Rebecca Stephens Falcasantos traces the development of Constantinople's religious landscape from the foundation of the city by Constantine until the death of Theodosios II. She focuses on three key dynamics: the impact of contention and violence in a religiously ambiguous environment; the ‘importance of communal ritual action’ in creating social structures and group identities; and the ‘curation of memory’ in the attempt to establish Constantinople as Christian capital and shape a specific idea of orthodox Christianity.
Ch. 1 assesses the governing principles and characteristics of civic religion in the Roman Empire. The author's main aim is to emphasise that the shift from traditional religion towards Christianity was in no way sudden or abrupt, but a gradual process, and to stress the continuity with traditional patterns of religion. Christian practices could look quite similar to the practices of the traditional cults, but cultural agents — most often members of the learned elite — took it as their challenge to point out the differences through rhetorical constructs. These elite actors, and how they effected a process of reframing cultural expectations, are F.'s focus in the following chapters.
In ch. 2, F. seeks to challenge the idea of Constantinople having been founded as a Christian capital, and instead stresses that the city was full of traditionalist, ‘pagan’ resonances. Constantine's new monuments drew on Greek and Roman heritage and were in line with established patterns of imperial sponsorship. Under Constantine, F. argues, Constantinople was a religiously ambiguous space and the emperor's presence was anything but exclusively Christian. His statue on the Forum Constantini received cultic veneration and his mausoleum, the Apostoleion, could be interpreted in traditional as well as Christian terms. It was Christian thinkers like Eusebios of Caesarea who struggled to collapse this ambiguity by imposing Christian meaning on Constantinople's urban landscape and presenting Constantine as outstanding example of Christian piety.
In ch. 3, F. explores the intersection between violence, the politics of memory and the creation of group identities. In the decades after Constantine's death, Christian elites managed to assert themselves more clearly in the urban cultic space; by then, the main lines of religious competition in Constantinople ran between opposing Christian parties. F. focuses on the violent conflict between two contenders for the position of bishop of Constantinople, the Nicene Paul and the Arian Makedonios. She traces both the conflict itself, in the mid-fourth century, and its memorialisation by the fifth-century church historians Sokrates and Sozomenos, who were staunch advocates for what F. calls ‘Theodosian Christianity,’ firmly rooted in the Nicene creed. Violence — both real and memorialised — is identified as a means of reshaping Constantinople's religious landscape. While group distinctions were often fluid in practice, rhetorically trained actors tried to impose (imagined) boundaries between groups and claim ownership over Constantinople's religious space.
Ch. 4 explores the impact of rituals in the reshaping of religious structures, focusing on John Chrysostom's tenure as bishop of Constantinople. Religious rituals were just one of many spectacles that structured the civic life of a late antique city. F. stresses that the similarity and even ‘citationality’ between different kind of rituals created a degree of fluidity, but also allowed for modifications and reinterpretations which could affect shifts in the civic identity, group values and hierarchies. She shows how John Chrysostom made attempts to gain control over the city's ritual environment and to counteract religious diversity. Through a combination of rhetoric and physical intervention in ritual practice, John sought to impose his idea of orthodoxy on the civic space and tried to gloss over competing commitments in the civic body.
In ch. 5, F. turns to the reign of Theodosios II with the premise that Theodosios could not resort to the traditional means of securing imperial power, due to his young age at the time of his father Arkadios’ death. Instead, his public image was based on Christian piety. As core characteristic of Theodosios’ reign F. highlights the efforts to strengthen religious conformity and to remove unwanted religious elements from Constantinople, a process that she interprets as contributing to legitimise the reign of a maturing emperor. Theodosian Christianity was, according to F., ‘a solution to imperial insecurity’. Efforts to marginalise non-Theodosian religious groups, aiming at creating an imperial Christian identity, can also be traced in the fifth-century historiographers Philostorgios, Sokrates and Sozomenos, for whom Theodosios’ ascetic piety guaranteed the stability of the empire.
F. convincingly traces how Constantinople developed from a religiously ambiguous city into the navel of Theodosian orthodoxy. Her book not only displays a clear structure and argument but is also enjoyable to read. What stands out is the author's ability to connect in-depth analysis of specific events or sources with more abstract analysis of, for example, the formation of group identities, drawing on sociological and anthropological research. One might, however, criticise her neglect of recent Germanophone research on late antique Constantinople, which could have further supported her argument, such as the work of Johannes Wienand on Constantine, Steffen Diefenbach on imperial piety and Rene Pfeilschifter on the emperor in Constantinople. All in all, her competent analysis provides new impetus to our understanding of the dynamics that shaped the capital of the East Roman Empire, appealing to ancient historian, Byzantinists and historians of religion alike.
