In the past decade, there has been a great deal of interest in religion and American foreign policy, as well as a renewed look at the varied ways in which religion has influenced the American past. This has brought President Woodrow Wilson, one of the most religious past presidents, back into the mainstream consciousness and provided a new way to look at Wilsonian idealism in international history. Religious historian Cara Burnidge's book does this and so much more.
To call this a short book does a disservice to the content that has been packed into its few, highly readable pages. Burnidge writes with a scholarly beauty that makes this book as hard to put down as a popular novel. In these pages the reader will not only find an exquisite reexamination of Woodrow Wilson's policies and life, but a sweepingly detailed understanding of American religion in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. This book is a “must read,” not just for scholars of Wilson, but also for scholars of American religion, as well as U.S. and international history in general.
Burnidge does not flinch from examining the failures of Wilson, his flawed progressivism, or the shortcomings of Wilson's co-religionists. As she criticizes, however, she contextualizes. We are left with an understanding of missed opportunities on issues such as racial and gender equality, both nationally and internationally, but also of why the otherwise visionary president was blind to these issues. She deals not just with race in the domestic area, where Wilson clearly fell far short of understanding equality, but also how he negotiated his complicated views internationally with nations such as Japan during the Paris Peace Conference (99). Despite his many flaws, Wilson managed to change the international discussion, laid the foundation for later decolonization, and introduced a new way of doing business between nations. The same reasoning made him progressive and conservative on different issues. For Wilson, religion “was a source of social order and cohesion” (101). That order could be progressive or not, depending upon the circumstances. In many ways, Wilson's religion was his opiate (44). When faced with a contradiction, he was able to reconcile both his progressive and regressive tendencies in the mystery of Providence. Burnidge does a remarkable job of dealing with this complicated man in a humane and sympathetic manner, allowing Wilson's brilliance to shine and making his failures understandable to the modern reader.
The book contextualizes the great Protestant schisms in American popular imagination during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries; and how the Treaty of Versailles, with its League of Nations, exposed those fault lines. In doing so, Burnidge makes a compelling case that the battle over the League of Nations in the Senate was the early breaking point between the modernists of the nineteenth century and the conservatives and fundamentalists of the twentieth century. This debate was the precursor to later domestic battles such as the Scopes Monkey Trial. American Christian unity was already fragmented and the Senate debate exposed that fragmentation.
This short work does much more than giving us an understanding of Wilson and Wilsonian politics. Burnidge provides insight into the religious views of many other contemporary actors and their impact on the political culture of the nation. The book explains the religious view and prejudices of Theodore Roosevelt, William Howard Taft, Henry Cabot Lodge, and many others. Their background is provided in a tight, neat context. Surprisingly absent is John R. Mott, a key player in international Christianity at the time, but Mott's absence is more than remedied by the detail with which this book covers its many other subjects.
Burnidge leaves us with an understanding of the religious background for the main international views that have played themselves out in the public square during the last century. Views of international relations, which range from idealistic nation building and realpolitik to the recurring “America First” movements in modern politics, are shown to spring originally from some form of religious understanding of America's role in the world (46–47). Though the scholarship of the last decade should have put that controversy to rest, this remains a controversial view for some. Burnidge has done much to further strengthen and clarify this case.
Scholars should seriously consider this work for upper undergraduate courses in American History; it should be required reading for graduate students studying late nineteenth and early twentieth century history, and anyone who wants a general understanding about modern U.S. international policy should take the time to read it. Seldom does one have the opportunity to read a book that is as satisfying as this one. It is an opportunity that should not be missed.
