My theatre history students often ask, “How exactly can we know the audience's response to a play?” A similar question is at the heart of Heim's semiethnographic study, Audience as Performer. Heim argues that twenty-first century mainstream theatre audience members are underexamined and underappreciated coperformers in the shows they attend. Their unique and complex collaborations with actors and front of house staff bear many hallmarks of nineteenth-century theatre etiquette and consumption, while also moving into new arenas of twenty-first century “co-creation” assisted by new technologies that push experience and discourse well beyond the theatre building (146). For Heim, much previous scholarship regarding audience response has neglected “ordinary” theatregoers or has conflated them with “integral” audience members (terms borrowed from Richard Schechner), such as critics, whose participation is marked by a theatre-specific educational background, industry training, or employment context (7).
To bridge this gap, Heim places the “ordinary” audience's articulation of their subjective experiences alongside those of actors whose own nebulous but tangible codependence on audience response drives their performances. A professional actor prior to her academic career, Heim asserts her embodied authority regarding the circuit of “electric air” passing through actor, audience, and front of house worker that is unique to live theatre (145–7). She reinforces her claims through her own first-person accounts; arranged and impromptu interviews of individual performers, ushers, and audience members; group audience questionnaires/surveys; and postshow discussion experiences and her own facilitation of the same. She conducted this research in New York, London, Sydney, Toronto, Chicago, and Glasgow during the 2013–14 season (8). These are Western cities with large, mainstream, English-speaking theatre industries, and Heim is transparent about names, locations, dates, and her desire to achieve a “reasonably wide demographic” (10) in her research. Heim chooses not to interview audience members whose coperformance in the theatrical event is sought specifically—for example, attendees of Punchdrunk's Sleep No More—because that work requires audience members to “relinquish[ ] their role as audience” and take on “the role of actor in the onstage play,” a role that is “under the direction of theatre professionals” (5). Instead, Heim wants to capture “spontaneous contributions of a theatre audience,” contributions directed by their unique enactment of their roles as audience members (5). These experiences are marginalized in theatre history even as, perhaps ironically, the “ordinary” audience members of large, Western, English-speaking mainstream theatres dominate the landscape of twenty-first-century theatre industry concerns.
Heim spends the first part of her book recounting theatre's disciplining measures over actors and audience members from 1800 to 2000. These measures took a particular hold, she argues, with the introduction of electric lighting in New York and London theatres, which put the audience in the dark and thus changed who was being seen/heard and who was looking/hearing. As a result, etiquette management shifted from a focus on actor conduct to audience conduct. Lively communities of copresence were “anesthetised,” and “demonstrative audience performance” was curtailed severely (76). In the second part of the book, she ties these historical features to contemporary mainstream audience's coperformance, community building, and critical repertoire: from physiological responses, such as crying, laughing, applauding, jeering, and policing the behavior of one's neighbors, to social role management and the audience's consciousness of their role in the event. Audience members, she argues, coperform by selecting specific costumes to wear; by vocalizing allegiance as followers of a particular actor or character type; by using props such as hats, handkerchiefs, mementos and tokens sold by the theatre, or even one's smartphone, to mark personal communities within the larger audience or to insert oneself into the event (via a surreptitious selfie or in more direct collaboration with the theatre's online and social media marketing engines); and by writing their own critiques (now via Internet platforms instead of private diaries) to encourage or discourage one's own “public” of followers from attending a show.
From this history, she excludes audiences of “Variety theatre, Vaudeville, Minstrel shows, Burlesque, Pantomime and Opera” (44), just as in her contemporary research she excludes “non-English-speaking European, Asian, Indian, African, South American and Middle Eastern audiences” and theatres (10). Heim's interest is in audiences of “mainstream theatre” (10), a mainstream that for Broadway is, according to 2015–16 demographics from the Broadway League (www.broadwayleague.com/research/research-reports/), white, mid-40s, female, and a tourist from another US state. She conducted her contemporary research at “state theatre companies, large performing-arts centres, commercial theatres and subscription theatres that were predominantly attended by the general public” (11, emphasis mine). It seems important to remember, however, that each of those entities constructs a specific “public” through factors such as how its performances are funded, where within its city the theatre is located, its ticket prices, and the plays it programs, among others.
I appreciate Heim's conception of audience as coperformer. Although she argues her book “introduces the concept of the audience as performer” (1), the idea that roles of “audience” and “actor” are fungible across performances in everyday life, as well as those that circulate around a formal performance event, is a performance studies truism. What is more significantly innovative is Heim's turn to qualitative measures such as participant observation, interviews, and group discussions—moves supported by her invocation of theorists whose work frequently populates performance studies syllabi, notably Mikhail Bakhtin, Michel de Certeau, Erving Goffman, Jean-Paul Sartre, and Richard Schechner. As the book moved apace through its ideas in Part II, I wished that Heim had chosen deeper, longer fieldwork investigations, perhaps at one of three theatrical houses where she examines individual case studies only briefly (New York's Signature Theatre, Chicago's Steppenwolf Theatre Company, and London's Shakespeare's Globe) or at the tourist crossroads of Times Square, which she discusses at the end of Chapter 6, “Audience as Consumer.” The fact that she concludes her research prior to Lin-Manuel Miranda's Hamilton and its cultural impact suggests there is much more to be written, taking Heim's thesis of audience as cocreator and her interview and fieldwork methodologies into new contexts.
