The influence of John Higham and Strangers in the Land on the fields of immigration, ethnic, social, and intellectual history remains unquestionable. Nativism is as relevant to the study of American history in the twenty-first century as it was in 1955, when the book first appeared. Strangers in the Land has endured as an inspiring work of scholarship not only for its substance, but also for the author's commitment “to join historical scholarship with contemporary social concern.”Footnote 2 Although he became interested in and wrote about many other subjects after the publication of Strangers in the Land, Higham continued to be concerned about the ebb and flow of nativism in the United States throughout his life. As Michael Kammen pointed out, Higham “remained exceedingly serious about the state of the nation and American society, sometimes verging upon gloom if not despair.”Footnote 3 This sense of urgency about the pervasiveness of history in the present emerged in his prologue to the 2002 edition of his book, when he wrote that he feared there was “an acrid odor of the 1920s.”Footnote 4 Fifty-five years after its publication, Strangers in the Land still conveyed the importance of its subject and inspired readers to seek an answer to Higham's fear of a resurgence of nativism.
Periodic reexaminations of Strangers in the Land since its publication pointed out the wealth of research questions that it generated every time a new reader engaged the text. As John Bodnar urged in 1991, “As we pause to reassess [Higham's] perspective . . . we should strive to learn all that there is in the book to teach us about nativism and culture and, at the same time, look for new directions that will help us to go beyond this work.”Footnote 5 For the attentive reader, Strangers in the Land perpetually suggests new research topics. I would like to focus on a few examples that tackle what the book offers to the study of social relations in a broader transnational context.
Perhaps the obvious place to start is the epilogue that Higham himself wrote in 2002 to the second reprint of his book by Rutgers University Press. He proposed two “interrelated suggestions concerning fundamental social conditions on which a new history of ethnic relations might be built.”Footnote 6 With his first suggestion, Higham asked historians to examine more thoroughly the significance that the numerical proportion between newcomers and the resident population has for the people involved. “Sudden alterations in numbers and in concentration,” he wrote, “often attract little attention in comparison with the flamboyant irrationality that can erupt whenever social constraints are weak. Yet underlying demographic changes, and new perceptions of the demographic situation, may have much wider effect.”Footnote 7 His emphasis on exploring how the perception of an immigrant threat ebbs and flows and affects social relations is particularly relevant. It represents a great starting point to probe how the perception of an immigrant threat and its connection to numbers and concentration has evolved over time, especially after the post-1965 immigration wave.
Higham's second suggestion focused on geographical mobility. In this case, he recognized the need to consider the intersection of immigration from abroad with internal migration to comprehend how the two movements overlap and diverge. How do these overlapping patterns of migration affect interactions between internal and international migrants, as well as the prospects of each group? He argues that, although immigrants often faced opposition, difficulties, and discrimination when settling in the United States, Americans' high rate of mobility in fact helped them accept new immigrants more quickly than in other receiving countries. On the other hand, he observes, African Americans undoubtedly represented the group that faced the greatest obstacles to geographical and social mobility. This, in turn, pushed them to resent “poorer minorities, who move more easily, and . . . more affluent minorities, who go anywhere they please.”Footnote 8 The comparison between immigrants' and African Americans' geographical mobility and the effects of such differences on the relationship between the two groups certainly merits more attention among immigration historians. It is also important to investigate how these dynamics became more complicated with the influx of Caribbean immigrants as well as the arrival of African immigrants and African refugees.
The presence of these newer groups of African Americans complicates any study of the intersection of immigrant and African American geographical mobility. It adds a new layer of subtlety as well as complexity to any comparative analysis of the subject. Sociologists and anthropologists have explored the inter-group dynamics within black America in recent decades and have analyzed the strain in the relationship among different groups and the competition for housing and jobs. However, scholars still know little about how these inter-group dynamics emerged and evolved over time, how the meaning that each of these groups ascribed to blackness influenced their social and geographical mobility, and how white Americans' ideas of blackness affected these newer African Americans and their life in the United States.
Higham's book also anticipated other themes that have remained largely unexplored. According to Higham, racial and ethnic hostility peaked in popular movements against Catholics, political radicals, and people of color. By highlighting the common traits in the patterns of hostility that white as well as non-white groups faced over time, Higham “helped to give pause to the assimilationist propositions advanced by Handlin just a few years earlier,” as historian Joe Trotter remarked.Footnote 9 Still, little has been written since the publication of his book to compare and contrast these popular movements against Catholics or other minority religious groups, political radicals, and people of color. A few studies have explored the parallels between the accusations of undesirability against Chinese and Italian immigrants, for example, but historians still have not really explained how exclusivist notions of religion, politics, and color fomented the inflammatory rhetoric, crude imagery, and violence unleashed against vulnerable minorities. Also, how did the different immigrant groups targeted because of religious beliefs, political ideology, and the color of their skin respond to attacks upon them? How did these attacks in turn shape their communities and their position within American society over time?
Higham contended that nativism existed “because of the disproportionate share of power that a largely white, Protestant, middle class was able to exercise in American public discourse.”Footnote 10 Although this is certainly the case for the time period on which he focused in Strangers in the Land, it would be useful to understand better the trajectory from disparaged to full-fledged American citizens that many of the immigrants in his book underwent and how that changed American society. Once the immigrants who had been targets of nativism gained political prominence, they began to influence the definition of the nation and of the meaning of being American. They appropriated the discourse to their own advantage. This meant that the definition of American nationality was still largely in the hands of white people, albeit now at times with roots in eastern and southern Europe. A follow-up to Higham's account would trace ways that nativism changed after southern and eastern Europeans entered the American mainstream and after many of them wholeheartedly embraced the “up from the boot straps” myth. How did the discourse evolve once non-white immigrants joined the mix? Did this discourse evolve much at all? Higham pointed in the right direction when, in the second edition of his book, he wrote that it was “time to study interactions, not just attitudes, and so to throw light on the overall structure of a multi-ethnic social order.”Footnote 11
In his 2002 epilogue, Higham worried that the nativism of the 1920s might be back. Despite his fear, he concluded that the twenties had not returned and that on issues of race, national identity, and nativism, “changes in American society and culture are far more significant than continuities.”Footnote 12 In light of the attacks over the succeeding decade against Arab Americans and Muslims, his conclusion certainly needs to be put to the test to verify whether nativism has indeed waned or has transformed into something else for which perhaps no adequate term has yet appeared.
Finally, as I reread Strangers in the Land, I wondered how one might expand the study of nativism over a longer span of time and into a global context. How do the patterns of nativism that Higham identified in the United States compare to strands of intolerant nationalism in other multicultural receiving nations? A transnational perspective on nativism, like recent efforts to study the global wave of immigration restriction that swept most receiving countries at the end of the nineteenth century, might reveal a great deal about how popular movements hostile to minorities in this or that country influenced the discourse in other places. This type of study could also help ascertain what generates, inflames, or tames xenophobia in different contexts and how class divisions, economic forces, psychological stress, and cultural attitudes combine to exacerbate ethnic, religious, and racial conflicts in a global context.
Like any seminal work, John Higham's Strangers in the Land raised questions that still remain unanswered. Amid a new wave of xenophobia toward immigrants in the early twenty-first century, the efforts to answer these questions take on a new sense of urgency. Higham's work gave much guidance to succeeding generations of immigration historians. His sense of purpose as a scholar also offered a model for how “to join historical scholarship with contemporary social concern.”Footnote 13
