John Collins' book is based on a subjective approach to the Palestinian youth who took part in the intifada in the late 1980s. Based on fieldwork that he carried out in 1997 in the Balata refugee camp, near Nablus, this socioanthropological investigation gives us the opportunity to confront political representations expressed by the uprising's protagonists. Assuming that young people were central political actors during the intifada, Collins considers that they incarnate a core issue of Palestinian memory and nationalism. Palestinian identity, he asserts, is reshaped by a problematic generational dimension.
Collins' original approach allows us to penetrate the intimate realm of Palestinian politics where individual experiences interact with national history and enrich it with new significance. Personal narratives related here provide us with concrete ideas about the meaning of the intifada to its protagonists as well as their conception of their role in Palestinian society and in the struggle against Israel. The author distinguishes several main “rhetorical modes” interlaced in his interviews. Heroism is a dominant mode, one that characterizes Palestinian discourses throughout the book. Participating in the intifada was an opportunity for youngsters to prove their manhood and to impose themselves in the community. Their young age at the time is a source of pride, as well as a sign of their vulnerability opposed to the powerful Israeli army. The strength of the weak is also illustrated by the character of the “mother” who manages to frighten Israeli soldiers when she confronts them in order to rescue “her children”—all of the stone throwers of her living area. Victimization is another ambiguous narrative mode. Young people refuse to consider themselves victims, because their involvement in the struggle breeds their self-esteem, yet they are tempted to emphasize their positioning as victims through testimonial when they seek to convince the world of their suffering. The author is aware that his presence as a social scientist encourages this type of nationalist narrative. Guilt is expressed by adults who realize their impotence to protect their children from occupation. Potential allows young Palestinians to imagine the future victory. In addition, empowerment describes their ability to gain authority in their own society. Rather than structural patterns, these “rhetorical modes” are different repertoires that protagonists can use alternatively or simultaneously.
Collins' approach in terms of spatial memories is an inventive and fruitful way to expose readers to strategies engaged in during the intifada, combined with the process of transformation within the public sphere. During the intifada, home and school are no longer sanctuaries of intimacy or education, because Israeli soldiers might penetrate either. Streets and schools are places of political socialization and mobilization, where young people negotiate new sets of rules or impose their choices on parents and teachers, organize strikes, and sometimes lead riots. In the views of the young activists, prison is evoked not so much in terms of Israeli repression as in the militants' space par excellence, where political education is dispensed and received.
The author is conscious of the romanticized aspect of remembering the intifada and produces an analysis of the “moral chronology” that young residents of Balata refer to and which helps them deal with the gap between the objectives and the results of the uprising. Collins argues that an unsatisfying present reinforces the idealization of the past. The uncertainties of Palestinian autonomy and the marginalization of the intifada's actors intensify their anxiety. However, despite the distance that he manages to keep from his interlocutors, Collins fails to question what he considers to be one of the central representations of the intifada generation. He acknowledges that generational unity is more a perception than an historical fact, but he still considers generation as the primary category for understanding Palestinian society during the intifada, ignoring other, more profound social and political dimensions. The social tensions that are deeply rooted in the Nablus area, especially between the urban bourgeoisie and the inhabitants of the Balata refugee camp, are barely mentioned. Little is written about antagonisms generated by rival political affiliations.
Reducing the intifada to personal narratives produces another ambiguity. In Collins' book, the uprising is portrayed essentially through stone throwing and violent confrontations with the Israeli army. The civil disobedience movement conceived by elder militants and the attempt to reach self-sufficiency in the West Bank and Gaza Strip that mobilized teachers, doctors, and engineers constitute the foundation of the uprising that is ignored completely here. Collins seems to not pay any attention to other different, multiple levels of involvement during the intifada: the elder militants, who initially organized the mobilization, the occasional stone throwers, or those activists who at some point decided to pick up guns. All of these figures melt away in Collins' vague notion of the “intifada generation.” This undifferentiated approach maintains the myth of a unanimous Palestinian mobilization, even if Collins mentions the process of fragmentation that develops under Palestinian Authority rule. In his interviews, the belief that self-interests tarnished the purity of the struggle is strong. The Palestine Liberation Organization's leadership in Tunis is often accused of having spoiled the authentic mobilization of the original intifada. How this mythical vision of the uprising affects the youth of Balata in their attempt to cope with the Palestinian Authority remains a central issue of Palestinian politics to this day.
