The publication of the Gifford Lectures by renowned thinkers is always an intellectual event. The reader turns to the volume not only with the expectation of insight into the author’s mind, but also to gain perspective on the religious tenor of our time. In this respect, and others to be mentioned, the reader will not be disappointed by Michael Welker’s slim, yet profound, book, In God’s Image: An Anthropology of the Spirit. Addressing some of the most pressing issues confronting people around the world, from justice to peace and freedom to truth, the work outlines a picture of human beings focused on the spirit. The reader is also taken into classical problems in Christian theology and is introduced to new ideas and ways of thinking about the human condition. The work aims, as Welker puts it, “at a deeper and more nuanced understanding of the human spirit and the divine Spirit as a sound basis for natural theology and theology in general” (ix). The task is nothing less than to show how humanity can be “transformed into a joyful and loving ‘image of God’” (x). Exploring how to be transformed into the image of God also provides, on Welker’ account, the grounds of ethics and the shape of life within diverse social and cultural realms. Some will be taken back by such claims about the imago Dei while others will find new energy in the theological task. Every reader, I judge, will be challenged and enlightened.
Welker is a generous thinker willing to grant and learn from the insights of others even as he mines the classics of the Christian tradition. As those familiar with Welker’s work know, he is also not the typical systematic theologian. Some in the theological guild have forsaken the insights and wisdom of the biblical texts and bequeathed them in toto to biblical scholars. Many prefer to engage contemporary or classical philosophical positions, or they support any number of liberative social movements. Welker, too, is interested in philosophical arguments and certainly the questions of justice and freedom. He is keenly sensitive to the fact that people now live in societies ordered by various subsystems where economics interacts with politics, media, education, law, and so on. If Christian theology is to speak to actual life, it must address from its own perspective the social conditions that sustain, limit, and promote life. Throughout his career, Welker has practiced what he calls a “biblical realistic theology” in relation to multisystemic thinking that aims, as well, to be a public theology. It is this combination of biblical, philosophical, and social analysis that has distinguished his work within the wide array of current theological positions.
Of course, the combination of sources that Welker draws on puts his work within and yet also outside the domain of the Gifford lectures. Established in 1888 by Adam Lord Gifford to focus on so-called natural theology, the lectures are open to anyone who wishes to think about the divine. Welker seeks in his lectures to develop an anthropology of the spirit that, at least initially, brackets the central Christian conviction that God is revealed in Jesus Christ (1). And yet the same commitment to biblical theology would seem to place Welker beyond the Gifford Lectures’ domain. The Bible, and so revealed theology, is usually thought in opposition to natural theology. Welker’s first task is to clarify his approach in the lectures, one that conforms to Lord Gifford’s wishes, and so makes no appeal to “so-called miraculous revelation” (1), while also drawing on biblical materials. How does he meet this challenge, since, logically, he must, by the terms of the Gifford Lectures, work within the conceptual space constituted by the lectures themselves?
Welker’s response to this challenge moves within what we could call a general apologetics for his approach to theology. One thinks here of Friedrich Schleiermacher’s On Religion: Speeches to its Cultured Despisers (1799) or even St. Augustine’s apology The City of God. The apologetic task is to get a hearing from those who negate Christian faith and then, in a crucial move, show how this faith is of greater depth and interpretive power than culturally prevalent positions. Welker undertakes this task in terms of method, or how to think theologically, and what can and must be said substantively about human existence in relation to the spirit. In terms of method, Welker draws on social and cultural realities, including the biblical traditions that can be examined and interpreted from various perspectives (such as historical, philosophical, religious) and construes natural theology as a form of realistic theology. By this designation Welker means a theology that seeks to understand the actual realities and operative powers within which we exist. In this way, he subverts the distinction between natural and revealed theology by opening reflection to a host of sources.
In terms of method, Welker can then examine the multiple social subsystems interacting in contemporary societies and the possibilities and limitations they place on life. Deeply influenced by thinkers as diverse as Alfred North Whitehead, Talcott Parsons, and Niklas Luhmann, social and cultural life, as noted, is interpreted through various interacting subsystems and cultural forms each with its own norms, values, purposes, and communicative forms. Not surprisingly, then, when Welker in chapters 3–6 turns to explore the human calling to justice, freedom, truth, and peace, each is correlate to a domain of human social and cultural life. And in each case, Welker both engages relevant thinkers and social movements and shows how each calling is interwoven reflexively with the others. With this emphasis on calling, or Berufung in German, Welker harkens back to Luther and Calvin and their understanding of Christian life as a vocation lived out in interacting estates. While the Reformers tended to think of three estates—Family, Church, and State—Welker has updated and nuanced the idea. Call the method a hermeneutical one, broadly conceived, that also enunciates the norm and value requisite in a human society and the social spheres within which we exist.
What then about the substance of what can be said concerning the imago Dei? Throughout his career Welker has been interested, first, in German Idealism during his student days, and so Kant, Fichte, Hegel, focused on Geist (spirit or mind) only later to find in the biblical tradition a much richer and less self-referential and so other-regarding idea of spirit.
Yet Welker does draw from Hegel an insight into the multimodal character of spirit.
Multimodal, he notes, means “several contact possibilities” between people and, say, a business or in media when information is delivered not “by way of a single medium such as a text but through other media as well” (24). From that interpretive perspective, the multimodal spirit is “operative not only in human minds but also in a multitude of historical and cultural environments” (43). And, further, the divine and human spirits, so conceived, “gain contours in their work for justice, for freedom, for truth, and for peace” (43).
So understood, the divine and human multimodal spirits work against forces that endanger and brutalize human life and thereby threaten the image of God. Further, humans can be transformed into the image of God when responding to their callings of justice, freedom, truth, and peace. The divine spirit is operative within reality for those same goods. Here we should think in terms of multipolar power where a “given constellation (of people, social entities or even an arrangement of nerve cells) possesses several centers or poles” (24). Again, with this interpretive lens one can decode the complexity of actual life without reduction to simple one-to-one relations (I-Thou; God-human; Church-World) or some vague abstraction, say divine mystery. The divine spirit empowers emergent movements and processes that are “always conducive to life” (27). The claim, then, is that God’s spirit and the human spirit are cooperative in social environments and institutions with their callings. In a real sense, we live, move, and have our being in the divine spirit through the multiple systems and cultural forms that structure life and the callings that are the human vocation (see Acts 17:28). Human beings are to cooperate with the divine spirit in the work of justice, freedom, truth, and peace countering forces that endanger life. In this way, the human spirit is “transformed into a joyful and loving ‘image of God’” (x).
In the central books in Welker’s corpus (God the Spirit; God the Revealed: Christology; and In God’s Image: An Anthropology of the Spirit), Welker takes as his theological base point the complex biblical picture of the working and outpouring of the divine spirit in creation, revelation, and human existence. Why is this shift from a purely philosophical conception of spirit to one found within the biblical traditions important and fruitful? It is fruitful, Welker suggests precisely because the biblical traditions, in the plural, encode manifold different human experiences of spirit in different times and sociocultural contexts and thus provides some means for us to read our own pluriform social situation. Further, as intimated above, the biblical account of spirit and its outpouring is not trapped in self-referential relation (I am I) or even a dyadic one (I-Thou) but is operative in many modes for the sake of the enhancement and ennoblement of life.
There is, in a word, a cognitive gain by looking beyond a philosophical tradition, reaching back to the ancient Greeks, that focuses on thought thinking itself. The move to the biblical traditions with a multisystemic social and cultural analysis and a multimodal and multipolar understanding of the Spirit is then important precisely because it avoids reducing the divine or the human spirit simply to a relation of oneself with oneself. It is a profoundly social vision of spirit oriented towards what we might call the work of the spirit: justice, freedom, truth, peace. This means that the “natural-theological perspectives on the shaping of human beings in the image of God can also be articulated with respect to secular contexts” (130). Natural theology and “revealed” theology are rethought in a way that renders the distinction mute.
A brief review such as this one cannot explore in detail Welker’s treatments of justice, freedom, truth, and peace. These chapters are packed with insights, and Welker engages key thinkers, theories, and ideas around each of the human callings. The joy of exploring these chapters is best left to readers. Yet in concluding, I note one theme that I believe is fundamental in Welker’s thought.
What do I mean? On Welker’s account, “nature” and “life” are inappropriate predicates for the divine and human spirits. This is because for him they are vitalist concepts, that is, concepts that denote the brutal struggle of living things through predation, conflict, the endless working of the will-to-power in a zero-sum game. Life lives off life. One can certainly grant this point. Life qua life is not sacred, rather it is the spirit of life or (as I have treated the topic) the integrity of life that is theologically and ethically focal. One ought not to reverence life as such. From this theme about nature and life flow three possibilities or challenges, depending on how they are seen.
First, Welker’s proper rejection of vitalism seems, at times, to lead him to a rejection of “natural law” ethics because he thinks it just means a justification of the laws of nature, as he sees them. But, of course, natural law is not just the basic laws of nature, especially about procreation. Properly it means the human capacity to know, however vaguely, some basic moral principles, like justice. Luther, Calvin, and many others thought that the natural law was republished in the Decalogue, the Ten Commandments, given our dimmed capacity to grasp it due to sin. Nevertheless, part of human dignity is precisely to know, to sense, that justice, peace, freedom, and truth resonate with our created being. As I read him, Welker is reworking the idea through the multimodal spirit of justice (chapter 3). This should prompt theologians who focus on ethical and political issues to think anew about publicly accessible and yet theologically viable claims to justice reworking the idea of natural law.
Second, Welker’s account of nature and life leads him to define love as “free creative self-limitation and self-withdrawal on behalf of others” (122). The claim is that “a vital energy and a life beyond the usual understanding of natural vital energy, which is inherently and indispensably linked to self-continuation and self-preservation” is possible (122, emphasis added). At issue is whether Welker means the divine spirit is not active within natural life processes. If not, what does this means theologically? Is the natural world somehow opposed to the spiritual world? That would be an odd conclusion. Realistically, it would seem, we must admit the reality of both deadly competition and sustaining cooperation in living realities. How might that inform a realistic theology? Possibilities seem opened here for a nuanced realistic environmental theology that avoids naïve ideas about harmonious life while also escaping a cynicism about living processes.
Third, Welker’s account of love, a reality and concept basic to Christian theology and ethics, seems to respond as well to the threat of vitalism in nature and life. He argues that “the capacity to transcend one’s own life burdens in creative self-withdrawal on behalf of others provides a powerful source of experiential joy and profound inner peace” (128). Welker contrasts this with benevolence and sacrificial accounts of love. But it is crucial, in my judgement, that Welker stresses free and creative self-withdrawal. Without those qualifications one might end with an account of love bound to endless self-sacrifice, coerced service for others, or, say with Schopenhauer, the demand to still the will-to-life for the sake of others. It is not clear, at least to this reader, what this means for proper self-regard, to love the neighbor as oneself, unless the joy and peace in self-withdrawal for others is a form of self-regard. Maybe, under the calling to peace, he is contrasting Christian love (agape or caritas) with other forms of love such that within the power of the divine spirit this love becomes possible and ennobling to self and others. Welker tends to define moral in terms of giving or denying respect. Could it possibly be that Christian love denies the claim of self-respect? One must pause and reflect further, I judge, lest an account of love be open to manipulation and self-deprecation, as feminist theologians have long worried. So, a possibility for further reflection also signals a real challenge.
I hope the above comments are an account and assessment of Welker’s apology for biblical realistic theology and his interpretation of the divine spirit and how human beings can be transformed into the image of God. The text displays the power of Welker’s thought in reconfiguring natural theology with respect to human existence. It also provides key insights into our present reality and the ways in which our social and natural lives are endangered, the abyss of existence as he calls it. This book provokes new avenues of thought. In sum, Welker has not only fulfilled the demands of the Gifford Lectures but also the reader’s expectations. It is hoped that this slim volume will enjoy the wide readership it warrants.
