Belizean historiography will never be the same again. In From Colony to Nation, Anne Macpherson draws on archival records and interviews she conducted with women activists who participated in political struggles in Belize across the twentieth century to challenge many standard assumptions of Belizean historiography. As the first scholar to apply a gendered analysis to Belizean history, Macpherson convincingly demonstrates how deeply gendered was the process of making a Belizean nation. Two key dimensions to this process are marked in the book's subtitle: first, that women played significant roles as activists within the two most influential political currents of twentieth-century Belize, colonial middle-class reform projects and popular labour-nationalism; and second, that gender constructs have been central to struggles over political power in Belize.
Beyond its significance to scholarship on Belize or the Caribbean, the book also makes theoretical interventions of much broader importance. Two theoretical strategies are notable in this regard. The first is Macpherson's theorisation of agency. Locating herself within an emerging tradition of feminist historiography that attributes both complexity and nuance to women's historical and political agency, Macpherson seeks to explore possibilities for subaltern and female agency without ‘constructing new heroic or teleological narratives of emancipation’ (p. 9). Thus, she examines the historical conditions, initiatives and limitations out of which both popular and middle-class women's political subjectivities emerged in Belize, recognising the ways that women's agency is constituted – both enabled and constrained – by particular historical contexts and social locations, rather than positing ‘an impossibly autonomous or pure resistance’ (pp. 10–11). The second is Macpherson's theorisation of hegemony, which, following Gramsci, focuses on the contested processes through which political subjects and political alliances are formed. In Macpherson's analysis, hegemony is ‘rule achieved through alliance, negotiation, and struggle rather than through total consent or accession to the dominant ideology’; it is ‘sustained by a constant testing and relegitimation of an always contingent and partial moral-political authority that is vulnerable to subversion from within and attack from without’ (p. 11). Accordingly, the book explores the intent, workings and achievements of political projects that attempted to articulate variously positioned groups of people into effective alliances.
Thus, in addition to producing the first study of women's political participation in twentieth-century Belizean politics, Macpherson's work also provides a more nuanced analysis of the political agency of popular and middle-class actors generally. She avoids facile characterisations of popular actors as either heroic or quiescent, ‘exploring instead how subaltern actors negotiated, adapted, manipulated, and resisted, without ever achieving total unity or gaining complete autonomy’ (p. 7). Similarly, she argues that middle-class reformers have typically been misunderstood either as more radical and anti-colonial than they really were or as ‘mere mimic men’. Macpherson ‘restores to them … a more complex and nuanced subjectivity and agency’ (p. 7).
For example, she examines efforts by middle-class creoles to forge and sustain an alliance with the colonial state across much of the twentieth century, in which women reformers played key roles as ‘maternalist uplifters of poor mothers’ (p. 73). While middle-class women's charitable and community service had not previously been understood as political, Macpherson argues that ‘their interventions in the name of proper motherhood’ were not ‘altruistic acts performed outside the dynamics of power but rather racialised efforts to control subaltern women and to detach them from their alliances with anti-colonial leaders and movements’ (p. 279). While such reform projects were ‘hegemonic in intent’, they were unable to forge the populist connections necessary to establishing hegemony. Through these efforts, however, middle-class women did succeed in establishing the legitimacy of women's political voices and activism within the colonial reform current in Belizean politics (p. 280).
On the other hand, the strength of the popular labour-nationalist tradition, embodied in the Laborers and Unemployed Association (LUA) of the 1930s and the Peoples United Party (PUP)–General Workers Union alliance of the 1950s, depended in large part on the activism of working-class women. Pursuing complex, somewhat contradictory goals, they negotiated with colonial authorities to meet ‘popular expectations of paternal state care’, but they also mobilized for ‘citizen and worker rights and for a national state that would meet their demands’ (p. 280). In both the LUA and the PUP, popular-class women threw their support behind the male leaders most responsive to their demands, shaping the leadership of both movements. Yet, Macpherson points out, ‘LUA women imagined – and struggled for – a society in which male leaders held themselves accountable to an organized and enfranchised female electorate, not one in which women shared ultimate political authority with men’ (p. 120). For their part, the leaders of the PUP ‘always sustained a tension between mobilizing and responding to women on the one hand, and containing, condescending to, and domesticating them on the other’ (p. 218).
Asserting that gender has been central to the production of the Belizean nation, Macpherson acknowledges that this centrality has been complex and contradictory: ‘While the modern state, colonial or national, has developed as an institution of hegemonic masculine authority, it has maintained that authority not only by forging vertical alliances with men, alliances that have reproduced female exclusion and/or subordination but also, and sometimes simultaneously, by incorporating politically active women's demands and expectations into its rhetoric and practice’ (p. 12). And while women activists ‘partially succumbed to paternalistic party clientelism … they also made nationalist legitimacy in part contingent on recognizing women's rights and working to solve their problems’ (p. 280). Indeed, it was the failure of successive PUP administrations to solve these problems that finally led to the emergence of Belizean feminism and autonomous women's organising (p. 280).
Macpherson's book will become required reading for scholars of Belize and an important interlocutor for scholarship on the Caribbean. Well beyond these audiences, however, Macpherson's nuanced approach to agency and hegemony position this book as an important contribution to scholarship on colonialism and anti-colonialism, resistance and accommodation, and the production of political subjectivities and political alliances more generally.
