Peter Boag, Columbia Chair in the history of the American West at Washington State University, has made a significant addition to the new histories of the Old West. Focusing on the elimination of cross-dressers from the Western frontier narrative, he demonstrates that people dressing and living as the opposite sex were much more common than historians have suggested, and he provides a logical argument as to why and how Americans erased them from the frontier memory. Although newspapers abounded with stories of both overt and covert male and female cross-dressers in the nineteenth century, and frontier towns seemed to have generally accepted the presence of such individuals, by the turn of the century people had become uncomfortable with those who did not fit into increasingly rigid categories of gender and sexuality. Influenced by awareness of new research into sexuality and concerned about challenges to traditional gender roles during the rise of industrialization, reports increasingly focused on cross-dressers' sexual as well as gender transgressions and targeted them as “unnatural.” In part one, Boag focuses on the stories of frontier people with chapters on female-to-male and male-to-female cross-dressers. In part two he analyzes the process by which they disappeared from historical accounts, with chapters on the transformation of stories about women cross-dressers, the marginalization of male cross-dressers, and the influence of new sexologists in classifying cross-dressers as exceptions on the frontier rather than part of the general narrative.
To reconcile memory with the mythical version of the frontier that was developing as rejuvenator of masculinity, newspaper accounts marginalized male cross-dressers by emphasizing any ethnic or class distinctions that categorized them as less manly by contemporary standards. It was even simpler to erase cross-dressing women, as people tended to believe they dressed as men only on exigency, either to earn more money or simply to travel safely. Once the frontier passed there was no longer need for such action, and thus women cross-dressers disappeared into what Boag calls the “progress narrative,” with only colorful stories remaining of jilted women dressing as men to defend their honor or to exact revenge on a runaway lover.
As the author clearly shows, however, such rationalizations simply do not account for the sheer numbers of people who chose to cross-dress in their daily lives, nor do they explain every case. The first strength of the work is Boag's evidence for the existence of large numbers of cross-dressers in the West who, while openly discussed in newspaper accounts, have vanished from the historical narrative. Although there have been previous studies of cross-dressing women in the military or in major cities such as San Francisco, Boag shows the frequency with which papers from frontier towns across the West reported such cases.
Relying heavily on these newspaper accounts but bolstered by medical case studies, Boag uncovers many examples for both genders. Usually the unveiling of both male and female cross-dressers came as a result of death or illness, but occasionally resulted from the suspicions of a town official or jailer. Women seemed to have been the most successful at gender masquerades, often living unchallenged as men and in many cases marrying other women. Some of these wives stayed with their cross-dressing partners even after they were publicly unmasked. Many women, when arrested for impersonating men, simply moved to a new town and assumed a new name but did not change their dress or behavior. Boag lists fewer examples of successful secret male cross-dressers, although still many more than most historians have discovered in the past, including the startling story of “Mrs. Nash,” a laundress with the Seventh Cavalry who married three times and was not discovered to be biologically male until her death.
What is striking, however, is Boag's accounts of those who openly cross-dressed, including professional female impersonators who, as entertainers, seemed to have earned a certain leeway in acting offstage as they did onstage, as long as they did not try to foist themselves on other men too openly. Boag also includes more well-known stories of women like “Babe Bean” of Stockton, California, who lived openly as a woman in male attire and conducted business without harassment. More commonly, the women who dressed openly as men moved in criminal circles, though their decision to cross-dress may have preceded their association with these groups rather than come as a result of it. For the most part, however, both men and women who overtly cross-dressed lived outside “respectable” society, though again cause and effect are not clear in this regard.
The second strength of this book is the author's ability to synthesize and contextualize the experiences of cross-dressers and the responses to them. Drawing on recent work on gender and sexuality both in and out of the West, Boag forms a clear argument about the “heteronormalization” of the frontier. Earlier stories about the West tended to frame cross-dressers as part of the frontier's colorful nature, almost the natural result of gender imbalances and rough humor. At the turn of the century, with the arrival of new anxieties about overcivilization causing effeminacy and women challenging gender barriers in the workplace and voting booth on the East Coast, increasingly public figures touted the rugged frontier as the antidote, finding it easier to ignore gender transgressions there as atypical. They found allies in the new sexologists who focused on the sexuality of cross-dressers as much as the gender transgression, defining them as physical anomalies and mentally unsound. Conveniently removing cross-dressers from the frontier narrative allowed a simpler story to emerge of sexual and moral rejuvenation for Anglos in contrast to weaker races. Thus the progress narrative evolved, one which even modern scholars of gender have clung to in the case of female cross-dressers.
There are some weaknesses in the work. Historians may note that the dates and locations of the examples stretch both timing and concept of the frontier a little far, and that examples often skip around between decades. At times the author spends more time discussing women than men, and indeed the argument surrounding the rationalization of women cross-dressers is much stronger. One wishes Boag had used more sources on masculinity and the West rather than just homosexuality. The discussion of race and masculinity could also be stronger. Nonetheless, what he has accomplished is a significant step to organizing the evidence into a new narrative that both greatly enhances understanding of historical concepts of gender and restores important elements to the Western historical narrative.
