haven from allergy, the home could harbour irritants just as noxious as those found out-of-doors.
Mitman deftly uncovers the ironic consequences that have often attended Americans' efforts to tackle the problems of allergy. He also shows how the very construction of allergy as a problem has sometimes masked more fundamental social problems. During the 1960s, for instance, shockingly high rates of asthma among poor urban blacks were commonly attributed not to the circumstances in which the victims were forced to live, but to the same psychopathology as was often invoked to explain racial unrest. Only from the 1980s onwards was asthma reclaimed by activists demanding environmental and economic justice. But efforts to link allergy to environmental and other forms of inequality still face powerful countervailing forces. Not least, the success of the pharmaceutical industry in producing medications that effectively inure individuals to the allergenic influence of the environment has done much to privatize allergy, moving it out of the realm of public policy and into that of consumer choice.
Strikingly, in their concluding reflections, both Jackson and Mitman hark back to the 1960s, and René Dubos's sceptical response to the millennial promise of modern scientific medicine. In keeping with their different historiographical perspectives, however, they pick up on rather different aspects of Dubos's arguments. For Jackson, concerned with time and historicity, Dubos was an anti-utopian prophet, for whom health and disease are inextricably enmeshed in the structures of human existence, and who insisted that we cannot predict what forms that existence will assume in the future. The corollary, for Jackson, is that allergy, so inseparable from the institutions of modernity, may be altered unrecognizably as modernity gives way to futurity. What will replace our present ailments, we cannot say. But it is unlikely that the future will conform either to ‘optimistic bioscientific dreams of future freedom from disease [or] despairing ecological dramatizations of impending environmental disaster’ (p. 218).
For Mitman, concerned primarily with place, Dubos was less a medical historian than a medical ecologist, who championed the same holistic vision of the social and environmental causes of health and illness as runs through Mitman's own account of allergy. Moreover, the message that Mitman takes from Dubos is as much political as medical. For Mitman, allergy as it presently exists is both a consequence of past power relations and a site for continuing contestation, and his recounting of allergy's histories is plainly intended to bolster activist efforts to reclaim allergy as a site of environmental politics. That political purpose leads him into certain historiographical compromises. Compared to Jackson's synthetic analysis of allergy's role in the constitution of an increasingly global modernity, Mitman's perspective tends to the episodic and parochial; despite his inclusive use of the first person plural in his subtitle, he writes principally about America and Americans. And where Jackson sustains a rigorous constructivism, Mitman is prepared to adopt a more pragmatic realism, as for instance when he includes nineteenth-century hay fever among his examples of how allergy shaped America. But what Mitman loses in terms of comprehensiveness and analytical purity, he gains in the exemplary character of his environmentalist parables.
In short, both books are excellent in their different ways. Both are models of historical research, and both are a pleasure to read. And while there is inevitably some overlap in their subject matter, it is far less than one might fear: more a matter of complementarity than of repetition. Read together, they show with startling clarity how an apparently unremarkable malady is woven into the warp and weft of the world we inhabit, and challenge us to see how that world might be remade if we only paid attention to the politics of everyday disease. Between them, they show how medical history might help us to fulfil both sides of René Dubos's most famous aphorism: ‘Think globally, act locally’.
