This handsomely produced volume is a revised version of Cristina Murer's University of Amsterdam 2013 dissertation, written under the direction of Emily Hemelrijk as part of a larger research project entitled ‘Hidden Lives – Public Personae: Women in the Urban Texture of the Roman Empire’. The study explores the questions of when, where and why female citizens were given honorific statues in the cities of Italy and North Africa. Display location — that is, the question of where — is the primary concern and was therefore the guiding principle by which the statues M. focuses on were chosen. While display context has sometimes been considered in previous scholarship on honorific portrait statuary, this is the first study to take location within the urban landscape as the main axis of analysis. With its focus on the archaeological evidence, M.’s book nicely complements and can be read as a companion volume to Hemelrijk's recent 2015 monograph, Hidden Lives, Public Personae: Women and Civic Life in the Roman West.
Ch. 1 deals with the history of scholarship on female portrait statuary, and lays out the aims and methods of the study. As the main focus is where in the cities of Italy and North Africa the portrait statues of women were displayed, M. must necessarily limit her sample to those few statues, at least in relation to the corpus as a whole, whose display location can be reconstructed with some degree of certainty. M. is forthright about the limitations of the evidence, as most ancient portrait statues and the bases on which they stood were moved from their original display locations in the late antique and post-antique periods. She focuses, therefore, on just thirty-two statues from six urban sites in Italy and North Africa (Pompeii, Tusculum, Herculaneum, Ostia, Leptis Magna, Bulla Regia); in twelve of these cases, the identity of the portrait subject is also known.
Ch. 2, ‘Ein Neubeginn im Westen?’, is a very brief account of the practice of setting up portraits of women in the Hellenistic East, both individually and as part of family group monuments, and the early occurrence in the East, from the early first century b.c., of including statues of Roman women next to those of their male relatives who served as proconsuls in the eastern Mediterranean. The earliest female statues in Italy were also set up within the context of family group monuments, beginning in about the 40s b.c.; individual honorific statues for woman first appear in the Roman West in the early Augustan period. Comparison of honorific practices in the Hellenistic East with what develops in the cities of Italy and North Africa, including display location and statue type, is returned to in the following chapters.
Chs 3 and 4 represent the bulk of the study. Ch. 3 focuses on Italy, with in-depth case studies of particular locations in the cities of Pompeii, Tusculum, Herculaneum and Ostia. Ch. 4 deals primarily with two cities in North Africa: Leptis Magna and Bulla Regia. Both chapters conclude with broader surveys of the evidence for statues of women in Italy and North Africa from the first century b.c. to the fourth century a.d. From this evidence, the following patterns emerge. For Italy, statues of women, even those of the imperial family, were hardly ever set up on the forum in the early imperial period; it was not until the later first century and especially in the second century that honorific portraits of women first began to appear in this prestigious location. Statues of women were, however, set up in buildings in the immediate vicinity of the forum in the early imperial period; these buildings tended to be financed either by the women themselves or by members of their family. Female portrait statues were also set up in cult buildings and in theatres, but only rarely it would seem in bath-houses. In North Africa, the bulk of the honorific practice seems to start a bit later, in the second century, and continues into the third, when the setting up of female honorific statues appears to be on the wane in the cities of Italy. The contexts of display, however, seem to be mostly the same in both Italy and North Africa, although statues of women are found in North African bath buildings.
As for statue types, the earliest honorific statues from Italy repeat hellenistic statue types: the so-called Pudicitia and the Small Herculaneum type are popular in the early imperial period. New types that are not dependent on those from the Hellenistic East, such as the Eumachia/Fundilla type, emerge in the Julio-Claudian period, but by the late first century, the Large and Small Herculaneum and Ceres types dominate the repertoire for the statues of both non-imperial and imperial women. In North Africa, local preferences can be seen in the popularity of the Large Herculaneum type in Leptis Magna, from which eight of the known thirteen examples come. The Ceres type, which is very popular in North Africa in general and Bulla Regia in particular, was not used for any female portrait statues in Leptis Magna. In both Italy and North Africa, M. sees little if any difference between the types of female statues set up in public urban contexts and those that stood in the cemeteries, a distinction that is sometimes made in earlier scholarship.
Perhaps one of the most interesting observations to arise out of this contextual study is the impact that different display contexts appear to have had on the appearance of the female portrait head. M. argues that the facial features of those female statues set up within the context of family groups (cat. nos 3, 4, 7) are characterised by strongly individualising traits that emphasise the subject's age; these portraits do not follow the period face of the reigning empress and they do not wear contemporary fashion hairstyles. In contrast, the female statues set up on their own, outside of family groups (cat. nos 1, 11, 12, 27), tend to have idealising facial features and to wear either imperial or hellenistic fashion hairstyles. As the number of examples here is limited, it would be interesting to see if additional evidence can be gathered in support of this interesting hypothesis.
In addition to the catalogue, there is a helpful appendix of additional material comprising 157 entries, including statue-base inscriptions, female portrait statues whose original display location is not known, disembodied portrait heads, funerary statues and statues from houses and villas. A series of tables organises this material in a variety of interesting and informative ways, while providing a rich resource for future research.
